Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

So upset told EBF 5 mo is "overweight and in the danger zone"

54 replies

Halfbaked · 08/02/2011 12:30

Hi I've just come back from the HV ( I know but so far they have been excellent) I am in tears.

DD is ebf and just turned 5mo, she was 7lb 6oz at birth 25th percentile she is now 20lb 1oz and between the 98th and 99th percentile.
I only stayed to ask how you tell the difference between teething and weaning signs, as i think she possibly is ready for weaning but wanted to do BLW as sitting up etc but seems early still.

I have been told to drop a feed and swap with water as she is clearly overweight and in the danger zone. If I keep on feeding her she will be off the charts and did a look to suggest action would be taken.

I said I had been told many times you cannot overfeed a breastfed baby, including by her colleagues when I have visited before- (in fact last time they congratulated me on doing so well and that it was rare to find EBF babies in the area.)

She said this was not true and some babies can be. She said the chart clearly shows that she is heading off the scale, that I should not wean her until at least 6 months because she will be obese.

I said perhaps I ought to take her to the Dr's she said it wasn't a medical matter. There was a trainee dr(I think) with her who was a bit flustered when asked her advice saying the HV knew more about feeding but pretty much backed her up.

I left, was in a daze came home and cried my eyes out.

So from all the posts that I have lurked on here, I think I am right but I feel so undermined and tbh I've worried about the weight thing from the beginning as she still nurses every 2 hours except at night.

Am I overfeeding her? Is she obese? Why am i listening to one HV when 4 others said the opposite?
So sorry for the long post.

OP posts:
barmbrack · 09/02/2011 11:46

My DT1 went from 2nd centile at birth to 75th at 1 year for weight; and from 25th - over 100th for height!!!

Your child is tall and perfectly in proportion.

Well done, btw! Grin

dawntigga · 09/02/2011 14:57

THIS is why I didn't weigh The Cub very often, although I have fantastic HV's who would NEVER have said this.

I shall now take a deep breath and post:

CHARTS ARE AN INDICATION AND AN AVERAGE NOTHING MORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And breathe.

EBF babies CANNOT over feed unless there is a medical problem (and then it's usually in the opposite direction). So what if your baby is in the 98/99 percentile? She'll start moving soon and use up all that energy she's got stored. That's what its for!

Just because this person is an HV it doesn't mean she knows what she's talking about on this! Wean when she shows the signs that she should be weaned sitting up test etc.

You're doing fine - hugs and to hell with the non MNishness of hugs!

Can you tell your HV upset me? Wink

WouldVERYMuchLikeToHaveA'Chat'WithThatHVTiggaxx

rollerbaby · 09/02/2011 22:04

Agree with Morloth - this is total nonsense. My 13 week old is already nearly 18lbs and entirely BF. I have no qualms about it - he's a big baby. I wouldn't give him water, just keep going as you are. What a great mum you are to get this far!

mamjo · 10/02/2011 09:55

I had the same thing with my HV - she actually rang me at home 8 hours after seeing us to say that she had been talking to her colleagues about my DD weight and they thought that I should stop demand feeding. I then spoke to my GP and she said that "they're the experts, do what they say" also members of my family and friends all having an opinion about her weight. So I tried to feed every 4 hours as they suggested but it made me and DD so miserble that I have just returned to doing what my instinct says and both of us are much much happier.
All the research I have done for myself and all the support I have had from the lovely MNetters say that I am doing the right thing.

BTW DD is 96th centile.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page