Hi OP,
I have Hashimotos too. To conceive and to carry a healthy pregnancy, your TSH needs to be between 1-2. A TSH between 2.5-4 is not ideal, but it is okay. Any higher and you have a very high risk of miscarriage. I found this out the hard way with my first pregnancy, as my TSH was 4.2 and I lost the baby as a result. I had to wait three months until my TSH was down to 2 before trying to conceive again.
If the pregnancy doesn’t miscarry, there are also sadly potential risks of developmental issues with the baby’s brain. The baby relies on mothers TSH for the first 13 weeks of pregnancy as baby thyroid doesn’t start working until second trimester, so it’s really vital that your thyroid is strong and working well before pregnancy to give the baby the best start.
50mcg also sounds like quite a low dose for such a high TSH. Although from experience the GP starts on the lowest dose (50mcg) and tend to add 25mcg incrementally until they’ve gotten to the right dosage, so it could take some time until you’re down to a TSH of 2.
It tends to take at least 6 weeks before doctors can really assess whether the levothyroxine dose is high enough, I’d suggest asking for a follow up in 2 months to see what your TSH is after you’ve gotten used to the meds. If it’s still high they will increase your dose. Let your GP know you want to try for a baby so that they can help get your thyroid in a strong place pre pregnancy.
With all of this in mind, I would put TTC on hold for the next 6 months or so, until your TSH is stable and consistently showing the same number, and that will put you in the best possible place for having a strong and healthy pregnancy.