Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really let down by DH on my 30th birthday?

84 replies

birthdayblues · 30/08/2009 20:51

Sorry, this is long and pretty dull, but genuinely don't know if I am being unreasonable nor not so would appreciate your verdict.

Have namechanged as my DH knows who I am on here. Not that I think he checks, but still...

Before our son was born, I used to make the most enormous fuss about birthdays. Other peoples' but also my own. I'd always have a party or drinks, and my husband would make a real effort with gifts (this isn't about money, btw, by "effort" I mean thoughtful)and to take the day off work so we could celebrate.

Obviously since having a baby, our priorities have changed a bit and birthdays no longer hold the significance they once did. I do mark them (For example, for DH's birthday I arranged a sitter and we had a lovely lunch and saw a film - something that's a real treat as we never do this now we have DS) but not in a full-on way.

However, I turned thirty a few days ago.

I should say here that I have been a bit curmudgenly about it. Trying to organise any social event when everyone has babies is nearly impossible, and also I've just had two miscarriages in a row, so have not been very "up for it".

DH asked me a few times if I was having a party and I said no, I couldn't be doing with a big fuss at the moment. He confirmed with me that I wasn't just saying that but was actually expected a big surprise party and I repeated that I wanted something very low-key.

None the less, I did expect DH to make a bit of an effort, because it was my thirtieth. Nothing mindblowing, just a nice meal out or something. I didn't explicitly state this, but I didn't think I needed to.

A couple of months ago he had asked me what I wanted for a present, and I said that I was so sick of the state of our living room and what I really wanted was to finally get some curtains and a rug. He was very enthusiatic about this idea as he finds present buying a bit tricky.

Now the sitting room really gets me down and getting these things genuinely would make me much happier, but part of me did resent the fact that these very basic householdy things were going to be my birthday present, particularly as they've been on our to-do list for about a year. Still, whatever. I assumed that he'd get me a little something that was more personal too.

Two days before my birthday, DH asked if I wanted him to book the day off work. I assumed he'd already done so, and said this. He then got a bit narky and said that I should have asked... We left it at that but were clearly a bit pissed off with each other.

On the actual day, DH did make me a nice breakfast but my presents were five paperbacks and an IOU on my card for the rug and curtain as I'll need to choose them.

The actual day consisted of: lunch at a kiddies restaurant (Giraffe), treking round a gallery that we ended up at as everywhere was heaving due to summer hols and wasn't really anyone's cup of tea and which DH and DS whinged about, pasta and pesto in front of a DVD.

So...not great from my POV. I mean, he could have booked a table for us all to have lunch. He could have booked tickets for the zoo or something a bit more special than usual.

I didn't make a big deal out of it becuause I didn't want there to be bad feeling, but I was really quite upset at his lack of effort.

Tonight as I was feeding DS, I was looking at the sitting room glumly(ok, I was doing it quite ostentatiously as I wanted to prompt him) and he said, "So, what are we going to do about this rug and curtains then?"

FFS! Would it kill him to suggest a date or try even slightly to make it something that is not totally my responsibility to organise? It's supposed to be my birthday present. Not some tedious household chore to be fitted in between unblocking the drains and loading the dishwasher.

I'm really fed up with him, but I know that if I call him on it he'll be all injured and say, "but you said you didn't want a fuss!". I know that's what I said, but there's a difference between not wanting a fuss and someone barely making a token effort to acknowledge that it's my thirtieth birthday!

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Eirlys · 30/08/2009 22:04

Sorry I think you're being a bit unreasonable.

It's fine to be a bit peed off because you didn't get the birthday you wanted, but unforutnately men aren't mind-readers....

SycamoretreeIsVile · 30/08/2009 22:09

Oh dear. You sound exactly like me, but unfortunately YABU.

Men do not mind read. We really, really want them to, but they do not.

You cannot hint. You must spell it out. That way, you won't be disappointed.

You should never have agreed to the rugs as a present for you. You should have said that one of your presents would be for him to research nice shops to look in and plan a day to do it.

You should have said you don't want a BIG fuss, but you want him to make some effort in smaller, more intimate ways to show you that he still loves you blah blah.

Honestly, if I've learned anything in all my years of marriage it's that some plain speaking goes a long way. You can deal with in 5 minutes what can otherwise go on for a week.

Talk to the man, tell him what's on your mind. He loves you, it's obvious. He will be glad of some clear instruction from you as to how to put it right.

hambler · 30/08/2009 22:19

YABU . You asked for curtains and a rug. He got you this AND 5 books. What a fab gift!
Breakfast in bed! What are you complaining about?

You KNOW you are being unreasonable

nellynaemates · 30/08/2009 22:20

YABVU, your DH sounds great.

wrongsideof40 · 30/08/2009 22:25

Agree with dogofpoints - YABU - he sounds like a lovely bloke who really tried to please you. It's not fair to expect him to 'read between the lines'

Portofino · 30/08/2009 22:25

YABU - he asked you and you said you didn't want a fuss/surprise party. He asked about gifts and you told him you wanted household things.....As others have said, men have to be told!

pjmama · 30/08/2009 22:26

Sounds to me like he did exactly what you asked but it wasn't good enough.

Portofino · 30/08/2009 22:29

Just to add, last year it was my 40th. I took matters quite in my own hands. We had takeaway pizza and a wine box on the day in question, but it was on the beach in St Tropez!

Silver1 · 30/08/2009 22:32

TBH He made sure you didn't want a big fuss, he bought you surprise gifts, gave you breakfast in bed and took you out for the day (to many men this would be a huge fuss) He took the day at your pace-and you are pissy with him for it-wait and see how much he tries next year!

YABU

Firawla · 31/08/2009 01:06

YABU it really does not sound that bad, i don't think there is much there to complain about. should be more greatful? perhaps next time make your expectations more clear as it seems your dh is willing to put effort and try to meet your expectations, after all he did get you what you asked and would be unfair to say he didnt put effort as he took day off work and did take you out @ lunch

claw3 · 31/08/2009 01:24

You said you wanted something very low key which translates to you wanted something special

You said you wanted a rug and curtains which translates to you wanted something personal

You didnt mention him taking a day off work, which translate to take the day off work.

Perhaps you should get him mind reading lessons for his birthday!

Happy birthday btw

ravenAK · 31/08/2009 01:31

I think he tried to please you every step of the way, tbh.

Next year just say: 'I don't want a party, but I'd like you to take the day off & take me out for a nice meal, & I know we're getting the living room curtains, but I'd quite like a lovely present from you too'

(& make helpful suggestions re lovely personal present).

If I were your dh, I'm afraid I'd be finding the whole birthday thing a bit scary now!

hairymelons · 31/08/2009 01:39

My 30th was a disaster too but DS was only 8 weeks old and I was as mad as a box of frogs!

My 31st was last week and it was the best birthday i've ever had. My gifts from DH were 1) the promise of an hour long back massage and 2) homemade chocs (nicked from work, DH is a chef).

Now, we've been together for nearly 10 years and I've had many a terrible gift from him- I've had an electric foot warmer; tickets to chitty chitty bang bang (as a life long hater of musical theatre); some godawful jewellery etc. etc.

This year. for the first time in years, I had a great time. I realise now that the reason was I'd totally lowered my expectations.

I know 30 is a big one, but often the pressure makes it disappointing. Maybe celebrating full stop is difficult for you both right now and maybe your OH doesn't know how to spoil you without overstepping the mark. DH confessed recently that he was so terrified of getting it wrong, he'd get in a blind panic and not be able to think of anything to do! He did have bad form though...

Tell him how you feel and exactly what kind of treat you think would be nice then everyone's a winner. He sounds like a nice, caring chap, maybe just needs a shove in th right direction.

mrswoolf · 31/08/2009 01:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

lilacclaire · 31/08/2009 01:51

I think yabu as he did make you breakfast, bought you a present and tried to arrange a day out (albiet, it didn't go exactly as planned).

Saying that, I would have been disappointed as well, as I always secretly hope that a fuss will be made, there will be some big suprise etc despite me insisting im not bothered about all that.

I think men need to turn into mind readers tbh.

saadia · 31/08/2009 04:15

Agree with everyone else I'm afraid - yabu, you said you wanted to keep it low-key. It is hard to read mixed messages.

Bumpinthenight · 31/08/2009 07:45

My DH bought me an electric blanket for one of my birthdays.

He learnt in time for my 30th!!

Tell him explicitly what you want and what you want to do or you won't get it. Little hints don't work, trust me!!

Happy Birthday!

LittleSilver · 31/08/2009 09:23

Maybe a tiny bit unreasonable. I do see where you are coming from, especially if you are the kind of person who really goes to town on birthdays. BUT remember he is a man and therefore incapable of reading nuances - eg "low-key" and interpretations of.

If it akes you feel any better DH has NEVER bought me a birthday present. But then he is rubbish at that kind of thing - and I've learned - I just use the joint account card to buy mself something nice.

Bathsheba · 31/08/2009 09:45

No wonder men say they don;t understand women..!!!

Its not his fault that your birthday is during the school holidays, so where you went on your day out was busy...!! If you had wanted a day at the zoo then say "I'd love to go top the zoo on my birthday"....you went for a day out but even then that wasn;t right...

My birthday is in December. I always go Christmas shopping on my birthday - I can;t turn round now and say I want to do sunbathing....which to me your expectation that somewhere child friendly should be quite on you (school holiday) birthday is akin to.

Did you expect him to pick the rug and the curtains and have them wrapped up with no input...well no, because then he would't have got stuff you like.

Now you want him to arrange some formal "curtains and rug shopping day" which is full of symbolic "Look, this is your treat"....ehm, pick something from the Next Catalogue and move on.

I think you need to apologise to your DH immediately - it sounds like he gave you a lovely birthdya and you sulked throughout for absolutely no reason which makes you a spoilt princess.

OrmIrian · 31/08/2009 09:49

Poor bugger! He can't win can he Next time marry a clairvoyant.

MmeLindt · 31/08/2009 09:59

YABU

You said that you did not want a fuss.

You said that you wanted a rug and curtains.

He brought you breakfast in bed. A couple of books as well as agreeing to the furnishings, and even asked when you wanted to start looking for furnishings.

He took the day off work adn you had a day out.

I feel quite sorry for him, tbh.

piscesmoon · 31/08/2009 10:02

YABU-he kept asking you questions and then went along with everything you said and tried to put something of his own in (I think books are a fab present). I think you need a claivoyant! He was supposed to spot what you weren't saying, which was in direct contradiction to what you were saying!
I find with men that you have to make things clear i.e if you want a romantic occasion say so.

mayorquimby · 31/08/2009 10:31

yab completely unreasonable.
he did everything you asked for and more.
asked numerous times if you were just saying you weanted something low-key but were really hoping for a fuss to be made and you insisted you werren't.
then when he does exactly what you asked for and more, you try to paint yourself as some put upon martyr who is keeping a stiff upper lip as you don't want to ruin the mood but by your own admission you are sitting there looking forlornly at your sitting room.
i don't even think this is a case of men not getting subtle and needing it spelled out for them as some are suggesting, he tried to read the subtle hints and you dispelled them by explicitly stating what you wanted and getting exactly that.

GrendelsMum · 31/08/2009 10:39

Yep, YABU.

He asked what you wanted and then did it. You got the big presents you asked for and then a special little present of five books that he'd put time and effort into choosing. Now, it sounds like actually you're not a great reader and you don't think that books are a proper present, but many people would be delighted to receive one book for their birthday, let alone five.

WidowWadman · 31/08/2009 10:49

So he's done everything you asked for with breakfat on top and you're sulking? I'd be very pissed off if I were him.