If I say Jonah, what do you think of?

[ICantDecideOnAUsername]

Erm, that's it really. Struggling with boys names (although don't actually know if we're team blue or team pink yet .)

My gorgeous DS- loved the name since sleepless in Seattle, then the NZ rugby player, the whale and then Jonah from Summer Heights High.
Didn't know the bad luck connection until I read it on mumsnet a few months ago but I still love it. Classic yet underused which is why I loved it. He occasionally gets called Noah by mistake or Jonas but that's rare.

Louis.

And I get "It Aint Necessarily So" as an earworm.

I love the name Jonah!

I wouldn't think anything if it was just said in conversation, but - like many names - if you ask me to think about it then I suppose I think of the little boy in Sleepless in Seattle, Jonah and the whale, and the fact that my friend at school used to think that Joan of Ark was actually called Jonah Vark!!

But if I were to meet a little boy called Jonah, I would think what a lovely name.

My cousin, known as Jonty, which I really like.

Whale

Bad luck.

I think of the whale in the word. But my sons BF is Jonah, it didn't come into my head when I met him. It's a lovely name. He too has a huge smile.

Jonah and the whale.

Smyrna 3 year old grandson

That should say MY 3 year old grandson
Stupid ipad

My DS has a best friend Jonah, too, never thought of him as anything but Jonah.
He's lovely, funny, chatty, sporty, brainy (secretly wishing he was my child?!)

How can a name be bad luck?

The name itself isn't bad luck but traditionally sailors have referred to someone who brings bad luck as being a Jonah. In the bible story God was angry at Jonah and created storm to have him thrown off the boat he was travelling on thus endangering everyone on board.

Then he got swallowed by a whale but escaped that too. So you could argue that Jonah was in fact very lucky!

Ah, I've never heard that before!

Satsumas

A couple at our church when I was a child announced they were having a baby by handing out satsumas. Their son was then named Jonah.

Maybe I'm over-thinking it. The more I think of the name the more I like it. I would probably do Jo or Jonny as a nn. Still have to get it passed the other half before it gets on the shortlist though.....

I don't get the connection between satsumas and pregnancy. Am I being thick? Nice thought though - I'm going through a satsuma phase at the moment.

Jonah Vark, love it! Sorry, our surname is not Vark but it would almost be worth a trip to the deed poll place .

As somebody else said when asked what you think of when you hear the name they may say whale etc, but when you meet a boy called Jonah you don't think of it.

Oh Jonah he lived in whale/ Oh Jonah he lived in a whale/ Oh he made his home in that fish's abdomen/Oh Jonah, he lived in a whale.

Ira Gershwin was a genius.

A whale

The Loner. Jonah the Loner.
Not sure if it's a rhyming slang thing but used to hear it down essex way.

Jonah Hill who I quite fancy.

Love the name it was a very close contender for DS3 but it's DH's friends nickname he is also quite fit.

Hang on - just because it's associated with a whale doesn't mean it's a bad name.
I mean - when I hear Noah I think "ark" but I love the name.

My DD has a name which means that everyone sings her name the first time they meet her. It wears off very quickly and then the association with her name becomes "her" rather than the "song".

Really like Jonah. Go for it.

I love it! But the nn Joe would put me off....I also like Josiah but similarly the possibility of the nn Joe would put me off!