Could anyone help me to edit my longlist for girls and turn it into a shortlist?

[YouCanBe]

By maybe giving me your favourite ten of these?

Astrid
Julia
Georgia
Sorcha
Seren
Elsie
Amy
Marnie
Harriet
Nina
Clara
Bonnie
Holly
Hazel
Rosalind
Hayley
Kirsty
Cerys
Clover
Annie
Sylvie
Katie
Gwen
Ailsa
Miriam
Natasha
Roisin
Catriona
Nesta
Betty
Susannah
Dorothy
Leonie
Anita
Lucia

Comments and opinions on any you hate or love also very much appreciated!

Harriet is the only one I really like

I only like these ones

Elsie
Marnie
Harriet
Nina
Miriam
Lucia

Elsie and Miriam were on my list for a girl (had a boy though).

Astrid
Julia
Marnie - I hate the film but the name is nice
Harriet
Clara
Rosalind
Miriam
Catriona
Susannah
Lucia

And the only one I really don't like is Bonnie. To me it's the Blue Peter dog.

Julia
Hollie
Lucia

Those are the only ones I particularly like from the list. I also have one of them for my dd.

Would ceren be pronounced geran? If so I like that too.

Astrid, Nina, Susannah,

I thought Leonie was my favourite for about a day, but really I am not sure yet at all!

I am glad that there aren't too many people coming on to say they hate 99% of them.

My favourites:
Elsie
Amy
Clara
Hayley
Rosalind
Katie
Gwen
Ailsa

Do you know what they all mean? For me that would make a big difference. The reason I like Amy so much is because of its meaning, loved. I don't know most of the others on your list, so I just picked what I like the sound of.

Also, several of these are originally nicknames - would you use them as they are or put the long form on the birth certificate so DD can use it when she's older? (e.g. Elsie/Betty = Elizabeth, Annie = Anna, Katie = Katherine). Kirsty didn't make it onto my shortlist but Kirsten might.

In order of preference:
Miriam
Susannah
Julia
Dorothy
Sylvie
Annie
Rosalind
Roisin
Gwen
Marnie

Top 10
Amy
Annie
Cerys
Georgia
Hayley
Holly
Kirsty
Leonie
Natasha
Seren

Top 5
Annie
Cerys
Holly
Natasha
Seren

Top 3
Annie
Holly
Natasha

Top 1
Holly

Leonie reminds me of that X factor winner (so a no) and she probably wouldn't thank you for calling her Gwen!

Bloody hell, that IS a long list!

Sylvie
Astrid
Sorcha
Clover
Hazel
Marnie
Julia (although I prefer Juliet)

there we are. Done.

Seren is getting very common popular indeed.

Is ceren pr geran?

I don't know what they all mean yet no, it is something I'd think about, maybe once I have cut a few. My book doesn't say Miriam means bitter though incidentally.

I probably would put Elizabeth on the birth certificate for Betty etc. yes.

Seren is pronounced pretty much phonetically I guess!

I have never seen Marnie. Maybe I should in case it totally puts me off that name!

Marianne is lovely too TSC, it nearly went on my longlist but I decided I slightly preferred Miriam. I do like the short Mari though... Don't encourage me to add another one on!

Georgia top like Elsie and Clara a lot too

My favourites are.....
Harriet
Nina
Clara
Bonnie
Rosalind
Clover
Betty
Dorothy

Astrid
Seren
Elsie
Harriet
Nina
Holly
Cerys
Clover
Sylvie
Roisin
Lucia

Seren
Hazel
Cerys
Ailsa
Roisin

Um... That's it. There are many that aren't bad but just not ones I could term a favourite/top ten

My favs would be:
Astrid (nice and strong)
Julia (also strong and classy)
Nina (LOVE it - soooo cool, but classic)
Cerys (on my shortlist for dd)
Gwen (again super cool)
Miriam (one of my all time favs)
Susannah (like nn Susie as well)
Leonie (love it)

My dislikes:
Amy (I find it really sickly, like a pink dolly)
Harriet (too horsey)
Holly (too chav)
Rosalind (too posh)
Hayley (round here would become 'Highly' and is very council estate)
Katie (boring)
Natasha (meh)
Roisin (most people can't pronounce it in England, but nice if you are somewhere people know how to say it)
Nesta (isn't that a brand of curry?)
Betty (old lady un-chic)
Dorothy (ditto)

Now make an excel spreadsheet and get all the votes in. Any dislikes get a minus point!