Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Appropriate punishment for breaking a dvd for a 3yr old...

54 replies

PavlovtheForgetfulCat · 14/10/2009 16:38

DD came in from shops with DH, spent the afternoon with him there with friends, gave them a lift. She has been good for them all afternoon.

I am at home, feeling a bit poorly.

She comes in, picks up a DVD which I stupidly left by the dvd player, unbeknown to me. She was posting it through cabinet drawers when I noticed she had it, and when I took it off her it is cracked.

It is her, and my favourite dvd, My Neigbor Totoro. I took it off her and told her she had broken it. She said 'i am sowwy mama' but I do not think she really knows what this means other than she says it when mama or daddy is annoyed about something.

Anyway, she immediately says what am I going to watch now? I wanted to watch it. I said she can't as it is broken. She wants to watch scooby doo, but I said no tv, she wants computer but I said no computer, but DH said computer is fine (changed his mind when I flashed my peepers at her). She then got down from sofa when asked not to, and knocked a glass over, spilt it all over the floor, again my fault as I left it there.

Problem is, we have builders here who have power tools in the hallway atm and she cannot go and play in her room, it is noisy, she is tired and there is not much else that will keep her calm. So we sat and cuddled and read a book.

Then she asked to watch tv nicely. I said ok, but only if she promises to be a good girl, but no scooby doo as she has broken the dvd.

She now really really wants scooby doo and I have said no.

I do not want it to go unchallenged this breaking of a dvd, as she needs to learn to look after her things and not be like, oh its broken, nevermind I will do something else, but I do not really know how to handle this today...

have I been too lenient, not lenient enough? Right punishment, completely inappropriate punishment? I just could not think of what else to do, but do not think she really has any clue of consequences or what breaking the dvd means, she has already moved on

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
PavlovtheForgetfulCat · 16/10/2009 04:10

of to try to get an hour or so's sleep before dd wakes up. she woke at 5:30am this morning. I am on sofa to avoid disturbing her or dh (she is in with us for a couple more weeks) and she will no doubt creep in and say 'what you doing here mama? before pushing me over and snuggling in for some early morning tele. Oh I wish she liked to snooze like her mama does

OP posts:
CJCregg · 16/10/2009 04:14

Ooh, varnish sounds nice!

She did it because she was pissed off with me. She's going through a (really charming) phase where she kicks off every bedtime, makes a huge fuss, I coax, cajole, bribe, threaten and try desperately not to shout, but usually end up removing a toy at which point she breaks down, sobs, says 'sorry Mummy', asks for 'one last chance', has a cuddle and goes to sleep like an angel. I am completely wired for the next hour!

It has been getting better recently - we had a star chart and agreed on a treat she would get if she could be good at bedtime for a week. She got the treat and has now reverted ... so tonight I took the treat away again. Probably not the best thing to do, but after up to an hour of this tantrumming I'm usually at my wits end.

Grrr ... sorry for ranting. 4am stuff again!

CJCregg · 16/10/2009 04:16

thanks, pavlov ... hope you get some sleep. I don't think they appreciate snooze till they're teenagers, do they?

mumeeee · 17/10/2009 22:03

She is only 3 ,she didn't do it on purpose and you left it where she could get it. So I don't think you should punish her. She can't watch that DVD anyway as it is broken.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page