Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wish that my MIL wouldn't call so early on my husband's birthday?

65 replies

chaya5738 · 04/12/2009 09:45

Every year on my husband's birthday his mother calls at the crack of dawn (ie: 6 or 7am) to wish him happy birthday. They then spend about 15-20 minutes on the phone while he opens his gift from them, ooohs and aaaahs, and catches up on gossip. This inevitably means that EVERY year she is the first person to wish him a happy birthday and by the time he has got through the phone call with her the moment has sort of deflated a bit. And then his sister will call and it will be the same thing again. By the time he gets off the phone he only has a few minutes left before he has to get ready for work.

I have mentioned this to him and he replies that that is just how it is done in his family - they love being the first to call. My feeling is that that was all very well when they were his nuclear family and he was at boarding school but now we are his nuclear family and we should be the first ones to wish him happy birthday. It is tricky to raise this with him as I don't want to ruin his birthday by having a fight. We had a terrible fight one year about it and I don't want a repeat. I have thought about raising it the night before - saying that would be mind letting us be the first to wish him happy birthday - but each year, like a fool, I hope that maybe his mum will be a bit more considerate and not steal the moment from me.

I have had to resort to getting up earlier and earlier (and inevitably waking him up earlier and earlier) to beat them to it. I have thought about turning the phone off but feel like that would be deceitful.

This year was the first year that we have a daughter together and I got up early to make him breakfast and put her in her "I Love Daddy" t-shirt. Just as we are going through to wake him the phone rings - it is his Mum. I asked him not to answer, and he didn't, but then he made sure he called them back as soon as he had opened his presents from us and then spent the rest of the morning on the phone.

In fairness, I should point out that his family all live overseas so they don't catch up a whole lot (although they do talk on the phone 1-2 times a week). There is a 12 hour time difference between here and there so they could wait a little later to call or alternatively call in the evening or when he is at work.

So what do you say girls? Am I being unreasonable, petty, or jealous to expect them not to call so early or at least make their phone calls short so we can actually enjoy the birthday morning together as a family?

OP posts:
FabIsVeryHappy · 04/12/2009 19:07

OFGS I couldn't read all the op as I was so .

In the split second that he is awake before he answers the phone wish him happy birthday then.

wonderingwondering · 04/12/2009 19:15

I think phoning at 6am is intrusive, you are lying in bed together, you don't want phone calls at that time even if you are awake! I think from 8o'c is fine, you're up and doing, but 6am would irritate me.

But the OP makes it sound as though her gripe is the MIL intruding on the present-opening ceremony, which is a bit barmy. As your DD gets older, you can put MIL on speakerphone and add her to the general chaos!

My in-laws used to phone at 10pm or later - we had to ask them not to in the end. Late at night and early morning is private time.

2rebecca · 04/12/2009 22:14

When I was a child it was the other way round in our family in that it was very much regarded as the birthday person's duty to phone relatives on my mum's side and thank them for presents before they phoned to wish you happy birthday.
My mum used to get upset as she had left it "too late" if grandmother or one of her sibs got on the phone to us first and we had to hurriedly do thank you phone calls as soon as we got home from school so they didn't have time to phone us first. Equally barmy.
My dad's rellies were more laid back.
Why do some people make an unnecessary competition out of stuff?

cat64 · 04/12/2009 22:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

NotAnotherNewNappy · 04/12/2009 23:02

I would be annoyed too. But boarding school? Living 12 hrs time difference away? It sounds like she's calling that to assuage her guilt of not really being 'there' for him. Leave them to it and enjoy having him to yourself 24/7.

My DH would well up if I put DD in an 'i love daddy' T-shirt

BitOfFun · 04/12/2009 23:20

I would suggest you initiate birthday sex at one minute past midnight and then have a smug lie-in.

leeloo1 · 04/12/2009 23:41

I'd agree that calling that early is annoying - as is the 1-upmanship, but if they've been doing it forever then better leave them to get on with it. So YANBU to be upset but YABU if you cause a fuss about it.

I do think that the boarding school bit has a lot to do with it! I had an ex-boyfriend who had been at b.s. and his parents made a v big deal about calling/presents on birthdays. The 1st year we were together they rang him a few days beforehand to check their (huge box of) presents had arrived in time - but in my family its the done thing to hide all presents/cards that arrive and then give them in a pile on the big day! I was at uni when they rang so there was a big worry about their ickle boy's gifts being lost! I did find that he was very worried about any criticism (real or imagined) of them and I think that the b.s. thing had given him a real insecurity about his whole relationship with them. (Met some of his other b.s. friend's who had various weird parental things going on too)

Can't really add to other advice, but would say to try and be glad they have a good relationship and that as you won't be able to change this (and it'll just upset everyone if you try) then try and rise above it and laugh if they want to be 1st (along with doing Bitoffun's b'day sex thing - then you can be v smug knowing you really were 1st) and make b'day tea be your special thing.

Oh and I think the I love Daddy t-shirt sounds lovely! I got my DS some 'Mummy's little pudding' bibs last halloween - which really were naff but he so is!!!

Lalalucy · 05/12/2009 14:24

I can't believe that you've actually had a big fight over this! How bloody insecure are you?

How sad and petty of you to be jealous of a fricking phonecall once a year. Why not stay awake the night before and wait until its one minute past midnight. Then you can wish him happy birthday in the knowledge that you were there first.

pagwatch · 05/12/2009 14:27

I often struggle to get in a quick "Happy Birthday" before DH has to go downstairs and make my early morning cup of coffee and start cookingthe DCs breakfasts.

He could wait a moment. He is so inconsiderate at times....
[sigh]

GibbonInARibbon · 05/12/2009 14:35

I would like to say that Pag, as always, has made insightful and thoughtful posts

YABU but I am in the gentle camp, try and let it go and enjoy your birthday time with DH.

Also ignore the dig at your DD's T Shirt, that was rude and bad form .

nearlybeans · 05/12/2009 14:35

Wife and mother sound remarkably similar

bran · 05/12/2009 14:38

Am I the only one who has to be reminded by her DH that it's his birthday? I'm not a morning person so he usually allows me to get half-way down my cup of coffee before he starts singing "happy birthday to me".

DH's family live 7 time zones away and I couldn't honestly tell you whether any of them phone on his birthday or not. I would be a bit pissed off if they phoned at 6am, but only because I hate being woken up any earlier than I have to be.

YABU to resent them phoning him.

GroundHoHoHogs · 05/12/2009 15:17

OP, on the morning of the birthday, when the phone rings, pick it up, without saying anything, run to DH shouting HAPPY BIRTHDAY DARLING... Phone call for you... and hand him the phone....

Job done!

pigletmania · 05/12/2009 15:33

YABU so what no biggie get over it imo.

Stigaloid · 05/12/2009 15:43

YABU

New posts on this thread. Refresh page