Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really let down by DH on my 30th birthday?

84 replies

birthdayblues · 30/08/2009 20:51

Sorry, this is long and pretty dull, but genuinely don't know if I am being unreasonable nor not so would appreciate your verdict.

Have namechanged as my DH knows who I am on here. Not that I think he checks, but still...

Before our son was born, I used to make the most enormous fuss about birthdays. Other peoples' but also my own. I'd always have a party or drinks, and my husband would make a real effort with gifts (this isn't about money, btw, by "effort" I mean thoughtful)and to take the day off work so we could celebrate.

Obviously since having a baby, our priorities have changed a bit and birthdays no longer hold the significance they once did. I do mark them (For example, for DH's birthday I arranged a sitter and we had a lovely lunch and saw a film - something that's a real treat as we never do this now we have DS) but not in a full-on way.

However, I turned thirty a few days ago.

I should say here that I have been a bit curmudgenly about it. Trying to organise any social event when everyone has babies is nearly impossible, and also I've just had two miscarriages in a row, so have not been very "up for it".

DH asked me a few times if I was having a party and I said no, I couldn't be doing with a big fuss at the moment. He confirmed with me that I wasn't just saying that but was actually expected a big surprise party and I repeated that I wanted something very low-key.

None the less, I did expect DH to make a bit of an effort, because it was my thirtieth. Nothing mindblowing, just a nice meal out or something. I didn't explicitly state this, but I didn't think I needed to.

A couple of months ago he had asked me what I wanted for a present, and I said that I was so sick of the state of our living room and what I really wanted was to finally get some curtains and a rug. He was very enthusiatic about this idea as he finds present buying a bit tricky.

Now the sitting room really gets me down and getting these things genuinely would make me much happier, but part of me did resent the fact that these very basic householdy things were going to be my birthday present, particularly as they've been on our to-do list for about a year. Still, whatever. I assumed that he'd get me a little something that was more personal too.

Two days before my birthday, DH asked if I wanted him to book the day off work. I assumed he'd already done so, and said this. He then got a bit narky and said that I should have asked... We left it at that but were clearly a bit pissed off with each other.

On the actual day, DH did make me a nice breakfast but my presents were five paperbacks and an IOU on my card for the rug and curtain as I'll need to choose them.

The actual day consisted of: lunch at a kiddies restaurant (Giraffe), treking round a gallery that we ended up at as everywhere was heaving due to summer hols and wasn't really anyone's cup of tea and which DH and DS whinged about, pasta and pesto in front of a DVD.

So...not great from my POV. I mean, he could have booked a table for us all to have lunch. He could have booked tickets for the zoo or something a bit more special than usual.

I didn't make a big deal out of it becuause I didn't want there to be bad feeling, but I was really quite upset at his lack of effort.

Tonight as I was feeding DS, I was looking at the sitting room glumly(ok, I was doing it quite ostentatiously as I wanted to prompt him) and he said, "So, what are we going to do about this rug and curtains then?"

FFS! Would it kill him to suggest a date or try even slightly to make it something that is not totally my responsibility to organise? It's supposed to be my birthday present. Not some tedious household chore to be fitted in between unblocking the drains and loading the dishwasher.

I'm really fed up with him, but I know that if I call him on it he'll be all injured and say, "but you said you didn't want a fuss!". I know that's what I said, but there's a difference between not wanting a fuss and someone barely making a token effort to acknowledge that it's my thirtieth birthday!

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
WebDude · 31/08/2009 11:31

YANBU - surely he could twig that household items were not much of a present (had been on to-do list), and of benefit to him and any visitors.

OK, breakfast in bed. nice start, but I'd think that standard on a birthday. Seems lucky you got that (booking day off work should have been a 'given').

Having booked a day off, he clearly didn't think out what would need to be done, like booking a table somewhere nice for lunch and planning (asking colleagues if he's hopeless for ideas) some activity suitable for you all. Full credit to him for checking you were not expecting a surprise party though.

No, can quite understand, though as some have pointed out mindreading, subtlety-detection, and simply being thick are common in men (myself included). I think ravenAK's suggestion about plain speaking might be the way to go.

Hope he understands that while he did make an effort, it only reached a bit below 'bronze' given the things that could have been better.

MmeLindt · 31/08/2009 11:34

Household items are ok as birthday gifts, if they have been agreed to beforehand.

I begged DH for years to get me a food processor for my birthday as I really wanted one. I ended up buying one myself as he would not. Cause he thought I would bash him over the head with it.

I know I am sometimes irrational, but not that irrational

AvadaKedavra · 31/08/2009 11:37

You are being completely and utterly U.

Nancy66 · 31/08/2009 11:44

My god you are being SO unreasonable and spoilt and childish.

he asked you over and over if you wanted to do anything special and you said no. then you threw a strop because he wasn't going to take the day off work.

In the end you got: breakfast in bed, gifts, a day out and the promise of more gifts.

He is doing the rug and curtains thing because YOU suggested it.

You sound very immature.

Thingiebob · 31/08/2009 11:49

You sound like you are feeling down and grumpy and because you didn't have fun on your birthday you are taking it out on your husband despite you making it clear you didn't want a fuss.

Despite this he -
He took a day off work
Made you breakfast
Got the present you wanted
Got you extra presents
Went out with you the kids for the day

If you had enjoyed yourself on the day, would you be posting this?

WebDude · 31/08/2009 11:50

(I wrote that yesterday night, and now see there were quite a few YABU comments in the meantime...)

I stand by what I said, it was a 'special' birthday for you, after all, and he knew how much you had done in the past when it came to birthdays, so could surely have guessed that even if a night out wasn't achievable, a few books may not cut it, and the (unplanned) gallery visit was the least awful option, that might have been avoided if he had used some brain cells beforehand!

(At this point, must remind others that him taking the day off hadn't been arranged weeks ago, so like so many men, he hadn't given the birthday much thought anyway! Seems he forgot effort made for his birthday to turn out nice...)

Hopefully he will see it from your side, if you explain "thanks but still feel a bit upset" (as fandango75 put it, with a bottle of wine and a smile).

TotallyAndUtterlyPaninied · 31/08/2009 11:56

Oh dear, you're not too happy about turning 30 are you? Sounds like you've had a naff time lately too. I think perhaps anything DH did would have irritated you, but it's not very nice for you that he hasn't said 'tell you what, Saturday we'll go in search of your prezzie and have a nice lunch'. I don't think he's realised how down you're feeling, and I think he thinks he's done his best.

So you're not being unreasonable to feel how you feel, but he's not being unreasonable either. You are expecting him to read your mind a bit, and I think he needs to be pointed in the right direction.

Have a word

MrsEricBanaMT · 31/08/2009 12:10

Yes, YABU, sorry.

Never assume, and all that. Go give you DH a hug and say sorry for being a grumpy pants

MrsEricBanaMT · 31/08/2009 12:11

and maybe go have a chat with your GP maybve? Not being funny, but you sound like you are having a hard time seeing the positive side of things which suggests to me a hint of PND.

ThingOne · 31/08/2009 12:37

YABU. If you tell someone you want something low key that's what you get!

Lunch at a nice child-friendly restaurant along with a child-friendly outing is pretty standard here for birthdays.

I'm a firm believer in telling my husband exactly what I want and what I want to do.

slowreadingprogress · 31/08/2009 12:56

yep, YABU. Very. Blimey, he won't be able to do anything right if doing what you actually ask for is wrong!

slowreadingprogress · 31/08/2009 12:58

and, tbh, you shouldn't have asked for rug and curtains if you were going to 'resent that these were going to be your birthday present'....

you have been so utterly unreasonable on this one, IMO.

Sorry by the way to hear of your miscarriages, you have clearly been through alot lately.

IdontMN2makecopyforlazyjournos · 31/08/2009 13:03

YABU, completely and totally. He asked if you wanted a party, you said no. You specifically stated you wanted the day kept low key. Lunch at Giraffe, a troll round a gallery and a DVD snuggled on the sofa sounds like bliss to me.

He asked you what you wanted for your birthday, and then moan about it.

He made you breakfast and took a day off work. I wouldn't dream of expecting my husband to take the day off work for my birthday - DS's yes. Mine or his, no. I go to work on my birthday so I can't expect him not to!

Either you are the most high maintenance woman in the world, or this is a wind up.

Blondeshavemorefun · 31/08/2009 13:14

yabvu

you told dh you didnt want a fuss/party and when he queried this again you said low key

a day with your dh and dc, having lunch etc sounds nice

if you wanted a party/night out then you should have said

he has left the choice of rugs/curtians to you, so you can get what you want - again a selfless deed by dh

so sorry to hear about the mc and sorry you didnt enjoy your day

but sounds to me you have a lovely dh who tries to please you

Milliemuffin · 31/08/2009 21:55

I disagree with all the YABU's. Yes you didnt want a big fuss but is it too much to ask for a little effort and thought on his part rather than him just going along with the flow?

You didn't want a party cos of all the fuss but it was still a special day for you or should have been.

There's a difference between wanting a fuss and wanting to feel special, even if its just for one day. I hoped my 30th would be a day to remember, DP bought some bits online and blew up a balloon. whoopee.

cjones2979 · 31/08/2009 22:09

I totally get how you feel birthdayblues.

I will be 30 on Wednesday. It is also DS2's 1st birthday the same day. I had to ask DH to take the day off.........he asked "why?"
FFS!!!!!!!
I have had to organise the meal out in the evening by myself, he wouldn't even have thought about sorting it.
As for my pressie, it is a lovely Links of London watch, but that's only because I chose it myself. He hasn't even wrapped it, it is still sitting in our wardrobe where I put it.
I guarantee that he won't even suggest us going anywhere in the day.
BUT...........I know he is like this & have come to expect it. I know he loves me, but have come to the conclusion that even if you do keep a dog, you still have to bark yourself !!!

Happy belated birthday !!!

TheFallenMadonna · 31/08/2009 22:11

Do people take days off work for birthdays? Gosh.

cjones2979 · 31/08/2009 22:33

I wouldn't usually ask my DH to take the day off, but as it's my 30th and our DS2's 1st, plus DS1 doesn't go back to school until Thurs, thought it might be nice if he had the day off to spend with us all.

SixtyFootDoll · 31/08/2009 22:37

You sound like a spoilt child to me

BreevandercampLGJ · 31/08/2009 22:56

I was 30 on a Friday. I spent the weekend waiting to find out on the Tuesday, just how bad my cancer was.

GET OVER YOURSELF

MrsEricBanaMT · 31/08/2009 23:10

LGJ, I had no idea.

GreensleevesFlouncedLikeAKnob · 31/08/2009 23:11

Oh shit, LGJ

I didn't know

BreevandercampLGJ · 31/08/2009 23:20

It was a longish time ago, and with top notch care, and follow up care, it has become a distant memory.

My point is, that whether it was last week, or last month it would have been more "important" and I use the term advisedly, than what the OP was "expecting".

You guys don't know, because it does not define me, IYKWIM. But equally posters carrying on in a ridiculous manner re birthdays (especially 30th's) brings me out in spots.

Thats all over and out. xxxx

flipflopper · 31/08/2009 23:42

hey, be kind to her- she has had 2 miscarriages!
She just wanted her dh to surprise her and give her a lovely day- they have in the past made a big fuss of birthdays.
I dont think she is unreasonable at all.

Sometimes we just want men to read our minds and do something really nice without having to tell them!

MrsEricBanaMT · 01/09/2009 08:50

So are you are in remission LGJ?

I do agree with Flipflopper too though. This is a support site, and some of us are't battling the worst life has to throw at us, but are still battling non-the-less. The OP sounds to me like she has a touch of post-natal depression that she needs to nip in the bud. That's not to be sniffed at.

But thank zod you're on the mend. x

Swipe left for the next trending thread