Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Behaviour/development

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Is it ever a good idea to 'give in' to your child, or is it a slippery slope that sends the wrong message?

54 replies

Earlybird · 09/08/2008 17:04

We've all heard of 'pester power' and how giving in to a child's demands/requests can be fatal to one's parental credibility/authority.

Do you ever give in to your child to defuse an escalating situation or just for an easy life? Are there other reasons/situations where it is OK? Specific examples would be helpful.

Would also like to hear from parents of primary/secondary school children (not just toddlers).

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
frogs · 11/08/2008 22:12

Yes, I'd tell the 9yo, not ask her. If she's too tired she can sit in the cafe with a drink and a book watching everyone else swim. The line between taking your children seriously and being taken for a mug is quite a fine one.

Thinking about this, it also seems to depend for us on how much effort the child has made -- I'm much more likely to look favourably on requests that aren't particularly convenient for me if the child concerned has clearly been trying to help/share/ be nice to siblings etc etc.

I bought dd1 (13) some clothes today that she didn't really need, at least in part because she has been exceptionally helpful with dd2 during dd2's unfortunate hospital incident involving bead up nose. I would have been much less inclined to break my 'if you don't actually need it, buy it out of your allowance' rule if she'd spent the last week lying on her bed sulking and listening to Greenday at top volume.

And that isn't bribery/reward, it's just human nature. I think it's good for them to learn early on that you are more likely to treat them like adults if they treat you and their siblings with consideration.

Letting a 9yo have veto over a family outing is just bonkers imo. Presumably she just has the one dd? Because as soon as you're juggling more than one child, that logic would fall into a very deep pit of its own making -- as soon as you have several people wanting different things, by definition not everybody can have things exactly their own way. And I think accepting that sometimes they need to do things because the adult wants/needs to do them is fine too. But I think that's different from the original question, which was more about strategies to avoid painting yourself into a corner that you don't really want to be in, confrontation-wise.

Earlybird · 14/08/2008 19:16

Frogs - yes, they have just the one child (as I do), and it is easy to see how 'onlys' can unintentionally be made to feel omnipotent because so much revolves exclusively around their needs/desires.

Also completely agree that doing something 'special' for a child is a good way of recognising/acknowledging especially good and helpful behaviour. But obviously, we shouldn't do it all the time because the child will come to expect it.

In the past few days, have been able to quite effectively use behaviour of dd's friend as an example of how not to behave, and it has helped immensely in defusing power struggles at home: dd had a playdate a few days ago, and the guest whined, wouldn't take turns, pestered, didn't share, wouldn't listen to any of dd's ideas for games, insisted on having her own way, etc. Have exploited that afternoon to the hilt with dd by referencing 'remember how unpleasant it was when X did this or that - what would have made it more fair or fun for you instead?'. Have found it a much more positive way of pointing out unpleasant demanding behaviour, and have not had the friction of 'getting touch' with dd, or giving in because I've been worn down.

Bink - if you check back on this thread, thought of you today when I took dd to the dentist. Are there pediatric dentists in London? It is a booming industry here, where children have teeth cleaned twice a year, monitor milk teeth falling out/permanent teeth coming in, etc - all of which dovetails straight into orthodontic treatment, if needed.....and it usually is (surprise, surprise). My point is though, that they are geared up toward introducing children to the dentist in a relaxed/fun way (playful games, choose a dvd to watch, etc), rather than putting them straight into an adult dental practise, which could be a bit frightening, and definitely not fun.

OP posts:
Earlybird · 14/08/2008 19:17

'getting tough'

OP posts:
OrmIrian · 14/08/2008 19:37

Yes to the first question
No to the second.

What happens if you find out something that makes it OK to let them do/have whatever it is? Do you still say no on the principle that 'mummy is always right'? Don't know about you but I am not infallible.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page