Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DH being unreasonable for not wanting to book a hotel?

93 replies

StripeyKnickersSpottySocks · 05/11/2009 19:30

We have a 7:30 flight from Gatwick to catch, we're at least a 4 if not 5 hour drive from Gatwick. I'm guessing we need to check in at 5:30am at the latest.

He just says that we can drive down during the night. With 8yo DD, then a flight, then a 3.5hr transfer the other side.

Just because he doesn't want to spend £100 on a hotel which includes parking, we'll have to spend £50 on parking anyway.

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 06/11/2009 13:41

YANBU, that would be a dealbreaker for me. I wouldn't go on the holiday if I had to arrive in such crap condition.

Tell him he needs to pay for the hotel or you won't be going.

Is this guy a total dick or something? You've paid for all the xmas pressies and he won't pay for a cheap chain hotel on a family holiday? What gives?

Even my DP and his mates are staying overnight at Gatwick on their way to a stag party in USA. There's no excuse for families. Stand firm.

girlywhirly · 06/11/2009 14:23

Stipey, this is what my exh and I did when we first married, and it worked well.

Each spouse has their own current acc. into which salary is paid.

Each spouse has a sole credit card for personal use. If you buy shoes and bags, you pay for them with your own salary, and he can't complain.

A joint names credit card for food, car expenses, hols, gifts etc

A joint current acc., into which is paid by standing order, four fifths of each spouses net monthly pay. The remaining fifth is each spouses own to spend as they wish. This joint acc. then has mortgage, council tax, bills direct debits, insurances, child expenses and joint credit card etc paid from the funds within. This can be added to if the monthly pay varies, as with bonuses or overtime, again this extra can be divided, four fifths to the joint acc., and remainder kept by the spouse in question.

I know there is always a risk with joint accs that in theory one holder could clean out the whole lot and blow it, but it does mean you are able to access the credit card yourself for family purchases without having to ask for the card.

I hope your dh wouldn't get obsessive and start doing excel spreadsheets of joint acc expenditure each month, like my ex!

alicet · 06/11/2009 14:34

girlywhirly is your ex my dh?!!

He has excel spreadsheets for our finances. This was against my religion when we met - I was a 'if you pay with plastic it's free and I'll stick my head in the sand about the bills' type before we got together.

Begrudgingly I think the financial planning and separate savings accounts for holidays / car etc is great - probably makes us obsessive but it works!

We have a joint account for all joint purchases and each have a small amount a month to call our own to pay for anything we do on our own and clothes etc. All joint / children / work stuff comes from joint account

ImSoNotTelling · 06/11/2009 14:36

Thing is girly, that works well when both working full time, but when one goes off on mat leave/goes part time/stops work entirely that leaves them with potentially nothing for themselves.

Which I still think is unfair. I don't see that someone should have to go without haircuts and clothes etc while their partner has £££ of spare dosh.

Morloth · 06/11/2009 14:45

Fabster the best way to get the thousands in the bank is to worry about the hundreds.

neenz · 06/11/2009 15:21

Why keep a fifth each? You should get the same as eaxh other to spend how you like.

DH earns x10 what I earn but we both get £200 a month for personal spending. If he kept one fifth for himself that would be totally unfair and would leave the rest of the family without.

Stripey your set-up sounds very unhealthy and almost like a game or a competition, and because you don't seem the least bit defensive about it I think you know it.

neenz · 06/11/2009 15:23

'I know there is always a risk with joint accs that in theory one holder could clean out the whole lot and blow it,'

You should not be married to someone who you think could do this to you, and certainly should not have kids with them.

girlywhirly · 06/11/2009 16:29

Well, ImSo, I admit that we were both working full time, and on nearly equal salaries. As time went on, he got a much better paid job, but was still putting in four fifths, probably three times what I was contributing. I did have a baby, and did quite a bit of overtime before mat leave. My money lasted until I returned to work when DS was 5mths.

The thing is, we had saved to buffer our finances to tide us over the mat leave, and could cope financially.

Obviously when couples circumstances change, the financial arrrangements should too, by mutual discussion. People can arrange the proportion of what they contribute to suit the circumstances - full time four fifths, part time two fifths for example. It doesn't matter how you do it, the point is, you are open and honest with each other and discuss it, not keep one person short and the other holding all the purse strings, making unilateral decisions about what shall or shall not be spent. I was just offering a suggestion for Stripey to consider. It seems her dh is being very evasive about their finances.

AliceT, I so hope not, for your sake! Does he go through supermarket receipts and moan about what you buy?

Neenz, it is possible to not know this will happen to you, in cases where spouses develop addictions to gambling, drugs, run up massive secret debts, and swipe all the money in desperation. As told to me by a financial advisor who had to sort out these situations. By the same token, if you are separated/divorced you should never hold a joint signatory savings account on behalf of a child/ren of that marriage, as that could be withdrawn in the same way, both parents being able to withdraw money until a child is 7 and able to hold an account in their own name.

Fibilou · 06/11/2009 17:05

Stripey, my husband earns treble what I do but wouldn't dream of considering it "his" money. It's our money and if he started taking the attitude that your husband is taking I'd have been off a long time ago.

He must be amazing in some other way to make up for this is all I can think. Why does he punish you for staying at home with his children by ensuring you get less money ? It seems absolutely extraordinary to me.

bellavita · 06/11/2009 17:26

Fibilou - my husband earns far more than I do like yours, but he would never ever pull stunts like this.

My friend (who is going through a rather messy divorce at the mo) - her husband actually comes out with £7000 a month after tax, yep you read right. He made her go to work and pay for all the childcare and her own car. She earns about £900 a month. He bought her a mountain bike but she had to pay it back at £50 a month. I can certainly say they have no huge outgoings. My DH said men like this are tossers.

Fibilou · 06/11/2009 18:57

F*ck ! No wonder they're getting divorced

bellavita · 06/11/2009 19:12

She said that he told her that he took her out from the gutter and that he wants her to remember where she came from so that is why she has to work!

Fibilou · 06/11/2009 19:27

Who did he think he was, some sort of medieval fief ?

Fibilou · 06/11/2009 19:28

Mind you, I'm sure she'll enjoy his comeuppance when the family judge deals with division of the assets

She is going to have that agreed by the courts, isn't she ?

ImSoNotTelling · 06/11/2009 19:34

Reminds me of that human league song...

Hope she takes him to the cleaners bella.

bellavita · 06/11/2009 19:46

Oh yes girls, she is taking him to the cleaners and is in the process of going to court at the moment....

oldraver · 07/11/2009 12:33

I was thinking £7000 a month thats one hell of a CSA bill, he'll wish he had been a better DH to her

Fabster · 07/11/2009 17:14

Yes, Morloth. Clearly you have to save small amounts to get big ones but this is just ridiculous. I just hope he doesn't crash the car and kill them all because he falls asleep while driving through the night.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread