Sophie or Lucy

[Pudding01]

I did one a while back with Lucy and Isobel & Lucy won by a mile! (Which surprised me)

So now trying it against a similar sounding name 🙂

DD is Erin... Not yet pregnant but TTC x

Still Lucy!

Both are beautiful names!

Love Lucy

Lucy, there are so many Sophie/as around and I just prefer the sound of Lucy. In my head all Lucys are blonde though!

Lucy (definitely and they are not blonde!)

Lucy

Lucy!! They are all blonde, all the ones I know.

Both lovely, but as there are more Sophies than Lucys, I'd go for Lucy.

Good chance of her being blonde @BendydickCuminsnatch (great name btw!) my DD is 😊

Love that I'm talking about an imaginary child lol But I promise I'm TTC x

Ditto blonde Lucys- the only one dark I “know” is Miss Penvensie ...
Actually saying that, Lucy in Snoopy has black hair... :)

Lucy by a mile
What boys names do you have, OP?

Yep, Lucy wins.

Well we may break the stereotype if she comes out darker 😆 I love the name. I've met two blonde Lucy's and one dark Lucie in my lifetime.

Boys we really struggle on and never agreed during last pregnancy... I love George 💕 But DH doesn't. Others we've talked about are: Adam, Joseph, Joshua, Jack, Harry & Toby x

Lucy but prefer Isobel

Love that you go for the more timeless classical names (Toby is the only one I’m not mad about).

Hope you soon get your BFP

Sorry just my opinion but I find them both quite dull, and they don’t hold a candle to Erin which is lovely. That said Lucy is the better of the two.

Thank you @Mollie85 😘 Toby was my least favourite too x

All opinions welcome @TroubledLichen.
Thank you 😊 What do you think to Isobel? x

I find both perfectly fine but a bit dull. So many of them. Sorry.

Sophie..

Both are lovely, but Lucy as less popular.

Probably just a result of my school days where every girl was called Emma, Lucy, Rachel, Sarah or Sophie! I love Isobel (probably because no one at school ruined it for me) but it is very popular for babies now, not that’s necessarily a bad thing. And for what it’s worth I love all your boys names, Joseph especially, it’s such a classic and you don’t hear it often these days. Good luck TTC

Sophie / Sophias are everywhere

We had the same 2 to decide between but OH had a childhood dog called Lucy so we ended up with a Sophie! It suits her and whilst it is fairly common I think Sophia is more so. She has been the only one in her class at nursery etc. It is Isobel/Isabella/Anabelle/Anabella that are all over near us! We also have an Emily and the other names we had were Zoe and Chloe

I prefer Lucy...when I was a baby I had a friend called Lucy, they used to call her Lucy locket never did know why, but I really like the name, definitely better than Sophie IMO. But that just might be because all I think of at the moment is a giraffe when I here Sophie, and I say Sophie multiple times a day .

both