Harper Rose or Amelia Poppy?

[Mumtobeee2020]

Can’t choose between these two names for our daughter due soon!! Please help!

💛 Harper Rose
🧡 Amelia Poppy

Worried Amelia may be too popular but also worry with Harper being less traditional...
What are others thoughts? :)

Ohhh I love the suggestion of Amelie Rose

Amelie Rose (although it's not an actual OP option) is my favourite too.
Amelia is WAY too popular and over used.
Harper is going to be too "of the time" and will date them like Kylie and Karen.

Amelie is much prettier. It's classy and will age better.

Amelia is rather dull but Harper is awful.

Harper Rose sounds lovely

If you haven't read To kill a Mockingbird then choosing Harper is really cringe imho

Not Harper

Not Harper. I love Rose.

Amelia way too popular now. I like Harper Rose but I do agree it's a name that will date. It depends if that will bother you!

I love the name Harper

@LittleTiger007

Harper does not scream Beckhams to me, instead it evokes Harper Lee and the classic book To kill a mockingbird. It’s a classy name.

Thank you for this. Harper is a fine name.

Amelia Rose

Rose is lovely. Harper is Grimm - sounds as if someone didn't know what to call someone who plays the Harp.

Harper Rose is gorgeous!

Love Harper, Amelia is fine but overused and quickly becoming the "Alice" of its day. Dullsville.

Harper is fresh and very classy - makes me think of Harper Lee!

Harper was on our list for DS1 had he been a girl.

Amelia is thousands of times better than Harper, which is downmarket. Rose is lovely, better as a first name than a middle.

Much prefer Harper Rose

I'm not a fan of Amelia but Amelie is nice.

I really don't like Harper, it reminds me of the beckhams and is very popular for under 5s in my area. I don't think the Harper Lee connection really helps it as Harper is her middle name, after the surname of a doctor .. I think her first name is actually Nell ( if I remember from a level English!)

Amelia Poppy is my vote