Polly, Amber or Eden?

[emeraldrainbow]

Thoughts for a baby girl?

Polly.

Eden or Polly.

Eden is my daughter's name, everyone comments on it! Amber also beautiful !

Polly is too popular, IMO.

Amber and Eden are both beautiful names.

Polly seems a bit of a little girl name to work for an adult. Amber and Eden are both lovely - I prefer Amber.

Polly.

I’m not a fan of Polly. Amber and Eden are both nice.

Polly

I know adult Pollys. Eden could be a boy and I think Amber is a dog’s name.

Love Polly and Eden…..both of which I considered for my DD.

Amber is ok, if I’d had a baby in my teens it would have been on the list.

I like Polly and Amber, but Eden - although lovely - is definitely a boy's name.

Anything but Polly! Polly is either a maid or a parrot.

Polly is lovely. I know a 60 something year old Polly and a 7 year old Polly.

Amber is my least favourite. It’s very dated , 90’s?

I like Amber. I like Eden too but it makes me think of cheese - I know that's Edam but it's too similar.

I like Eden

Eden is not a commonly used boys name though. Regardless, I don't see the problem with giving your child a unisex name.

Polly

It’s 50 50 in the ones I’ve met. Of course it’s not a reason, we’re all different.

Polly is too cutesy as an adult name

Amber and Eden are beautiful, probably would go with Eden as it’s a bit more unusual

Rather unhelpfully, I like them all!

Polly sounds like a quirky but interesting child and woman.
I haven't met many girls called Amber, and only a boy called Eden, but they're both nice names.

Polly. Amber is nice but not as classy. Eden is not nice or classy.

Polly but prefer Poppy.

Not keen on Amber or Eden. Don’t sound as classy or timeless.

Amber 😊

Its the second name of one of my DDs.

I think Amber is my favourite followed closely by Polly.

I'm in my 50s and was at school with a Polly who is now a solicitor.
Amber and Eden will date badly.