Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider egg donation?

75 replies

FrozenNorth · 21/05/2010 18:02

I'd quite like to be an egg donor. My friends and family think I'm slightly mad to consider it - it involves injections, ultrasound scans and surgical egg removal. The medical risks notwithstanding, they've also pointed out that there are ethical implications to contributing genetic material to a child I am unlikely to ever meet.

My rationale: I know a wonderful, loving family whose daughter was conceived via IVF with a donor egg. I'd really like to be able to help a family to have that kind of happiness. I have two daughters and since I'll turn thirty in a few years' time, now seems like a good age to donate.

I thought and thought about where to post this, and I'm still not sure I've found the righr forum for it, but I'm interested to get some feedback before I contact a nearby NHS fertility unit. Has anyone out there has ever considered it themselves? Or, if it's something that you don't think is a particularly good idea, I'd like to hear more about why.

OP posts:
rasputin · 28/05/2010 19:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

baiyu · 10/06/2010 12:54

So glad I found this thread. I'm PG with DS2 at the moment but have been thinking more and more about egg donation when I've stopped breastfeeding. I've a long way to go before making a proper decision but I would love to do it. I don't want more children so as long as the rest of my pregnancy and my baby are healthy I think I may go for it after that.

I have mild PCOS, do you think that would exclude me from donating? Not overweight and have had 2 normal pregnancies so far.

Just turned 25 so will hopefully be healthy enough.

sanielle · 10/06/2010 13:08

Baiyu I would think you would be more high risk with your PCOS for OHSS, I have it as well..

pcos.about.com/od/infertility/a/OHSS.htm

baiyu · 10/06/2010 13:28

So glad I found this thread. I'm PG with DS2 at the moment but have been thinking more and more about egg donation when I've stopped breastfeeding. I've a long way to go before making a proper decision but I would love to do it. I don't want more children so as long as the rest of my pregnancy and my baby are healthy I think I may go for it after that.

I have mild PCOS, do you think that would exclude me from donating? Not overweight and have had 2 normal pregnancies so far.

Just turned 25 so will hopefully be healthy enough.

baiyu · 10/06/2010 13:29

Oops, sorry! Ok thanks sanielle, I'll have a look at your link.

sanielle · 10/06/2010 13:31

Do as much research as you can before you speak to a doctor, although I think it is a really nice, selfless thing to do you can't put yourself at risk!

marenmj · 26/06/2010 09:00

resurrecting an old thread. treedelivery what you say really resonates with me. I am considering donating eggs. I've always thought of biology as being trivial to the making of a family. In fact, I really don't get people who have IVF and go through the process to have their own, biological child. If it was me and we had trouble conceiving, we had already decided to adopt. BUT, those other people aren't me, and if it's really, really important to them, who am I to judge or scorn that desire? And if I can help, even better.

Btw, re convulted family trees, my mother had an 'Aunt' who she thought was her dad's sister. When she was an adult she found out that the Aunt was actually her dad's cousin, whose parents had died, and the kids were spread throughout the extended family. Her grandparents have basically said it's "the way things were back then." It was common amongst their parents' generation for a widow to marry her late-husband's single brother so that he could take care of her and her kids, which would be a recipe for Jeremy Kyle now.

The group who I consider my family includes lots and lots of people who I have either no, or a very slight biological connection to. It's really interesting to see how much of what I thought I "knew" about my family tree changed and morphed as I become an adult.

I think I am ok with it, as I wouldn't see the egg/baby as "my" child. MY dd is my child, she has my sleepless nights and my extra cuddles and I would say who ever gives that to a donated egg is their parent, not me. I wouldn't mind being an auntie though

All of this MAY have been only slightly affected by the fact that DD is a shadow of her daddy - I don't see anything of myself in her, so I am pretty ok with the concept of not having maternal [genetic] input, even though I actually did - so am not attached to the concept of a progeny of mine loose in the world. I had to come to terms with my daughter not being like me a long time ago. (and I know she is still young and there's lot of time for her to take after me, but the twinges at my heart strings over having a girl who didn't take after me AT ALL have long faded)

Also, my mother is an old-fashioned (pre-IVF), identical twin. She has six kids, her sister has eight. Because they are identical, my cousins are, genetically speaking, my half-brothers. The only thing about it that is weird is when we all get together and find out we've been reading the same websites or bought the same car. My mom and her sister routinely meet to find that they've just got the same haircut within days of each other. IMO, having genetic half-siblings does not have the element of betrayal that, say, finding out your father had another child might - because you have your parents and they have their parents and no trust has been betrayed IYSWIM.

Anyway, my concept of family is fluid, and not really based in biology, so I think I'm ok with that aspect of it.

I'm just not SURE my own family is finished yet, so I am curious about the risks of future infertilty.

teaandcakeplease · 26/06/2010 09:05

Tree is away this weekend, as I'm on her ante natal thread. This thread may have dropped off her list as well.

But I'm sure if you contact her by CAT she can reply in due course

marenmj · 26/06/2010 09:16

I hope the OP doesn't mind either, in my novel I think I forgot to ask how she came out with her egg donation experience

teaandcakeplease · 26/06/2010 10:00

Oh sorry didn't realise you were different

Well her amazing original thread is here

happyjules · 26/06/2010 15:30

I would have given serious consideration to being an egg donor if only I had been younger when I had my children, inspired by the fact that it took 3 years to conceive dd1 (with a mc in that time too.) I was fearful of he possibility I may be sub fertile. (I'm not thankfully). I am also very matter of fact about body parts and donation as I am also a blood doner, on the bone marrow register and my self and my daughters are all on the organ donor register. I still feel sad at times when I know that I wont be able to be a egg donor.

marenmj · 26/06/2010 18:29

thank you, happyjules - I'm happily rounding 28. DD was a surprise and conceived in spite of birth control, so I'm pretty sure fertility isn't a problem . It means we started our family a few years earlier than we planned, and I am very aware that if I am going to do this, I should start thinking about it now. If it really does mean I can't get pregnant again afterward, then I still have time for my own before the clock runs out. I too am on all the donor registries, except for my kidneys, which DH has first dibs on (he only has one)

teaandcakeplease thanks! I'll also pop over to that thread. I did a search and all the other threads I saw were very old. This one seemed slightly less old and I was considering starting vitually the exact same thread

treedelivery · 29/06/2010 22:32

Hello, I;m tree and I wa san egg donor

I was very very privileged to see the bump last weekend.
I can honestly say I had not an ounce of 'ooo that's my bump and baby'. Not a bit. It was very clearly her bump and her baby.

Bloody marvellous. They have kindly said again that I can visit when they have the baby, and I cannot wait to see the 3 of them. Just amazing.

treedelivery · 29/06/2010 22:34

Also, having read my post in this thread, I should add that were I to have another wedding [hopefully not as I had a very nice one a few years back] or any sort of gathering I would certainly invite the couple now

marenmj · 30/06/2010 00:21

Thanks! I am ever so slowly making my way through your other thread. I wanted to get the info on the process from someone who's been through it. I didn't think the fertility clinic would give me 100% unbiased info.

I've read a lot that says it is like IVF, but I've never had IVF so that doesn't really help me

gtamom · 30/06/2010 00:29

I wouldn't do it myself. I don't like to think a child of mine would be put there being raised by people I know nothing about. Plus so many children are out there needing to be adopted into a loving home.

marenmj · 30/06/2010 20:24

yes, I think someone upthread said something similar, but I think the difference is that I wouldn't see it as someone else raising my child because I wouldn't see it as my child.

I've said I would adopt if I found out I couldn't have kids for exactly the reason you've given, but I think if a couple has gone to the trouble of IVF etc, they probably aren't going to be in the adoption market anyway. Perhaps the (genetic) source of the baby matters a lot to them, and they have decided they will settle for one that is at least 50% their child?

Mumcentreplus · 30/06/2010 20:30

couldn't do it..my eggs are myy own..not something to be shared ..jbh..

treedelivery · 30/06/2010 20:36

My eggs are my own too. I chose to share and try to help. So I made a gift of 9 of them. I have a crazy number left should I need them, and 2 amazing children to fill my heart.

Spread the love I say!

Mumcentreplus · 30/06/2010 21:12

Nice for you tree just not for me..I could not think of 2 other children out there who are genetically mine living without my input and love..selfish?...I dont really know..its a very personal thing..I would rather give a kidney than an egg

4madboys · 02/03/2011 16:47

bump, this seemed to be the most recent thread on this issue.

anyhow its something i am considering doing, as in have given all my details and am in process of arraging all the relevant blood test/counselling that i have to have to go ahead with it.

was just looking for experinces/thoughts etc.

i just think i am 32, i have been lucky enough to have 5 beautiful, healthy children, if i can help another couple to have that gift then that would be lovely, to put it crudely my eggs are just going to go down the loo each month, i dont need them so why not give some away.

i realise i wont be annonymous and that a child may want to contact me in 18years etc, but i think i am happy with that. that child would never be mine, genetically they would be 50% of me but their parents would be the mum who carried and grew/birthed that baby and then raised it and her partner, i would just be donating a bit to help that happen? or at least that is how it feels to me? :)

any further thoughts/experiences welcome :)

PepsiPopcorn · 02/03/2011 17:30

I think it would be a wonderful thing to do, 4madboys. It would mean so much to a childless couple to have someone make their dream come true by donating an egg to them.

MadreInglese · 02/03/2011 17:34

I have done this and would be happy to chat to you about it off board if you want to PM me

Meikyo · 02/03/2011 17:47

Just want to thank the OP for considering egg donation. I had a m/c after natural conception, then a failed IVF with my own eggs. We needed a donor egg and were lucky enogh to be matched after only an 8 month wait. After 5 years in total of trying to conceive, I gave birth to my beautiful DD, now 8 years old. I often think of the egg donor, especially at this time of year (anniversary this month!)and will always be extremely grateful to her. Ours was part of an egg sharing IVF programme so our donor was undergoing treatment for herself in any case, but still a wonderful gift to us. Donors are amazing-thank you.

4madboys · 02/03/2011 18:38

thanks madre that would be great, have diner to sort and small baby to feed (dd is 12wks) but will pm you later :)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread