Please or to access all these features

Bereavement

Find bereavement help and support from other Mumsnetters. See also your choices after baby loss.

Enquiry into Bo's death

74 replies

bubble99 · 29/04/2005 23:32

We met today with the cosultant obs. who is in charge of reviewing our case and, by coincidence, was our 'named' consultant and The Head of Maternity Services. The meeting lasted for two and a half hours and it was horrible to have to re-live the whole experience again in detail.

The post mortem results showed that there was nothing wrong at all with Bo. He was a healthy 7lb7oz baby boy who had grown well.

The MW at our booking appt. had written at the end of her entry "Needs consultant appointment" addressed seemingly to no one in particular, she obviously couldn't be arsed to make it herself and despite my GP writing and requesting an appointment it eventually fell to me to make the appointment. Fine for a reasonably intelligent, medically aware person like me, but not so fine if I'd happened to be someone who couldn't speak English and/or didn't realise the need to see a consultant.

We'd been booked into the diary by the MW at the antenatal clinic for induction on the evening of the 16th February but this had not been passed on to the maternity unit. We phoned as requested at 5pm on the 16th to check that there was a bed available. We did and were told that there were no beds on the antenatal ward but to come in at 8.30pm anyway. When we arrived we were put in a room on the postnatal unit. Those investigating had been told by the staff that they had 3 beds available on the AN ward but that they'd put me in a single room elsewhere because I had shoulder pain and they thought I'd be more comfortable there. Absolute crap as I hadn't mentioned my shoulder pain when I'd phoned earlier and they only knew about it when I arrived at the hospital.

The entire unit was so short staffed that evening that they'd had to close the active birth ward and four antenatal beds. This information was not volunteered and only given today when I asked a direct question.

Up until two years ago the maternity unit had a 'bleep holder', a senior midwife who's role was to coordinate and be aware of potentially difficult inductions such as mine. This post was dropped as the bleep holder was supernumerary and could not be incorporated into staffing numbers. The bleep is now held by a midwife who is probably up to her eyes trying to run her own (short-staffed) area.

There was a total breakdown in communication, we should have been moved to the labour ward for immediate induction within an hour of admission, not seven hours later. The labour ward was full as there were insufficient staff to move those mothers and babies ready to go to the post natal ward.

My notes were full of references to my shoulder pain (which was acknowledged to be muscular and not a life threatening pulmonary embolism within two hours). No plan of action made for delivery of the increasingly distressed twins.

The CTG traces had been picking up the same twin for two and a half hours and this had not been recognised. The attempt at vaginal delivery was apparently the right course of action as they wanted to attach fetal scalp monitoring and see if there was meconium in the amniotic fluid. Mr Bubble pointed out that at this point twin 2 was really struggling and they could not break his waters anyway. They maintain that the babies' tachycardias(fast pulse rates) were not cause for concern in themselves as they were respondant to my pulse rate which was at that time fast. No kidding.

A consultant anaesthetist arrived at this point during the meeting and told me that the attempts at spinal anaesthesia had been abandoned on the direction of the obstetrician who performed my CS. To this I replied, and it was the only time I swore, that if so they must have been f*g telepathic because at that point there was total silence in theatre and that it was me who'd insisted on the general anaesthetic. He decided then that maybe after I'd said it the obs. nodded her head to agree. WTF

Not one MW or doctor thought to check that the consultant had been informed of the deteriorating clinical situation.

I was flat on my back for 30 minutes while they tried and failed to intubate me. This caused hypoxia in me as my lungs couldn't fully inflate. The blood supply to the placenta was also severely restricted. The respiratory depressing anaesthetic agents had been crossing the placenta for too long before a succesful intubation was achieved and it was the combination of these things that killed Bo.

We now await the full report in writing and will discuss the proposed actions/policy changes in detail at our next meeting.

BTW. We were told that the whole case was also being reviewed by 'The Clinical Governance Facilitator'(sp) WTF. How much is he/she on? No money to pay MW's a liveable on salary but enough for yet another 9-5 bod to mop up the piles of poo that understaffing causes

OP posts:
champs · 30/04/2005 01:03

grrrrrrr[sngry]
so sorry you're going through this. So impressed in your strength.
love to you and dh xxx

colinsmommy · 30/04/2005 01:08

Bubble, I don't really understand the medical system there, but I just have to say how sorry I am that it let you down. My DH got home and I was crying because of reading this, so he read it too, and wanted me to be sure to let you know how sorry he is too.

bobbybob · 30/04/2005 01:21

So as I understand it, some of these people are actually lying to you and the enquiry, and then completely backtracking when challenged, and this is "full and frank"?

So and for you bubble.

Chandra · 30/04/2005 01:40

I have no words to express how angry I am on your behalf! . I'm so sorry Bubbles, a big hug to all your family.

Titania · 30/04/2005 06:34

oh i am so sorry you are having to go through this. Reliving it must be a nightmare. thinking of you all xxxxx

WideWebWitch · 30/04/2005 06:55

How awful Bubble and how completely unsatisfactory (which seems a totally inadequate word), the understaffing is absolutely disgraceful.

WideWebWitch · 30/04/2005 06:56

It's all disgraceful though

Twiglett · 30/04/2005 08:11

That is just so disgusting. How dare they treat a bereaved family like that

I am so sorry for you and your whole family

are you planning to write to them to express your disgust before the next meeting and tell them exactly what should happen in the next meeting: small things like honesty and clarity spring to mind

I am so so sorry bubble (and Mr bubble), I am thinking of you

LGJ · 30/04/2005 08:25

Whitewash.

I know that this wasn't about money, as nothing can replace BO, but quite frankly I would drag them through every paper in the land at this stage.

My heart is breaking for you and Mr Bubble.

{{{{{{{{{{ Hugs }}}}}}}}}}}}}}

hub2dee · 30/04/2005 08:26

Hi Bub,

Sounds like hell. It appears perfectly clear that a whole series of errors (and now people covering their asses) led to Bo dieing. The failed consultant appointment and then the ward allocation thing sounds like very poor administration, and the 'squeezing' of information (re: staffing) is obviously not what you wanted to happen in a 'full and frank' exchange. The f*ckers.

And you can add to that with porterage / other staff not being available to move new mums to post natal too so that everything continues to flow.

... you might think that with a suspected pulm. emb. they'd have given you specially good care instead of specially bad care and kept a better eye on things, INCLUDING the babies.

Ref: tachycardias - I think you mentioned before it was the failiure to recover from dips, more so / as much as the tachycardia itself that was the obvious sign of signficiant, serious distress. Possibly an equally dictatorial / pushy consultant / lawyer arguing on your side would be able to push that particular point further if you've had enough...

Also a pity, of course that the consultant anaesthetist needs to appear creative with his version of events and arguments. ... made worse of course by the fact that no staff dared squeak about the clinical status surrounding the twins at the time.

I note Mears' comments on suitable position for intubation and guess this should be added to your arsenal of comments / significant points... it appears to be one of the last, major contributory causes to Bo's death.

From the reception you have received, and the diversions you may feel you've been presented with, do you anticipate continuing the next meeting on expectation of honesty from them or are you considering further 'in meeting' professional assistance ?

Oh bub, it is shameful. . X

PS - Hugs to you from everyone here . X

Munchkinola · 30/04/2005 08:39

xxxx thinking of you and your family

Hulababy · 30/04/2005 08:44

Oh bubble; I am so sorry for everything you have been through, and continue to go through.

foxinsocks · 30/04/2005 08:45

I'm really sorry bubble.

I can't think of any positives but at least you now know what the contributory factors were in Bo's death. What I can't understand is why it could take them 30 mins to intubate you - especially as you are a healthy, young woman (albeit were pregnant at the time). That anaesthetist sounds like a total wanker.

Was your consultant there at the enquiry? He sounded like he would be 'on your side' based on the earlier discussions you'd had with him.

MABS · 30/04/2005 09:02

thinking of you all,thats all i can really say.

Whizzz · 30/04/2005 09:30

So sad and needless
Thinking of you & your family & admiring your courage to fight to find out what went wrong.

pupuce · 30/04/2005 09:31

It's just appaling.... surely it would be better, faster, cheaper and less excruciating for everyone if they were just frank and admitted their errors rather than trying to cover up..... grrrrr.....

Bubble much sympathy to your and Mr Bubble....... hope some good comes out of this - I really do [hug]

miam · 30/04/2005 09:34

There are no words for how bad I feel for you bubble. I hope you have lots of support to help you through this. xxx

LIZS · 30/04/2005 09:48

omg I am so sorry and angry on your behalf that they are attempting to fob you off. It doesn't even seem as if they had prepared a cohesive review for the meeting.

All credit to your and Mr Bubble's courage that you have the strength to pursue it further. Is there a timescale for the report and next review ?

{{hugs}}

Frizbe · 30/04/2005 10:18

Oh bubble I can only echo the thoughts above, v about this for you.

snafu · 30/04/2005 10:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

marthamoo · 30/04/2005 11:07

It just gets worse I am so sorry and really don't know what to say. Keep fighting, and take care of each other.

Heathcliffscathy · 30/04/2005 11:09

i'm so sorry that this process isn't giving you the peace of mind you deserve. i think you are being incredibly brave and dignified.

i'm so sad and angry for you. i hope the next meeting goes better.

sassy · 30/04/2005 11:10

Can't say anything useful, just wanted to add my thoughts and love to you all.
You are very brave to keep pushing this - hope you get the honest answers you need soon.x

bubble99 · 30/04/2005 11:24

mears, if it's OK with you I'll CAT you about left lateral tilt and failed obstetric intubation oxygenation procedures. If You could point me towards some credible text/literature on the subject I can follow this aspect of the case up. TIA

OP posts:
jambo1707 · 30/04/2005 11:45

Thinking of you and your family bubble at this sad and distressing time.

Hope you get your answers hun keep us posted

Swipe left for the next trending thread