Hey there,
My mother found a story that was written about your post and shared it with me. I wanted to reach out and share some experience.
My name is Autumn. I wasn't born in the fall. My cousin had a friend around the time my mom was pregnant whose name was Autumn and my mom decided she liked it. People ask me all the time "Autumn? Like the season?" or even sometimes I have to explain it that way (I live abroad currently so it actually helps to associate it with the season if they don't understand my pronunciation). I get jokes constantly, like "Can I call you Fall?" or "Do you have a sister named Summer?" People spell my name wrong. ALL. THE. TIME. Like, seriously...you learned how to spell it in 2nd grade. It's not spelled "Atom" or "Adum", and no, my name isn't "Adam". And yes, there's an 'n' at the end. (I even had a woman tell me once while I was working retail - I had a nametag - that she named her daughter Autumn as well, but she spelled it without the 'n'. Holy crap did that make my blood boil.) I even had a Brit ask me why Americans bother to name their kids Autumn when we don't even use the word to talk about the season.
Basically, I hear all kinds of jokes and comments about my name. The kind of stuff your mother might worry about. But I wouldn't change my name for the world.
Some people are asshats. But I guarantee that most of the people who are saying "Like the season?" are only saying that because they've never heard the name as a proper name before. That, or they don't hear it often enough for them to associate it as a proper name. It's most likely not because they think it's stupid. And if they do think it's stupid, fuck them.
I love my name because it's unique. I would even go as far as to say I am proud of it. I don't want to be just another Jessica or Brittany. I was heartbroken when my SIL decided to name her daughter Emma. It was the number one female baby name for that year and a couple years prior. But I also appreciate it because it IS a proper name. It's not some weird shit that parents want to make up for their kid to be different, whether it be weird spellings like Hayleigh or Ashleigh, or just things that were never proper names before, like Paisley or Apple. And even though it's a rather new name as far as names go (coming around in the 1970s), it's gaining popularity according to some baby-naming websites I've had a look at. And while I never hope it becomes an overly popular name, it would be nice to have my name readily available on gift shop merchandise (haha).
I hope you don't change your daughter's name. I may be biased, but I think you made a good choice. I hope you can ignore your mother's terrible opinion of your daughter's name, and maybe even put her in her place about being so rude and disrespectful of your choice. But please don't let her persuade you to change your mind.
I probably won't come back to this website again, but if you want to reach out, you can email me at [email protected]
Good luck,
Autumn