Is it too much of a rhyme?

[CastlesByTheSea]

Love the name Clara, but surname rhymes… as in O’….
Would it be okay or silly? Would it even matter?!

This

I really like Araminta, but I don't think it flows well with your surname.

Edith would work brilliantly, lovely name.

As for Clara O'Hara... I love it but the fact that other people feel so strongly against it would put me off, sadly.

I love it

I think Clara O'Hara is a beautiful name, yes it rhymes but it flows so nicely. If you love the name go for it

Edith flows better but Clara is a beautiful name so I'd go with it anyway!

Minty O'Hara sounds good though.

Edith O’Hara is beautiful.

I like Edith but spelt like Edyth. For what it's worth I much before Clara

Edith O’Hara is lovely

Or Meredith if you want something more unusual

Flora
Stella
Oona
Emma
all work in place of Clara

or
Alicia
in place of Araminta which is nowhere near as mental as Clara O’Hara but is too awkward to say

Yes, you definitely can't use that.

My surname is Hill and one of my favourite names is Lily, but Lily Hill sounds a bit stupid so I've never used it. Same with Matilda nn Tilly.