Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Original poster

To have persuaded DP to not send his mums hubby a fathers day card?

26 replies

glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:14

DP is 42. He has a dad who is alive who he loves. His mum married a man who irritates us intensely (although he is not horrible) perhaps 8 years ago. This man has fallen out with his two sons, so (understandably) MIL feels for him on fathers day.

For the last 2 years she has called to ask us to send him a fathers day card- both times DP would have done it to please his mum although he really didnt want to.

I persuaded him not to (in fact I was that she would even ask) - but was I BU? Do others send their step-parents mother/fathers day cards?

Thanks!

OP posts:
Iggisonthesofa · 29/06/2010 22:17

You can get one for a step dad.
If we all stopped sending cards to people we don't like, Hallmark would go out of business.
I sense a family feud coming on, is it worth it?

PeedOffWithNits · 29/06/2010 22:19

she actively encouraged you to send one despite there being no love lost, as it were

very sincere then, this card sending idea?!!

PeedOffWithNits · 29/06/2010 22:20

oh and OP, YANBU

I always assumed step dad cards were for those actualy RAISED by a great step dad to send?

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:20

Nah, no family feud. I doubt she would mention it. I dont want to be unreasonable but it seemed wrong- would the card say 'dear dad?' or 'your like a dad'?

Just seemed odd- DP was not bought up by him. He is not a 'dad' to him in any sense...

OP posts:
Maylee · 29/06/2010 22:22

Yes YABU (based on what you said in your OP)

Your DP wanted to do something to please his mum and, ultimately, his step-dad (a man who you readily admit is not horrible. You persuaded him not to. All it costed was the price of the card and the stamp.

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:23

Thanks peedoff! Thats what I thought- he didnt bring DP up.

And she dosent know we find him irritating! We are all polite- he is her husband after all, even if we are not very keen!

OP posts:
Iggisonthesofa · 29/06/2010 22:24

You shouldn't have started the tradition. I'd wonder what I'd done if I got cards for 2 years and then nowt.
If your mum's felt strongly enough to phone you about it, I wouldn't bet that she won't be upset by it.

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:25

Maylee- I think it was calling someone 'dad' who is about as far from a dad to DP as you can get!

OP posts:
Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:27

Iggi- we have never sent him one! She just started asking us to the last couple years- I dont know why.

And its DPs mum, not mine. Mine remarried about 15 years ago but I dont send her husband one either. Never considered it TBH!

OP posts:
Iggisonthesofa · 29/06/2010 22:28

Ah, it's different if you haven't started it yet then. Don't!

Maylee · 29/06/2010 22:28

I see.

I have step-parents and trying to navigate through all the politics and keep everyone happy (and maintain some degree of sincerity) is a flamin' nightmare......

SalFresco · 29/06/2010 22:29

It's up to your DH, isn't it? If he didn't want to, you wouldn't need to "persuade" him, surely?

SalFresco · 29/06/2010 22:29

Sorry, DP

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:29

Oh phew, thanks iggi I was starting to feel very unreasonable!

OP posts:
Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:31

sal- he didnt want to, but felt guilty that his mum had asked and we didnt want to.

In fact I left it up to him but sort of made my opinion on it (load of nonsense) clear.

OP posts:
Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:32

Maylee- I know! Both my & dps parents are divorced and remarried- its lots of fun at Christmas...

OP posts:
Iggisonthesofa · 29/06/2010 22:32

It would be more meaningful for him to try to make up with his own sons, rather than make a fake son out of your DP (who was in 30s when they first met!)

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:35

Exactly Iggi! That's what I said to DP. He is full of pride and wont do it- but he is the dad- at end of day its down to him.

Terrible to disown your kids IMO.

OP posts:
SalFresco · 29/06/2010 22:37

Fair enough
I would probably have sent one of those cards that just says have a nice fathers day or whatever (ie you are not my father and haven't raised me, but here is a card anyway) but then I come from a family where it is easier to just do these mad things rather than to face ridiculous over the top fallout!!

Original poster
glitterkitty · 29/06/2010 22:44

Sal- I know what you mean- but MIL is very nice she would never mention it. Thats why I feel a bit guilty I think. But I still didnt want DH to feel he had to call him daddy

Ah we need a range of cards for this...

OP posts:
SalFresco · 29/06/2010 22:47

I suspect it could be a very lucrative market...!

GiddyPickle · 29/06/2010 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SalFresco · 29/06/2010 23:03

"You're not my dad, but you used to be married to my mum, but now you're divorced, but I still like you and I don't want to hurt your feelings...Happy Father's Day!!"

I'm going into business

saslou · 29/06/2010 23:15

YANBU.This man isn't your DHs dad, didn't bring him up and your DH doesn't love (or even like)him. It is an insult to his real father to send a card in these circumstances. Different if a step father has been on the scene since childhood and has loved and brought up a child

fernie3 · 30/06/2010 07:18

I send my step mother a card in mothers day she married my dad 4 years ago (about a year before I got married myself) and I didnt meet her until well into my 20s.

I dont have a particularly close relationship with her but I send a card as it is important to my dad as a sort of signal of acceptance I think. I dont see the harm myself if your husband thought it was the right thing to send it then perhaps he just wanted to make his mum happy? I would be a little annoyed if my husband "convinced" me not to send a card I wanted to send.

I dont feel at all that sending the card in any way insults my real mother, and it makes my father happy - plus seems to make my step mother happy so why not?