Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to end this so-called 'friendship'?!?

69 replies

PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 10:58

I've known this person since we were teenagers, her Dad used to work with my Dad and we lived a few streets away from each other. We always got on OK and have continued our friendship as the years have gone by. Her and her partner are DH's friends too and we've often got together for evenings and had a brilliant laugh. When I had DD2, she fell in love with her and was very supportive etc, but she kept buying her outfits and clothes (DD2 was in and out of hospital for the first six months). One time, she brought an outfit round, then told me it was £8 and did I need change from a tenner, I was gobsmacked!!! I've always said, "you shouldn't have" and stressed it, because we can't afford to buy things for her - we have 3 children to feed whereas she has 3 cats and a dog...

So, last year on her birthday, DH and I were going through an extremely rough time - in fact I had thrown him out because he was severely addicted to cannabis and I couldn't cope with it anymore (long story!). He stayed over there a couple of nights, then in a hotel as he needed to get away from other smokers. I'm proud to say that he has been clean for a year now (apart from the odd joint here and there that I've found out about after but he was smoking @ 20joints a day before). Anyway, I digress, it was her birthday and DH was round there, but things were friendly, so I went round and gave her a card and spent a little while there. A few days later I got a text telling me she felt hard done by because she buys stuff for us all the time but I didn't get her anything for her birthday! I replied saying I thought she would appreciate me turning up under the circumstances, and that I hadn't been in any fit state to go out shopping and had been skint. (which she knew because DH had given them money for food when he stayed over). I got her a few little bits a few days later and apologised.

In the year since then, we haven't seen as much of them - in fact the last time we went round, she sparked up a joint while we had DD2 with us, in the same room!!! We made a hasty exit of course! There have been times when she has needed a lift or something, and I've happily given her a lift, we even lent them our car when I was recovering from my hysterectomy - it was just sat there so it was no cost to us. When she did her knee in, she rang me and I rushed round there and took her to hospital, and took her to the follow up appointments, physio etc. I just thought this was friendship and didn't think twice about it.

So, a few weeks ago, I thought I'd best get her something for her birthday after last years antics. I found a few little things on ebay (not much money wise but I was sure she would like them!). I even checked with her DP whether I should get the fridge magnet or the keyring, he said a keyring... Royal Fail took its time with one of them and it wasn't here in time for her birthday, I was gutted and explained that I was waiting for something to turn up for her.

I should say, that on our birthdays, we are expected to go round there and collect our presents, when I've told her she really doesn't need to get us presents, a card will do. So, her birthday comes, I texted her to say happy birthday, she had previously said she would be leaving the house straight away that morning so I wouldn't be able to drop her pressie off as she wouldn't be there. She replied saying she would be in for the next hour or so - but I had a migraine so couldn't possibly have driven. I knew she was disappointed, and so was I but what could I do!!?? So I said I'd wait for the other bit of her pressie to arrive and drop it off when it did. Then she posted on fb that her DP had got her a keyring and she couldn't believe it as she had just got rid of a load - OH MY GOODNESS!!! After all that, she really didn't want a bloody keyring, but it was of her favourite character so I thought I'd still have to give it and tell her if she wanted me to change it, I'd be happy to.

So, when it arrived, I texted her to say it was here - I knew she was in because she's been having work done on the house so I suggested I pop round with it. She asked if I could post it because the house isn't visitor friendly - I said of course...

So, it got posted through the letterbox inbetween me picking up kids and dropping off stuff and doing all sorts of things as DH has done his back in.

Then yesterday morning, I thought I'd check if she got it or not, but then saw on fb that her status reads something like this: Doesn't know what to say but now knows what some people think of her!!

DH commented saying that I was worried she was talking about me and that we thought she liked the particular character that the keyring was... No reply...

Then DH got a message from her saying that she got me a lovely pair of shoes for my birthday and that she felt hard done by and that it wasn't fair!!!!! We were fuming - I haven't even mentioned all the other things we've done for her, because as far as I'm concerned I don't tot up theses things, friendship isn't about that!!!

I have sent her a message telling her I'm devastated that she thinks that material things reflect what I think of somebody, and whatever happened to 'its the thought that counts', and that I'd rather call it a day because I will not be judged by what I've bought people, I really didn't think she was that shallow and that I'm gutted. Also I'm really hurt that she posted it all over fb - how childish is that!!!!

I'm hurt and angry but writing it out here has really helped, well done if you've got this far lol!!!

AIBU!!??

PLP

OP posts:
SolidGoldBrass · 08/05/2010 11:03

She sounds completely mental. I'd have ditched her long agao.
Thing is, when someone tiresome has been in your life for a long time, it's hard to summong up the strength to actually tell them to piss off, so I owuld suggest just letting it fizzle out, be 'busy' when she calls etc. And if she does turn up with things she has bought for you and asking for the money, say you don't want the things and can't afford them and basically refuse to hand over the money.

ilovesprouts · 08/05/2010 11:06
Confused
BrokenBananaTantrum · 08/05/2010 11:06

YANBU

i will agree with what SGB says and just let the friendship fade

i can't believe she bought stuff for your baby and then wanted you to pay her for it. I think that's beyond rude

Feelingsensitive · 08/05/2010 11:06

She's a loon. Get rid.

wukter · 08/05/2010 11:07

She sounds very childish, and used to people pandering to her.
AS SGB says let it fizzle out. I couldn't have someone live in my ear like that.

BAFE · 08/05/2010 11:11

Is she 8 years old?

Just stop buying her presents. Then she'll stop buying you stuff. Simples.

Pozzled · 08/05/2010 11:12

How very materialistic, and self-centred- she seems to have no understanding that your financial circumstances are different.

I think if it were me, I would try to have an open conversation with her before losing the friendship, explain that you tried hard to find a present that you thought she would like, went to the effort of speaking to her DP etc. Tell her that you were hurt by her reaction. If she apologises, great, but if not then you will know how things stand and can just move on.

PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 11:17

Thank you all, have to go out food shopping now but will pop back later... I'm so angry! I'll be interested to see what her reply is, will let you know...

OP posts:
SugarMousePink · 08/05/2010 11:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LoveBeingAHungParliament · 08/05/2010 11:31

Cull her, if you don't want todo that then agree now that neither of you will be doing pressies from now on.

CheekyRedWineGirl · 08/05/2010 12:33

No you anbu she sounds like a right cow

piratecat · 08/05/2010 12:41

I think i would email too. I would give it, until i felt I had really thought of exactly i wanted to say tho.

I would ignore any further contact, and give yourself a day or so to write.

The expectations on her side are very odd, and she seems volatile.

maristella · 08/05/2010 12:51

i think that whatever you do next, you need to realise that your life has become entwined with hers; to such an extent that she has high and unrealistic expectations of you. if you do decide to maintain the friendship, maybe you could loosen the ties a bit?
but it does sound as if you have really outgrown her. you already have children, you don't need to pander to another

hatesponge · 08/05/2010 13:20

I can slightly see why she would be pissed off tbh....she buys you a present which I presume you liked (and am guessing because it was shoes is something she knew you specifically wanted? can't imagine buying someone shoes I didnt know they liked/coveted)and in return you get her something that she specifically didnt want!

To me it seems less about the financial value (her gift being more £ than yours) than that you've given her something literally a day after her saying she's just got rid of a load of similar things. Does she know you already had it by then, or does she think you just cba & bought it after her comment, irrespective of them?

It sounds in any event as though your friendship has largely run it's course. You seem to find it a hassle to buy her a present so going forward agree you should tell her that you wont do presents in future - so long as you're prepared for her to stop buying presents for the rest of your family as well.

PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 16:44

Hiya,

"I can slightly see why she would be pissed off tbh....she buys you a present which I presume you liked (and am guessing because it was shoes is something she knew you specifically wanted? can't imagine buying someone shoes I didnt know they liked/coveted)and in return you get her something that she specifically didnt want!"

I specifically remember her saying that she had got me something for my birthday and my response was "honestly, you are very naughty, I really would be happy with a card as times are hard!". I hadn't asked for shoes, I'm not a shoe person really, but they were purple and she knows I love purple. She has a thing for the muppets and loves Gonzo, so knowing that, I got a coaster and a keyring of him - the keyring thing came out after her birthday, rather than before...

I know she means well, but if you received a present that you were disappointed with, would you say something to that person, or even worse, comment about it on facebook!? She is a very generous person but at the same time, she clearly expects material things in return! A few weeks after they had the car, she came round with some bits for me (nail varnish etc), saying it was to say thank you for having borrowed the car - I made a point of saying then, that there was no need to buy me anything and I don't expect anything in return - I do things out of friendship, not to get things back...

I must stress though, that the time she asked for the money for DD2's present, was a one off, she's not done it again, perhaps she sensed my shock!? On DS's birthday, she put money in a card for him and got annoyed that he hadn't picked it up - I told her she really shouldn't give him money as I know they've been skint too. Her response is always that she wants to do it.

I agree, this really has run it's course. It just feels like I'm obligated to be friends with her. She often has run-in's with other friends and I get the impression that they just beg for forgiveness and apologise if they upset her - I have a backbone and I'm not scared of her!

I just don't get it, she really is a nice person but this is all too much for me now. I don't lose friends easily, especially after so many years, but maybe it is time for this to fizzle out...

Thanks all for listening to me waffle, it really is cathartic!!!!

I'm off to do tea for the kids, thank you again

PLP xxx

OP posts:
firsttimemum77 · 08/05/2010 17:08
  • what is she - like 7 years old...?
verytellytubby · 08/05/2010 17:16

She sounds so immature and really odd about presents and money.

jenduff · 08/05/2010 17:25

I think that you're better off without people in your life who make you feel upset - ditch her until she grows up

pigletmania · 08/05/2010 17:31

how old is she btw, 6! My goodness, even if she did not like what you gave her she should have just smiled and thanked you, and asking for pressies my god how low, its like begging tbh. I would be well rid of her, not a true friend imo.

foureleven · 08/05/2010 17:39

she is a needy, materialistic loonatic.

If you are not one then I dont think you should be friends really.

Some of my friends are loonatic but what they lack in normalness they make up for in kindness so I let them off.

Youre not getting naything in return for your friendship to this person.. oh except birthday presents.. which I assume you can live without?

pigletmania · 08/05/2010 17:43

Love your pictures Purple, your kids are soooo cute . This is one friendship you can do without tbh

gomummygo · 08/05/2010 18:05

YANBU at all, I would just let the friendship fizzle out, persnally. She doesn't sound like someone I'd put a lot of further effort into being "friends" with. Buying things for your DD2 and expecting to be paid for them is particularly bad taste, imo.

PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 18:06

Just got a reply from her, basically saying she wasn't looking for a fight or expecting an 'end of friendship' type thing. And have I considered how this will effect DH and her DP's friendship? She says it's not about material things and she is definitely not shallow, she is upset because I didn't even knock the door and she had only said it was difficult in the day with all the builders etc. She says she has learnt her lesson about being so generous, but she has enjoyed buying DD2 all the presents as she'll never be able to do it for her own DC's. (not able to have kids). I had ended my first message with the word 'gutted' and her last sentence is 'if you think you're gutted, try being me!'.

She knows I have DC's to deal with in the evenings - as it turns out I had a car full of children, one not mine as I was giving her a lift. She asked me to post it!!!! If she enjoyed buying all the presents, why moan about it. And most of all, why post it all over bloody facebook!!!!

I'm not sure I should respond until at least tomorrow. At the same time, I know this will be playing on my mind all night...

OP posts:
PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 18:06

Thank you piglet! I must update them tbh lol

OP posts:
PurpleLostPrincess · 08/05/2010 18:17

I'm now feeling rather sad about the whole thing . Must stop thinking about it all the time!!!

Roll on BGT...

OP posts: