Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect my dp to tell his family what his daughter's full name is?

34 replies

weebump · 14/06/2009 21:11

Myself and dp aren't married, but have a little girl together, and when she was born we discussed surnames. He said he wasn't too attached to his surname (lets say it's "Bloggs"), as his parents divorced when he was young and his mum brought him up on her own. I, on the other hand, quite like my name (let's say it's "Jones"), and always knew I wouldn't change my name if I got married. So when our dd was born she was given my surname - "Baby Jones", no middle name or anything else.

She's now 1.5 years old. Earlier in the year dp's dad sent a card to our dd with the Bloggs surname on it, and it occurred to me then that he didn't know she had my surname. DP didn't correct him.

This morning dp and his brother were on skype. I heard his bro call her the wrong name - Baby Bloggs. It occurred to me that dp's bro hasn't been told otherwise. DP didn't correct him either.

So I said afterwards that it was interesting they all call her by the Bloggs surname, when that's not her name. DP didn't see the issue. Then I said I thought it was a bit misleading for him not to tell them what her surname was, that they should know. Well, he didn't like that at all! Got very upset with me for saying he was being misleading, when it was something he didn't actually even think about. As far as he's concerned her name is her first name only, and he wasn't being misleading, he just hadn't told them. And I was at fault for bringing it up after the fact. Why don't I tell them myself next time they do it?

AIBU??? I really think they should know, especially her granddad, and I think he's the one who should tell them. They're his family. I ended up apologising for saying he was misleading, simply because he got so annoyed, but I shouldn't have apologised, because I think he is being misleading! Aaargh!

OP posts:
weebump · 15/06/2009 00:43

zipzap, we had a naming party for her and had a cake with her name on it, but funnily enough it was just her first name!

I think he's told his mum, but she wasn't too pleased, apparently. So I can only guess he's a bit nervous of telling the others. It just seems odd to me . (btw, his family don't exactly talk much to each other, so his mum's probably not told them either...)

OP posts:
YMC · 15/06/2009 13:57

Look at something like this

Label all of her belongings with her name - clothes, beakers, bags, toys; anything she has with her when she sees them. Job done.

minouminou · 15/06/2009 14:22

I had a (only slightly) similar situation with DP's very elderly relatives.....
DS' and DD's surnames are double-barreled, with my surname first (not because I'm some kinda raging femmo, but because with DP's first, it'd sound like a merchant bank).
Anyhoo....congrats card arrives for DS from this old couple, along with a little present, and they've got their barrels mixed up.
DP was more taken aback by it than me, but didn't want to directly correct them, as he was worried about upsetting them.
So, by return of post, they got a nice birth announcement, with photo, and DS' full name, along with time, weight, thanks for the present etc....this made it look like it was a routine announcement, and not a gentlr correction.
No probs since....I think someone had said he was double-barreled and they assumed it'd be bloke 1st.
Could you try something like this - an "official" family pic, or nursery pic, and send them round to a few people, with her name on it?

spina · 15/06/2009 14:26

my in-laws never for one second presumed that they're precious first grandchild would have anything other that his dad's surname despite the fact that I didn't have the surname as i wasn't married to dp (at time). When i did marry "said party" I took my child's surname(I do love my DH, but have never felt the need to take anyone's surname or in fact marry but that is a differant thread!)I'm still Mrs Maidenname at work.

Perhaps it was easier for your dp to be passive about "that" conversation. Perhaps his family don't give two hoots but he thinks they will.

Someone needs to mention to them though or you'll end up with a very upset baby jones at some point when she has tried to explain her name and the grown ups have told her she's wrong!( This happened to my son with regards school he was due to attend. A school visited his nursery and thought he was on their list so spoke to him about how exciting their school was.The whole time my ds1 kept saying "i'm not going to school B.I'm going to School A."He was told he was mistaken. It was the first time he realised that grown ups are always right!)

simplesusan · 15/06/2009 17:34

I think minouminou has made a very good suggestion. You cpould get something ready for her grandad for father's day and possibly sent to other relatives too, just so grandad knows there is no mistake.

weebump · 15/06/2009 22:20

Hhmmm, yes, a printed name on a photo..... That sounds like a good idea, min.

OP posts:
PrettyCandles · 15/06/2009 22:30

Both my parents and my ILs couldn't get their heads around the fact that we had double-barrelled our names. I corrected my own parents several times (in one ear and out the other) but didn't feel I could do so with my ILs. So I ensured that every single written thing sent to them - birthday cards, dc's artwork, etc - was signed with proper, full names. Eventually they all got the message.

It is important to clarify the issue for your dd. I have two first names, my given one - which was only ever used by medics, and by new teachers at the begining of the school year - and what I've always considered to be my real name, the one that was and is always used. It caused me a lot of confusion, and I remember asking my parents to explain it when I was 6. My situation had an unavoidable and completely acceptable reason. How are you going to explain to your dd?

Debs75 · 15/06/2009 22:43

It could be a pride thing.
Tradirionally you are married and have taken hubby's name when you have kids. He may feel that his family think your dd should be named in the 'proper' way. with your partners surname.

Personally I feel kids (and hubbies) should have the mothers surname as you are 100% sure that said kid is the mothers child. Not saying that your child may not be your dp's but do you see what I mean. If you remarried then you wouldn't have the hassle of having a different name to your child's and you wouldn't hack off exh by changing childs surname

My kids however have my dp's name. he told me we would get married but that was 14 years ago and at the time I didn't like my surname

SugarBird · 15/06/2009 23:17

It's a tricky one - the longer your DP leaves telling them the harder it will be but the 'official' photo idea is a good suggestion for making your DD's proper name known.

DP and I are not married and we gave our kids my surname, with DP's surname as a middle name. We told all the family at the time but even though they know what the boys' names are they all wilfully ignore this and insist on doing double-barrels or just giving them DP's surname on birthday cards etc.

The DC (they're teens now) understand that the older generation gets its knickers in a bit of a twist about this kind of thing and as it doesn't seem to bother them, it doesn't bother us tbh. If it upset the boys we'd be firmer about it, though. And I would be very annoyed if DP hadn't told his family what their names were right from the start!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread