Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

"Please breastfeed"

111 replies

hunkermunker · 15/04/2009 21:14

I saw the slogan "Please give blood" today on one of their vehicles and it set me thinking - we all know "breast is best" is trite and unhelpful - but what would be a good message?

I like "Every breastfeed makes a difference" - but would the give blood phrase work for this?

OP posts:
tiktok · 21/04/2009 10:41

Good to hear, Qally.

standanddeliver - complain. You are not in the job, you have nothing to lose. Tell them what you saw. Explain it's a training issue. Very few mothers even realise when they have been let down - you can be their voice. Copy your letter to the MSLC, the PCT's chief exec and anyone else you think needs to know.

To be fair, if the co-ord's job is admin, she doesn't need much training in bf. So be careful what and who you talk about

EachPeachPearMum · 21/04/2009 11:04

standanddeliver I have to agree with the quality of bf advice from community workers- all the m/w I saw had no idea about bf... except the one who had bf 3 children herself. Thankfully I am v close to an excellent bf clinic, whose support and advice is 2nd to none (even tiktok/hm! )
With dd there were no problems... but ds was horrific- fed constantly, and so painfully... one visit, tongue-tie diagnosed, feeding position changed to one that didn't hurt, appointment made for snipping, and bf was saved. I knew it shouldn't have felt like that, because of my exp with dd (17mo ebf) but a first timer wouldn't, and I can understand why many women just cannot continue, despite their efforts and wishes.

Upwind · 21/04/2009 11:42

I think that a big part of the problem is some ingrained notion that breastfeeding generally comes as naturally to humans as it does to most other mammals. The skill and learning involved is not properly recognised.

hanaflower · 21/04/2009 12:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Upwind · 21/04/2009 12:07

I had truly excellent support in the community with breastfeeding - from my midwife, health visitor, NCT and LaLeche. But if I had had half decent advice at the hospital I might not have needed so much from them and my baby would not have been seriously ill. I think there needs to be less promotion of breastfeeding until it can be adequately supported. As it is, the promotion just spreads guilt and even endangers infants. "Every breastfeed makes a difference" is the worst slogan of all in that respect.

coochicoo · 21/04/2009 12:13

This thread and the talk of posters etc reminded me of some posters I saw in the baby feeding room at Eurodisney. All the posters were of old Nestle adverts and one in particular sticks in my mind - a young baby looking adoringly at a bottle of milk with the words 'Her Birthright' underneath.

Imagine the furore if breastfeeding was advertised in that way?!

In terms of this thread, I place another vote for 'Every Breastfeed Makes a Difference'.

Upwind · 21/04/2009 12:32

hanaflower AFAIK it is learned behaviour in other primates too. And even farmers with suckler cows do intervene if a calf is unable to feed themselves. If only my dd had recieved that level of care!

Stories like mine and Qually's turn women off even trying to breastfeed. Mine could easily have been very positive. If I had been unable to get my DD to take any formula I am sure it would have been taken more seriously. But somehow I think that the feeding issues of my vulnerable breastfed baby were seen as my problem to solve.

Qally · 21/04/2009 23:06

Upwind - I could not agree more. It wasn't until I found competent help that I discovered how horrifyingly incompetent the local had been. If the NHS spent less on publicity and more on having a clinic like the John Radcliffe's in every maternity unit in the country, bf rates would rocket. Most women start already. It would therefore seem that the problem lies in helping them continue.

MrsHD · 22/04/2009 10:18

Hello. Haven't had time to read the other posts so apols if I'm repeating... On my birth board are several mums who gave up BF within days or a month at most and now regret it. The general sentiment is 'I wish I'd stuck with it, hadn't given up so easily when LO got demanding/I got tired/couldn't manage with the other children too', that sort of thing. It's as if only once they've given up do they realise what they actually had. Many of these mothers are the young ones fairly focussed - from what they say, not my judgment - on figure, boyfriend, clothes etc, and see BF as interfering with that which, yeah, it does I guess! It's as if it takes a while for it to sink in to them just how much it matters to them that they can do this thing for their child. Also many of them were FF, their friends FF, they see no precedent for doing something which can be messy, embarrassing, painful, time-consuming and exhausting.

None of which answers the original point. I'm trying to get across why it is some people ho have free choice choose not to BF or give up fast. Rather than harping on about the health benefits - let's be honest, we all know them, it's the same as 'eat less to lose weight' and 'smoking will give you revolting, painful diseases', it doesn't make people change their habits - perhaps we need a viral marketing campaign which places images of BF women everywhere in a million different contexts, so that it becomes normal. I don't watch EastEnders or anything like that (naturally I'm above those things, being a smug BFer ;)) but if they had storylines about people determined to BF and overcoming probs, or even better just had mothers quietly BFing in the background, it might become a normal part of life. There's perception that FF gives you freedom as others can feed the baby and while that in itself is true, EBM works the same way and there's nothing as free as grabbing the baby and scooting off, milk all nicely stored sterile and at the right temp under your armpits!

Okay will stop rambling now

MrsHD · 22/04/2009 10:21

It would have been much more helpful if I'd restricted myself to 'Every breastfeed makes a difference' too! I like that.

SallyJayGorce · 22/04/2009 14:30

Every breastfeed makes a difference is good because a lot of people try and it doesn't work out so this is encouraging and doesn't exclude people who have given their babies at least some breastmilk.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page