Narrowed down to 4 girl names

[glasshalffull0]

Molly
Erin
Isla
Grace

Thoughts?

Me too.

Isla and Grace are just too overused atm.

Erin's a funny one.

I agree with a pp that it "barely sounds like a name", and I also associate it with heron.

However, I do actually quite like it, and out of your four it would be my preferred name.

Molly; agree with a pp, very dated and infantile.

Grace; so horribly overused. People seem to think it's incredibly classy for some reason, but it just isn't. I also just don't like the sound, I don't like the hard G.

Isla; have always loved it but the popularity would sadly put me off a lot. It's sudden rise in popularity will mean it dates very quickly (it already sounds dated to me).

Molly or Erin

Erin is the best of the choices, though you could have Margaret with Molly as a diminutive..? Then I'd change my vote.

Molly

Why not all of them, in that order. Also, you'll know who she is when you meet her. Good luck!

Erin or Isla

Erin absolutely

Isla is prettiest and Erin least common

Erin or Molly.

Definitely Erin. I wanted Erin for DD1 all the way through my pregnancy, but 2 weeks before due date DH admitted he didn't love it as much as I did 😭

Isla is nice but I know lots of them. Not keen on Grace...I think it's the Grrr sound that makes it quite harsh to my ears.

Molly is awful. Wet, inelegant, frumpy and infantile.

Erin is my favourite. My dh vetoed it because it was an ex girlfriend's name which is fair enough!
I also like Isla but it's a bit overused here in Scotland.

Grace

Erin
Isla is overdone but Iona is beautiful

Have you Irish roots?

Eireann, pronounced almost identically as Erin, is the Irish language name for Ireland. It's used in the US by Irish-American families. I don't think it used much in Ireland as a name.

Grace or Isla

They are all fine. But I like Grace best.

Erin
molly
isla
grace

that order

@continentallentil
. Molly is slang for ecstasy/MDMA
(as @TropicalTrama has also said)

Mary or Margaret with Molly as diminutive? Then she can choose later if she finds the slang a problem.

The other names are nice but very popular at the moment.

I’m biased because I have an Erin! it’s not too common (at least not where I am) but not in anyway unusual or weird.

Molly is not my cup of tea at all but I like the others. I’m in Scotland and Isla is super popular right now. I think Grace is lovely too (we know quite a few close friends and family with the name so couldn’t use it).

I love Isla.
Grace and Erin are both pretty.
Molly not so much.

I find it so weird that Isla is mega popular and Iona isn’t. I think Iona is lovely!

I like Molly the best. Isla is nice but overused, Grace is also overused but I’m not keen. Really don’t get the love for Erin, it’s got a scratchy sound to it imo.

Molly