Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest that enforced national food rationing might help solve the nation's obesity problem?

350 replies

Lucia39 · 30/05/2009 00:13

During the period 1939-1954 the nation's diet was, apparently, the healthiest it has ever been.

So would a similar regime assist helping those who are increasingly "dimensionally challenged"?

Vegetables, fruit, and pulses would be more freely available but meat, dairy produce, sugar and fats would be strictly rationed.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
Gorionine · 30/05/2009 16:37

I hope for you it is included in therations Starbear, if not I can smugle some from switzerland soon!

Starbear · 30/05/2009 16:41

My Gran was a smuggler during the Spanish Civil War & beyond. Best time of her life she said. Until she ended up in prison in the late 1950. She wasn't really a nice woman. My Mum and aunt ruined her career! So I'll work it out it's in the genes

Starbear · 30/05/2009 16:42

Gorionine We could go into business I could dress like one of those girls in 'Allo,Allo'

Gorionine · 30/05/2009 16:47

Oh! a smuggling grandma that is interesting! I have a grand father 7 generations ago though, arround the times of the French revolution who was the last man to have been hanged in my county, because he ploted with a few friends to kill some rich people who were "bleeding them dry" and hook them on a bridge at the entrance of the town. They did get arrested before though because the wife of one of them confessed of their intentions to the town's priest who went straight to the autorities with the info!

Gorionine · 30/05/2009 16:47

x posted! LOL @ your last post

Starbear · 30/05/2009 16:51

Gorionine Wow! what a history. Should have hang the priest too! I thought confession was sacred. If we went into business how would you dress?
I've asked the question but must go now the sun is shining

Laquitar · 30/05/2009 16:54

The poor woman (OP) should listen to brightongirl and seek counselling. She obviously has huge issues.And and obsession with 'fat people'. I am wondering if she has children. And if her Dh plays that game she talked earlier in front of them .

OP stop starting stupid threads and seek some help.

Gorionine · 30/05/2009 16:54

I will think about some sort of camouflage, I will have to probably stay in hiding now anyway after what I said in another post on this thread!.

expatinscotland · 30/05/2009 17:01

you reap what you sow, people, especially when it comes to feeding trolls.

Laquitar · 30/05/2009 17:07

i agree Expat.

but look how many people took the time to type proper and serious posts . if you mention the words 'food' and 'fat' they get over excited.

blueshoes · 30/05/2009 17:19

Lucia and a food thread.

edam · 30/05/2009 17:32

Lucia, I don't know why I'm wasting my breath on someone who never, ever, makes any attempt to take on board another point of view... but here goes anyway.

My godmother was, in fact, in touch with people up and down the country. She was heavily involved in the Labour movement, as was her entire family. She talks about her experience of the war, indeed, but also knows a damn sight more about the wider experience of other working class people than almost anyone else around. Not just her own family, but the wider world.

Dismiss her as one person if you like, but she is MUCH more impressive and has a much more distinguished life than 99.5% of the people around today.

Unlike most of us lucky enough to be live in Western countries she has seen starvation up close. When she was a child, people who dared to get involved in the fight for political representation of the working classes were often thrown out of their jobs and homes. Including my godmother herself, when her father dared to stand for the council. (The mine owner was a Tory who told his workers how to vote.)

She also trudged the streets of Manchester with her mother in order to raise funds to set up the first birth control clinic there. Even though it was clearly intended for married women, people spat in their faces.

She also helped members of the International Brigade who survived the Spanish Civil War get back into this country, when the government was trying to keep them out.

But hey, I'm sure YOU know much more than her about the social and political history of the 20th century.

RumourOfAHurricane · 30/05/2009 17:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

MachuPicchu · 30/05/2009 17:44

Wow edam your Godmother sounds really interesting - has she written about any of her experiences?

SummatAnNowt · 30/05/2009 18:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

nkf · 30/05/2009 18:54

I thought the wartime diet was considered to be healthy because until then many people lived below that level.

Baisey · 30/05/2009 19:49

Ahhh Lucia39 I think your husband might be my boss he also plays the spot the fatty game on quiet days at work, it drives me insane.
Enforced bedtime. We could have a Cbeebies type bedtime hour with Cerrie and the other bloke singing the song!!
As for enforced rationing, its the most ludicrous thing ive heard of, im all for addressing our nations obesity levels but I think there might just be a few more less insane ideas out there...

Dalrymps · 30/05/2009 23:04

YAWN trolling about are we again?

scottishmummy · 30/05/2009 23:14

yes war,blitz,traumatic evacuation of children from families.great idea

yep nothing like stress and war to keep the beef off

you first then lucia?

LupusinaLlamasuit · 30/05/2009 23:45

It's entirely possible Lucia might be a 19 year old history finalist with anorexia. Cos she certainly obsesses like one.

LupusinaLlamasuit · 30/05/2009 23:45

Though clearly, she'd have to be particularly G&T to be a finalist at 19

Starbear · 30/05/2009 23:49

edam Your Godmother might have met my Gran.
Hope she was a nicer person.
Dalrymps you enjoy it really
Gorionine Sorry I left to enjoy the sun and do some digging for England. Which thread are you hiding from? Are you going to sing at a concert before you make a break for the border? Oops! That might be in poor taste

edam · 30/05/2009 23:52

Machu, she's written a few accounts but just for very close friends and family. But she did have a long and distinguished career and life in public service.

Her third* husband was an historian specialising in the Labour movement so I think she left all the lecturing to him, really (he was still popping over to the Sorbonne to lecture at the age of 98, last one just a fortnight before he died).

  • She had a very entertaining life in all sorts of ways!
edam · 30/05/2009 23:52

has had! FFS what's wrong with me, I shouldn't be killing her off.

edam · 30/05/2009 23:55

Starbear - mine's lovely, sorry your Gran, um, wasn't!