Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Do you have an anti- bf MIL? Let's have a rant!

79 replies

sweetandtenderhooligan · 03/01/2011 12:26

I'm sure this has been done to death but I'm curious to hear stories about other disapproving mils! Mine reckons I'm depriving ds of a "proper feed", arrived at my house when ds was 3 weeks old with a tub of Aptimal and 6 Tommy Tipee bottles in am attempt to lure me out of bf, refuses to feed ds a bottle of expressed breast milk, commented recently that because ds had a cold it proved that bfeeding isn't all it's made out to be etc etc etc. I could go on. Let me have your stories please!

OP posts:
GrumpyFish · 03/01/2011 14:32

Oh can I join in! Mine sounds very similar (scarily, she was a midwife - although stopped practising in about 1975!). Comments too numerous to mention, but particular incidents inlcude an attempt to feed DS weetabix when he was 11 weeks old and I was in the shower (he was "clearly starving and needed proper food"), and at 4 months buying us a special "Christmas bottle" (covered in santa and reindeer pictures etc) and then insisting that we must try to use it on Christmas day or DS would be very upset (despite the fact that he had had no bottles at all - not even expressed milk as I couldn't get him to take it).

TBH my response was probably quite childish but I think DS did well out of it - I bf him for a lot longer than I might have otherwise (15 months) party spurred on by her reaction Grin.

DS2 due in the spring so looking forward to going through the whole thing again!!

allnightlong · 03/01/2011 14:41

I had problems with both PIL and my parents.
My PIL didn't really say much just very uncomfortble with me feeding in front of them, FIL would walk out the room, MIL would look anywhere but me it made me feel very awkward.

My parents are more vocal not so much in a negative way just a little Hmm 'she always has to be the awkward difficult one'
They don't agree with BF past 6 months but know not to challenge me on it anymore.

There was also a bit of presure over GP wanting 'their turn' in feeding baby.
I'm afraid I'm a bit of a bitch in that department imo they've had their turn feeding their own babies now it's my turn.
Plus it was a good excuse not to allow my mum to have my DC overnight as newborns. She had told me she was looking forward too having them without asking if I was ok with it, I just didn't feel ready to leave my DC when they were only weeks old.

Porcelain · 03/01/2011 14:46

My MIL would have been very supportive, she was outside her time in that she bf, and took a 5 year career break to raise DH in the mid 80s, ignoring the advice at the time. Unfortunately I never met her in person as she died before DH and I became an item Sad

My mother however is one of the generation of schedules and "not being taken advantage of. She bf me for a few weeks, but stopped to have her wisdom teeth out.

She was horrified about me planning a home birth, kept ringing me to tell me about how it could go wrong and how would I feel then. She got a bit "I told you so" when I had to transfer for a section (he was stuck, to the point he never engaged correctly, labouring at home actually made the whole thing better, they wouldn't have operated or possibly even admitted me any sooner if I had planned for a hospital birth).

She stayed with me for a few days when I came out of hospital. She was forever telling me to put DS down so he could "get used to his cot" or "learn to be independent". Suggested I gave him a bottle a day when he was a week old to "give yourself a break" (because preparing bottles and cleaning up afterwards is so much easier than sitting on the sofa feeding).

She rang me up to suggest I put him out in the garden in his pram (in October, it was raining) so I could paint the hallway in peace. Told me he needed to cry to "develop his lungs".

I got married when he was 10 weeks old. When I arrived at theirs it was suggested I go up to the bedroom to feed, rather than stay downstairs and talk to my brother who I hadn't seen in years (I stayed down, and my dad came over, talked to the baby and kissed him on the head without realising, even after, I was feeding him). I got a cat's bum face when I told her he would sleep in my bed, and she suggested I put him on the folding bed alongside Confused. She was badgering me to give him formula instead of expressing for the bit of the day when he would be with my SIL. I overheard her telling my brothers fiancee "he is spoiled because she never puts him down". All of the wedding day she kept trying to get me to give him to other people (did the walking off jiggling when he was hungry, despite me having made it very clear I wanted to tank him up in the morning when I was getting ready), including my SILs mum, who he (or I) had never met before (my mother invited her, no idea why, but that's another rant). I also got a cat's bum face when I got up from the table during the meal to go feed him (it was a buffet, so no big deal, and I was leaking onto my silk dress).

She still keeps asking me how long he is going, and is appalled that it is actually only 1.5-2 hours in the day, so clearly he needs formula, or weaning (4 1/2 months). She also calls him "greedy" for feeding frequently and "fat" (he is 91st centile, but his dad is 6'2" and built like a rugby player, he isn't meant to be a dainty child).

I try to avoid talking about our daily "routine" with her now, and just tell her about his new achievements instead.

allnightlong · 03/01/2011 14:47

Oh that was another thing BF on demand got lots of comments on that all my family are the feed only every 4hours no matter how loud baby cries types. I got no sympathy for being an exhausted new mum all the could say was 'well if you bottle feed....'

Porcelain · 03/01/2011 14:47

Oops, I may have ranted.

jaggythistle · 03/01/2011 15:19

ooh mine could be at least that long if i got going.

the only thing that stops me is that she is otherwise a fairly nice and very generous person (she gave me my first car, for example!), she just has a slight inability to listen and a daily mail delivered every day...

it was soo frustrating being questioned all the time, DH got quite upset by it.

DancingThroughLife · 03/01/2011 15:29

Lol, Porcelain, my Mum is a watered down version of yours!

She tried the 'one bottle a day' suggestion and received the same answer you just said.

DD goes to my Nan one day a week, while I've been getting ready to go back to work. She's 7 months now, so I'm working on getting her to drink from a cup rather than get her too hooked on a bottle and have to wean her from two things later. Mum and Nan almost told me to put her on formula during the day and just feed her morning and night, but they soon changed tack when they saw my face Grin I can express enough during the week to last her the two days I'm at work. Apparently she can't have a cup all day or else "how will she know to go to sleep?" Erm, put her down in her cot and stick the mobile on usually does it Confused

I've had comments about it not being enough and how will DD be able to stay over if she's not on formula and all sorts. I glaze over now... Grin

spiggy · 03/01/2011 15:50

Being greeted by the ILs with "still starving my grandson then?" every single sodding time I saw them.

I bought the "I like milk from my mum not just any old cow" T-shirt for DS in the end. Then they just muttered behind my back rather than to my face. They didn't do it to DD strangely enough. Perhaps they'd got used to my "odd" ways by then Grin

bellylicious · 03/01/2011 15:56

my mil has been super supportive until dd hit 12mo Confused
apparently she will become clingy her teeth will fall out and there is no benefit to the milk anymore

she was facinated by it as she adopted dh and sil so didnt bf, i think shes sad about it and has many a time told me that shes always had an empty womb feeling so sad Sad

pearlgirl · 03/01/2011 17:06

you would think that with ds4 I would have been ready for the comments about frequency of feeding. we had a visit when he was 5 days old and it took my mil 10mins to tell him the "milky bar" was closed. I bit my tongue and calmly took him back and latched him on. I also got the jiggling and taking the baby off for walks because it wasn't time for a feed yet.

Porcelain · 03/01/2011 23:33

This milky bar embraces 24 hour licensing.Grin

PenguinArmy · 04/01/2011 02:23

I'm glad other ILs do the walking off and jiggling thing. In our case it was when she was tired, but no she liked to have a tour of the house with full narration at 6 weeks Hmm.

She's 10 months now and they keep asking about when can she have cows milk. We've explained at one year, but we don't want to give dairy so I'll carry on feeding her. 'What about soya' DH replies again we don't see the point of artificial dairy so Penguin and her army will carry on feeding her. Cue confused faces and change of topic.

ChunkyPickle · 04/01/2011 03:26

Mine has been great on the whole, but both my mother and MIL haven't been able to resist the 'oh by that age my milk wasn't enough - I had to give you/him rice/rusk/cereal'

I politely change the subject...

Want2bSupermum · 04/01/2011 03:55

I am in week 14 of my first pregnancy and my mother and MIL have both told me that I MUST breastfeed for at least 6 months and try to continue for up to 12 months. I am 3000 miles away from them and will do what I am able to do. I have every intention of going as long as I can with bf but I will go back to work after 3 months, have a house to keep up and DH is working his socks off (he travels a lot too leaving me on my own) plus doing his MBA.

My MIL has already bought me a breast pump to use when in Denmark. The only problem is that everything is 110v here so I can't use it. It was very sweet of her but my face was a picture on christmas morning when I opened up 2pair of sloggi bloomers and a breast pump.

PenguinArmy · 04/01/2011 04:00

I nearly did BF Want2b because a past boyfriend had told me that if he had children he'd expect the mother to BF. Made me very sensitive to all the pro-BF advertising after that.

PenguinArmy · 04/01/2011 04:13

opps that should have nearly didn't BF

Livinginoz · 04/01/2011 04:37

My mil admired me for Bf, she didn't feed any of her three, and regularly told me that I was a good mum, bless her! Although she occasionally made comments about missing giving her GS a bottle, but never had issues giving EBM and had a freezer full, for babysitting!

My aunt was an absolute cow though, kept drip-feeding to my mum "how does she know he is getting enough?" and "have they weighed him yet?" My mum who BF for 8 months with both me and sister started questioning me a lot, and then when I found out where it was coming from, went a bit mad Blush saying "that cow had 5 kids and didn't BF, what the hell would she know?" and it all went quiet Grin

pommedeterre · 04/01/2011 11:30

Want2be Superman - You raise an interesting point of vice cersa. MILs/Mums making daughters feel worried/guilty about not bf-ing. One of my friends did have this when she stopped.
I think the main message is that MILs and Mums should be supportive whatever and butt out..
Ah dear god the jiggling. Drives me insane. Hated chasing after jiggling MIL and starving dd.

StayFrosty · 04/01/2011 11:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

redandyellowandpinkandgreen · 04/01/2011 15:25

My MIL is trying to be supportive as best as she can but I don't think she really understands a lot of it. They do comment how DS has grown and must be doing all right and they will read the leaflets I show them to explain why I am not giving any formula as a top-up etc.

She clearly finds it a bit embarrassing though and can't even say 'breast' she says 'mother's milk' Grin. FIL can't be in the room when I feed and puts his coat on very quickly when it's time.

At the beginning DS wasn't gaining weight as my milk took a while to come in and the midwife was at my house explaining my options and she suggested to top up with forumla. MIL has the steriliser going and had got the bottles out while I was still digesting the information and deciding what to do. I imagined walking in to find them feeding him formula but I was a bit hysterical and hormonal at this point. To be fair, they were just trying to help but at the time it took a lot of willpower not to lose my temper.

My mum is very supportive and breast fed me but I'm not sure how she will be if I decide to carry on feeding after 6 months.

Zimm · 04/01/2011 17:45

I have the exact opposite - MIL adores Bf'ing and insists on staring right at me when i do or coming right up close and patting DD. lovely and wonderful i knwo and I am very lucky butTBH although I'm not shy I can live without teh staring!

jaggythistle · 05/01/2011 12:19

interesting that other MILs with adopted dcs have been fascinated and supportive.

mine has kind of been really defensive about it. she had to ff so it must be fine kind of thing. she was much more supportive of my SIL ffing from birth and was all excited to give bottles.

i don't think she ever wanted to give DS a bottle of ebm. FIL did, but i think he actually thought it was formula, he was always shouting through to ask DH if he wanted a hand making up a bottle! i expressed for when we were at theirs sometimes just to try and get less hassle. Blush

i appreciate she was out of her comfort zone and didn't understand bf, but she made no effort to listen and be nice about it.

hopefully if and when there is a dc 2 we won't get the same hassle again...

HollyFP · 05/01/2011 14:34

Wow am quite :( about some of these MIL comments. I cannot understand why people would not want the best for their DGC. And in any case, it's not of their fooking business really is it?! Grin

My mum is fab with me still bf my nearly 6mo; my MIL supportive but I still get the odd 'is she sleeping through yet' or 'is she feeding every 4 hours yet' sort of thing. Smile and nod, smile and nod...

justasmallglass · 05/01/2011 14:57

Another here with supportive and complimentary MIL, but a not so mother.

Comments such as "you are always feeding him, does he really need it?", echoing the 4 hour rule they used to work to. Oh, and the latest one "Aren't you giving that up yet?", DS is 8 months.

tiredfeet · 05/01/2011 15:25

I am so lucky, my mother and MIL both breastfed, four babies each. They are so supportive and full of advice

However, Dh's brother and his wife (early thirties) were horrible about me breastfeeding ds (3 months) this christmas. They kept making disparaging comments about it, would do the walking off and jiggling thing and sulked because we couldn't go out for the evening with them. I suspect a lot of it stems from wanting more time with my baby than bf allows (dSIL very broody) but I am sad that even in our generation people are so ignorant about the benefits of breastfeeding (their friends and family all formula feed).