Narrowed down to 4 girl names

[glasshalffull0]

Molly
Erin
Isla
Grace

Thoughts?

It looks as if I'm the minority of one, as I don't like Erin at all. Of those names, I'd choose Molly.

All of them are fine but very popular and she will be Erin W or whatever your surname is the whole time she is at school.

Grace or Isla

Erin. The rest are nice but so meh

I like Grace but Erin is the least common.

i order of preference: Erin, Grace, Molly, Isla

I agree Erin. Isla and Grace are too overused atm for me, and I prefer Erin to Molly, though I don't mind Molly.

I feel like everyone is saying Erin purely because it's least popular, but it depends if that's important to you?
Isla has started to grate on me loads.
Grace is bland
Molly is really cute

Erin is lovely.
Isla is ok.
I know a Grace I dislike and I think it's a lot of pressure on the child to call them things that infer something about character.
Molly is a bit wet. My Brighton cousin tells me that's an insult there, not sure about anywhere else.

Erin has my vote!

Erin by a mile then Grace. Not keen on the other two

Erin is a lovely name. Not just cos it's less well used. It's feminine but strong, not girly like Molly. It won't date like Isla. It sounds poetic (sorry stereotyping there) but doesn't really have an obvious connotation like Grace (or Molly sadly). It passes the Supreme Court test. And it won't take ages to write out on every form

Grace is beautiful, Isla is OK, Erin and Molly are meh

Molly. Simple and cute.

Cant understand the love for Erin. It sounds like Eric which is pretty awful?!

Honestly I think how overdone or otherwise a name feels makes up for a huge part of whether people like a name when they hear it. Very few names are objectively awful, it's just associations.

All beautiful but I'd say Erin or Isla

I really like them all, especially Molly and Grace.

All lovely 😍

1. Erin
2. Molly
3. Grace
4. Isla

Molly - lovely
Erin - can't see any appeal
Isla - pretty but overused
Grace - nice

Erin or Molly are gorgeous. I know so many Isla's. Grace is very popular too x

Grace is the most classic imo, all lovely names though

Another vote for Erin!

I'd go Grace.

It's classic and a beautiful name.

Isla is lovely but very common and a lot of people spell/pronounce it wrong.

Molly I love however I know soooooo many dogs called Molly (still wouldn't put me off using it)

Erin is also a great name just prefer Grace.

They're all really lovely names. I was going to call my daughter Grace, but after my mum immediately said (in the labour suite no less than 3 minutes after I'd given birth) "ahh our little Gracie" I changed it. I absolutely despise the name Gracie 😅
Might it be an idea to use Grace as a middle name to one of the other names? I used Grace as a middle name in the end and I'm so glad i did. Molly Grace has a lovely ring to it 😊
Anyway, whatever you choose I'm sure it will sound lovely. Congratulations on the imminent arrival if your little one

Erin