Polly, Amber or Eden?

[emeraldrainbow]

Thoughts for a baby girl?

Eden

Polly feels more timeless. Amber and Eden feel like they would date.

Eden. Definitely not Amber.

Depends on surname

Polly is delightful

I like Amber, mainly because I know a lovely ( teenage) Amber. Not keen on Polly - it's too perky. Really don't like Eden. Sorry. None of them really excite me. I really love Lara. But there you go, we're all different!

Definitely Polly. I really despise Eden, it is very 'of the moment' and I see it as more of a boys name.
Amber is pretty, a bit dated, but fine. Polly is cool, quirky and cute at the same time, and also under-used.
PJ Harvey is a very cool Polly!

Polly.

I'm the reverse: Polly is sweet, and Amber and Eden aren't really my style.

Exactly.

If I’d have had a girl she would have been Eden. It’s lovely.

Polly 9
Amber 9
Eden 7

@mamaduckbone , Polly seems a bit of a little girl name to work for an adult.
@user2848502016 , Polly is too cutesy as an adult name

Polly Toynbee did OK with her 'cutesy', 'little girl name'. I know a doctor Polly, a neighbour when I was growing up was 'Aunty Polly' etc.
Current children are called things like Alfie, Archie, Ellie and Elsie.