Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous of older generations who were able to buy houses because their bosses exaggerated their salaries?

434 replies

HonestTealPoster · Today 09:05

Yesterday I was at the spa and got talking to a man who was older than me (I’m 33 and I’d put him in his early 50s at most).

He told me that when he was in his 20s, he and his friend were able to buy properties in the area of South London where I grew up.

Despite not earning particularly much at the time, his boss wrote a letter stating that he earned £90,000 a year! He openly admitted that he wasn’t earning anywhere near that amount but the letter helped him secure a mortgage. He also received £5,000 from his grandmother towards the purchase.

I’d heard stories about people being able to do things like this years ago but I’d never actually met someone who’d benefited from it!

I was genuinely gobsmacked. Imagine being able to get on the property ladder like that.

AIBU to feel rather envious of how much easier some people had it when it came to buying their first home?

OP posts:
ClawsandEffect · Today 15:38

gibletsarerank · Today 15:21

@ClawsandEffectnext people will tell you pension schemes were better than today.

Well, my older friend makes more in his penions (employer and state) that I make working full time. And the fcker looks as if he's going to live to 90 (due to all the bloody relaxation and chilled retirement he's had) whereas I'll probably keel over at 67.

PetulaGordeno · Today 15:39

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 15:38

I look at photos of my grandma on the 60s and she definitely had false eyelashes, something else that gets thrown at today's generation like it's a new thing.

I love 60’s pics of my mum. Liz Taylor eyebrows, lashes, beehive hairdo.
This was when a lot of looks from now started especially with Bardot.

time4anothername · Today 15:40

YANBU but unfortunately that behaviour all was part of what lead to the crash of 2008. You didn't even need a boss, by around 2000 you could self certify that you were self-employed earning 90k and, so long as you had a mortgage broker motivated only by earning their commission, no questions were asked.
Here's an article from 2003 about it. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2003/oct/29/mortgages.property and this early 2008 article, at the brink of the crash, notes that 1/5th of mortgages at that time were self cert and/or subprime https://moneyweek.com/3777/self-cert-mortgages-a-warning-from-the-last-crash

Easytoconfuse · Today 15:41

FourEyesGood · Today 09:13

This is such a patronising response. Many people in their 20s and 30s already live frugally, but even if not, buying fewer takeaway coffees and cafe lunches would not be sufficient to bridge the enormous gap between house prices of thirty years ago and today.

But not having Netflix, Sky or foreign holidays might well do. We didn't have a holiday for 10 years, we bought everything second hand, we didn't eat out or buy anything except the most essential clothes and we did all the work we could ourselves. Base rate was 12.38% when we got married.

Easytoconfuse · Today 15:42

ClawsandEffect · Today 15:38

Well, my older friend makes more in his penions (employer and state) that I make working full time. And the fcker looks as if he's going to live to 90 (due to all the bloody relaxation and chilled retirement he's had) whereas I'll probably keel over at 67.

How long has he worked for? How much did he put into his pension rather than spending? And is there any need to call him that?

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 15:42

PetulaGordeno · Today 15:39

I love 60’s pics of my mum. Liz Taylor eyebrows, lashes, beehive hairdo.
This was when a lot of looks from now started especially with Bardot.

Exactly and they looked lovely! I don't begrudge at all but raise an eyebrow when they preach about how they went without and sacrificed and todays generation get their lashes and nails done

BeUmberMember · Today 15:44

It's actually the massive cost of house deposits, stamp duty and solicitors fees these days. Plus the costs of surveys have increased and if you find something on them unacceptable and choose not to go ahead and buy, its money down the drain. Back in thev197Os we even got tax relief on our mortgages . The only big disadvantage then was that we had to insure our houses with the mortgage lenders.

BestMugPlease · Today 15:50

I'm 60. Had to supply payslips and P60 to prove my income for my first mortgage and every subsequent mortgage. I also worked placing mortgages in the 90s. Never heard of any lender accepting an employer's letter. I think this bloke was lying.

If it makes you feel better, I had to move away from the area I grew up in because I realised I would never be able to afford to buy a home there.

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 15:53

BerryTwister · Today 15:14

@SparklingGlitteryWine it all adds up. Try it. Don’t buy any takeaways, meals out, fancy coffees, nails, hair , handbags, unnecessary clothes for a month, and see how much you save.

I don't do any of that, I can only dream of getting my hair done, it's overgrown and split and looks a state. It's my daughter's birthday next month and I can only dream being able to her to a lovely fancy meal or a fancy coffee with whipped cream and sprinkles. I've worn the same clothes for many years, and I've owned the same handbag I got from a charity shop years ago. I work full time. What do you suggest now?

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 15:55

Easytoconfuse · Today 15:41

But not having Netflix, Sky or foreign holidays might well do. We didn't have a holiday for 10 years, we bought everything second hand, we didn't eat out or buy anything except the most essential clothes and we did all the work we could ourselves. Base rate was 12.38% when we got married.

I do all that now. I don't have sky, never had a foreign holiday, never eat out and I work hard. What do you suggest? Simply stop being poor? Dang never thought of that one.

BestMugPlease · Today 15:55

HonestTealPoster · Today 09:27

Of course, I can’t independently verify his account but I’m not sure why I should automatically assume he was lying either. And obtaining a mortgage based on an inflated salary doesn’t necessarily mean he couldn’t afford the repayments. It means he may not have qualified for the mortgage under the lender’s actual affordability criteria, which isn’t quite the same thing. Either way, I found it interesting to hear a firsthand account of something I’d previously only heard about anecdotally.

You've still only heard about it anectdotally tbf. I doubt he was able to prove it to you 🙄

gibletsarerank · Today 15:56

@ClawsandEffectsorry I meant they weren’t better! There’s a reason very final salary schemes exist these days

TheEighthDwarf · Today 15:58

Theeyeballsinthesky · Today 09:21

indeed! Frankly that sounds like bollocks to me OP

when I got a mortgage I had to supply copies of payslips and bank statements going back a few years

the idea that one letter from someone's boss was sufficient is absolute nonsense

he was just exaggerating because he wanted to impress like some twatty people do

if of course any of this actually happened and isn't yet another intergenerational conflict rage bait thread

Agree. From someone with personal and professional experience of house buying from the 1980s.

glitterpaperchain · Today 15:59

AMillionTomorrows · Today 09:09

YANBU. You can be jealous but it’s not going to help you. If you want to live like people in their 50s did 30 years ago, get rid of your mobile phone and internet, get a landline, stop eating out and buying take away coffees, ditch the avocado toast, netflix, Disney and Amazon Prime, your car, and your foreign holidays. You’ll probably save up quicker.

The very first comment mentions avocado toast 😂😂😂

TeethAreImportant · Today 16:00

HonestTealPoster · Today 09:05

Yesterday I was at the spa and got talking to a man who was older than me (I’m 33 and I’d put him in his early 50s at most).

He told me that when he was in his 20s, he and his friend were able to buy properties in the area of South London where I grew up.

Despite not earning particularly much at the time, his boss wrote a letter stating that he earned £90,000 a year! He openly admitted that he wasn’t earning anywhere near that amount but the letter helped him secure a mortgage. He also received £5,000 from his grandmother towards the purchase.

I’d heard stories about people being able to do things like this years ago but I’d never actually met someone who’d benefited from it!

I was genuinely gobsmacked. Imagine being able to get on the property ladder like that.

AIBU to feel rather envious of how much easier some people had it when it came to buying their first home?

I'm in my 50s and I don't know anybody who did that. Banks and building society's were ridiculously strict about mortgages only being 3 x your income at that time. What helped me and many others buy then, was that property wasn't the ridiculous price it is now, because Buy To Let mortgages didn't exist at that point either, so there weren't lots of people getting into the landlord game, which massively pushed up prices. You can be annoyed about that, but it's about as much use as shouting at clouds.

Badbadbunny · Today 16:02

@Suspicioustoenails

Young people these days are worse off than our generation. Not because they go on holiday, not because they have phones, but because we've fucked it up for the generation behind us.

Nail on the head.

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 16:03

AMillionTomorrows · Today 09:09

YANBU. You can be jealous but it’s not going to help you. If you want to live like people in their 50s did 30 years ago, get rid of your mobile phone and internet, get a landline, stop eating out and buying take away coffees, ditch the avocado toast, netflix, Disney and Amazon Prime, your car, and your foreign holidays. You’ll probably save up quicker.

Cool I've got rid of my internet. Please can you now tell me how my children can access their homework that is set and completed and marked with feedback online please. Much obliged x

KeepPumping · Today 16:04

HonestTealPoster · Today 15:26

Those are certainly useful indicators to watch, particularly new-build sales and mortgage approvals. I’d be interested in whether the trends point towards a sustained deterioration in the housing market or a period of adjustment to higher borrowing costs. I think there’s an important distinction between the two. But I agree that looking beyond headline house prices gives a much fuller picture of what’s actually happening in the market.

Everyone looking to buy a house already lives somewhere, most people don"t NEED to move, the market can slow to a very slow clip and just turn over on probate, divorce and cash needed for debt sales, those sales usually drop prices to sell and that affects the valuation of the wider market whether it is selling or not.

gibletsarerank · Today 16:04

very few

gibletsarerank · Today 16:05

@TheEighthDwarfself certainly mortgages were a thing & you didn’t have to be self employed. Read the thread

SparklingGlitteryWine · Today 16:05

AMillionTomorrows · Today 09:09

YANBU. You can be jealous but it’s not going to help you. If you want to live like people in their 50s did 30 years ago, get rid of your mobile phone and internet, get a landline, stop eating out and buying take away coffees, ditch the avocado toast, netflix, Disney and Amazon Prime, your car, and your foreign holidays. You’ll probably save up quicker.

Also you can get 2 avocados for 99p in Lidl so how is that even relevant please? x

gibletsarerank · Today 16:06

Badbadbunny · Today 16:02

@Suspicioustoenails

Young people these days are worse off than our generation. Not because they go on holiday, not because they have phones, but because we've fucked it up for the generation behind us.

Nail on the head.

.

gibletsarerank · Today 16:06

Badbadbunny · Today 16:02

@Suspicioustoenails

Young people these days are worse off than our generation. Not because they go on holiday, not because they have phones, but because we've fucked it up for the generation behind us.

Nail on the head.

I suppose admitting this means taking accountability hence the denial?

KeepPumping · Today 16:06

TeethAreImportant · Today 16:00

I'm in my 50s and I don't know anybody who did that. Banks and building society's were ridiculously strict about mortgages only being 3 x your income at that time. What helped me and many others buy then, was that property wasn't the ridiculous price it is now, because Buy To Let mortgages didn't exist at that point either, so there weren't lots of people getting into the landlord game, which massively pushed up prices. You can be annoyed about that, but it's about as much use as shouting at clouds.

I think you are confused on the timeline? This guy would have been in his late 20"s in the early 2000"s, BTL was well under way by that point.

time4anothername · Today 16:07

wow, can't believe the number of deniers on here. So many people deny things that didn't happen to them or people they know! As a pp said, there really were sites selling fake payslips, the phrase "liar loan" didn't come out of nowhere.

Here is a Financial Conduct Authority document from 2009 saying that verification of self cert is needed - amazing but true that there was not full regulation for this previously
https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/discussion/fsa-dp09-03.pdf

"In our view, there is a clear and non-controversial case for product regulation of
non-income verified (self-certified or ‘self-cert’ and fast track) mortgages. Self-cert mortgages were designed by the market to meet the needs of self-employed
borrowers but grew way beyond the consumer groups for which they were
originally intended. Our analysis shows that self-cert borrowers take out larger loan
amounts than borrowers with standard products and fall into arrears much more
frequently. To address these issues, we propose to require verification of income for
all mortgage applications"

Swipe left for the next trending thread