Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to have ignored this woman?

53 replies

gagamama · 01/06/2010 10:19

Please tell me if you think I have been horrendously callous, this happened yesterday evening and I still feel absolutely awful about it.

I was walking down a short alley between the station and a main road, it was starting to get dark and I was by myself. I was approached by a young (under 30) woman who was crying and had a small scab on the bridge of her nose, and was reasonably dressed but had no shoes. She approached me from the main road and cried "can you help me, I've been in an accident, I haven't even got any shoes (points to feet), I'm not homeless or anything, I just need some money to get the bus home." She was reasonably well-spoken, if that makes any difference.

Now, she had some coins in her left hand which I reckon were enough to cover her bus fare. She did have a very small injury to the face but it was dark and scabbed over and looked days old. She was wearing tights which weren't laddered or damaged in any way, which I assume they would be if she had been in an accident which had caused her to lose both her shoes. She was walking away from the main road where there were lots of people who would have been able to help her and may have witnessed the accident.

I stopped, looked at her for a few seconds, said 'sorry' and strode away. I'm torn between thinking this is a fairly standard begging (or worse) tactic and I'd have been an idiot to have shown her any weakness. But what if she'd genuinely been hurt, had concussion, was confused and wandering aimlessly looking for someone to help her? Should I have at least called her an ambulance? I'm ashamed to admit that I was worried that she or an accomplice would mug me if I got out my phone, but isn't that an awful thing to think? I'm usually very helpful to strangers but I just didn't feel comfortable helping this woman.

Was I being unreasonable? If you want some geographical context, this was in SE London. I also don't give to beggars (and there are many here) - I prefer to give to charities which will tackle homelessness or poverty. I'd rather this didn't turn into a debate about whether I should have given her money even if she had been a beggar, but I know this is AIBU...

OP posts:
DaftApeth · 01/06/2010 13:36

The 'crying boy' is also well known in Chiswick.

He scarpered, I believe, after a local went up to him and acted very pleased that they had at long last seen 'the famous crying boy' and that he was well known to everyone. After mouthing off, he ran away. Obviously moved on to Ealing!

Shaz10 · 01/06/2010 17:01

DaftApeth that's brilliant. I hope he was really gutted to discover that instead of being a dead clever beggar he was in fact a famous local oddity.

atomicsnowflake · 01/06/2010 18:57

There was a guy interviewed on Radio 4 about two weeks ago and he helped a teenage boy who was sitting on the street crying. He took him home where his wife was asleep upstairs and the bloke fell asleep on the sofa.

The teenage boy stole their car keys and ran off with their car whilst the couple were asleep. He did a joyride on their car and then drove it onto some railings and trashed it.

No good deed goes unpunished.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread