So far Astrid is the only name I've come up with so far that ticks all of our boxes - I love it, my husband likes it, most people have heard of it but it's not overused, it's not complicated to spell or pronounce, and goes well with our (strong and simple but very uncommon, two-syllable) last name.
I'm worried I'm not 'cool' enough to have a baby Astrid, though, so I'd love to hear any general opinions on the name. Pregnancy has me doubting everything and decisions just feel very daunting at this point.