Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...not to want to contribute to DD's friend's expensive birthday present?

52 replies

muffinmonster · 16/07/2009 18:41

DD is in Y7 and will be 12 next week. Several of her friends are also celebrating 12th birthdays around now. She told me the other day that a group of schoolfriends have decided to pitch in £20 each in order to buy one of the girls an expensive (£90 to £100) phone for her birthday. I have said no to this because:

(a) DD doesn't have £20 so I will be expected to pay (as I expect at least some other mums will), and this is double what I normally spend on birthday presents (except for children I really like!).

(b) I have recently ruled out buying the same phone for DD herself as I feel it's too expensive a piece of kit to be carried round by a 12-year-old.

(c) I have very little confidence (based on past experience) in the ability of DD's friends to organise collecting money and purchasing a phone in time for the birthday, especially as school breaks up tomorrow.

DD thinks I'm mean and I realise I'm putting her in an embarrassing position, but I can't believe I'll be the only mum to object.

OP posts:
whatmaisieknew · 21/07/2009 17:01

wrong for so many reasons...here's 3 to start with:

  • too much money
  • children should learn to resist peer pressure in a discriminating way
  • do birthday girl's parents know about the plan ? I wouldn't want a group of friends buying a phone for my 12yo, at £100, £50 or any amount !
BitOfFun · 21/07/2009 17:07

Her parents might disapprove of her having a phone, especially an expensive one, and she may get mugged by other kids for it. I would call the parents of one of the other girls, say why you want to say no, and ask her to back you up. Then the plan will be down the swanny and normal service will be resumed.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page