Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people ill with Covid stay home?

355 replies

LakelandHiker · Yesterday 18:09

This week, my manager and a friend who goes to my exercise class are ill with Covid. I don't know if they've tested, but they've both said they have it. However one is still coming into the office and the other still attending the exercise class. AIBU or overreacting here... but why don't they stay home until clear? Even if 'feeling 95% better' wouldn't you wait until potentially exposing others? I can't help but feel mad at them both for being so selfish. I often look after an elderly relative and can't risk passing Covid on to her as she is frail. I get life can't be on pause forever but my manager can get paid sick leave and my friend can miss a class, it isn't like there's anything at stake...

OP posts:
TheFlandersPigeon · Yesterday 19:00

Seems rather odd behaviour to test, tell everyone and do nothing about it, I agree. I understand not testing, or testing and staying at home, or testing and not telling anyone so nobody gets peeved if you do your usual activities. But not this specific combination!

SheilaFentiman · Yesterday 19:00

ToKittyornottoKitty · Yesterday 18:54

Well they aren’t saying they’ve got a cold though, they saying/announcing they have Covid.

DEAR GODDESS I UNDERSTAND THAT

You say “I’m ill with X” it’s not an announcement of a cold OR an announcement of Covid, it’s just a thing you say at work.

My objection was to you phrasing that it was an unreasonable announcement.

They are more unreasonable for announcing to everyone it’s Covid

SheilaFentiman · Yesterday 19:00

You have a lovely evening with your chessboard, MsKittyPigeon

x2boys · Yesterday 19:01

BillieWiper · Yesterday 18:59

People with any type of air or touch borne contagious illness should avoid others.

Whether it's upper/lower respiratory, cold, COVID, flu, TB, whooping cough, random viral or bacterial infection with no name yet.

Anything that can make others sick by close contact. But some people are so selfish. Or just thoughtless.

Or cant afford to tske time off work.

Spaniels4Eva · Yesterday 19:03

It's frankly bizarre that people are still testing for it.

TheFlandersPigeon · Yesterday 19:03

datedsockthief · Yesterday 18:55

Well apparently at least some Boots stores have sold out of tests, so I think perhaps more people than you think are interested in knowing what they've got. Not people who've continuously tested every illness since 2020, just people wondering what's making them ill.

My take is it seems to have been particularly nasty so far this year, plus there's flu going around, and being more ill makes some people more curious.

I didn't say I didn't think many people were interested, though. You've misread my post.

Fiftyandme · Yesterday 19:04

Because most employers aren’t going to allow 40 plus days per employee off sick over the winter because of bloody Covid.

aliasfrog · Yesterday 19:04

Floatlikeafeather2 · Yesterday 18:24

Is there some reason you can't have your jab?

I've had 12. I have one twice a year.

TheFlandersPigeon · Yesterday 19:06

SheilaFentiman · Yesterday 19:00

You have a lovely evening with your chessboard, MsKittyPigeon

What does that mean?

datedsockthief · Yesterday 19:06

weareallcats · Yesterday 18:55

I can tell the difference between Covid and a cold - Covid gets right into my sinuses and I sneeze shitloads - but that’s just the way it presents in my body. I would try my best to keep my distance and definitely wouldn’t go to an exercise class, but otherwise I’d still go about my business. Life has to go on. My dd was extremely unwell and vulnerable as a baby - it never occurred to me to try and stop people living their lives and we took our own measures to keep her safe. Some of these were a bit bonkers, eg, dh stripping off on the doorstep before coming into the house when he got back from work. If we were planning to see friends and one of them had a cold we would choose to stay away, rather than ask them
to. You can’t expect others to care in the same way you do about your family - we are responsible for ourselves. I’m sure people will hop on with all sorts of what ifs, but it’s unreasonable to expect people to take measures that have a negative effect on their own family.

You can't stop people living their lives, but can we not reasonably expect people to live their lives but take basic precautions that reduce negative side effects on other people?

Why is staying home when ill when someone has a choice a negative effect that matters and can't be allowed to happen, but being infected with an illness by someone who could easily have stayed home a negative effect that doesn't matter? Even if you're a perfectly healthy person and it's just a cold, that's at the very least annoying and unpleasant.

datedsockthief · Yesterday 19:07

TheFlandersPigeon · Yesterday 19:03

I didn't say I didn't think many people were interested, though. You've misread my post.

What I mean is, I don't think the set of people testing is actually the set of people who are generally cautious about covid and who you might expect to avoid indoor exercise.

Fiftyandme · Yesterday 19:08

Pieceofpurplesky · Yesterday 18:54

Another immunocompromised person here. Covid could make me seriously ill.
I also know of someone who died of Covid last week. Not prior illness, just caught it and it turned to pneumonia and they died. They were a colleague of my friend in a very public/people heavy role.
I know life has to go on these days but people are still impacted greatly.

And unfortunately people can’t be taking 10 days off every time they catch it over winter - they have jobs to go to, bills to pay, people to feed.

id much rather stay at home but one year I had it six times.

Whiskeyandkittens · Yesterday 19:08

I test if I have symptoms as I'm immunocompromised and eligible for the antiviral treatments if I test positive.

I understand people having to work, I take precautions myself and sit away from coughing and sneezing people (working from home isn't an option where I work)but it's a bit selfish if you're contagious and working from home is an option, and going to an exercise class is even more selfish.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Yesterday 19:08

SheilaFentiman · Yesterday 19:00

DEAR GODDESS I UNDERSTAND THAT

You say “I’m ill with X” it’s not an announcement of a cold OR an announcement of Covid, it’s just a thing you say at work.

My objection was to you phrasing that it was an unreasonable announcement.

They are more unreasonable for announcing to everyone it’s Covid

OP literally said they are ‘announcing’ it. So go do your big letters at her if you want to carry on being pedantic. I don’t care about your objection 👍

ThisGladGoose · Yesterday 19:09

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · Yesterday 18:21

There's some horrendous "survival of the fittest" shit posted about this topic on here.

How can you read aliasfrog's post upthread and still say it's fine to further disable people because you have to "get on with your lives"?

I find it fucking sociopathic.

Do you find it fucking sociopathic that some people get paid when they go to work, don't get paid when they don't go to work and cannot afford to not go to work?

Because those people are very often the ones who need to get on with their lives, aka not render themselves unable to pay their bills.

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · Yesterday 19:12

ThisGladGoose · Yesterday 19:09

Do you find it fucking sociopathic that some people get paid when they go to work, don't get paid when they don't go to work and cannot afford to not go to work?

Because those people are very often the ones who need to get on with their lives, aka not render themselves unable to pay their bills.

I do. See the last post I made, if you want to, where I acknowledge that it's the system in the UK that's the problem, not individuals.

(The individuals who choose to go to exercise classes, knowing they are infectious with something that could seriously harm someone else, on the other hand... I might get deleted for saying what I think of them.)

HelenHywater · Yesterday 19:12

I don't expect people to go without pay or lose their jobs in order to stay at home if they have covid.

I personally would test and would wfh if i had covid - not least because I don't want my colleagues to get ill. My colleagues would do the same. I appreciate I'm lucky to be able to do this.

I think there is something wrong with our society (employers mostly I think) that they value attendance in an office over the health and wellbeing of their employees and the wider population, including those who are vulnerable.

I also think that maybe mask wearing on public transport would be a good thing, although i don't know how effective that is. But given the Japanese do it, I think maybe it is a good thing....(before you all @ me, I'm just speculating that this would be beneficial to those who are more vulnerable)

BillieWiper · Yesterday 19:13

x2boys · Yesterday 19:01

Or cant afford to tske time off work.

Yeah thank you I was actually going to add that one in. It's not intentional often. I remember getting sick as fuck in this grim call centre where there were a hundred of us all crammed in like sardines, zero hours contracts, penalised for being sick. All travelled there on crowded public transport. Broken Aircon. It was just germs everywhere all the time.

HappyLizard23 · Yesterday 19:13

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · Yesterday 19:12

I do. See the last post I made, if you want to, where I acknowledge that it's the system in the UK that's the problem, not individuals.

(The individuals who choose to go to exercise classes, knowing they are infectious with something that could seriously harm someone else, on the other hand... I might get deleted for saying what I think of them.)

Earlier in the thread you called those who have to go to work selfish.

Ewock · Yesterday 19:13

LakelandHiker · Yesterday 18:09

This week, my manager and a friend who goes to my exercise class are ill with Covid. I don't know if they've tested, but they've both said they have it. However one is still coming into the office and the other still attending the exercise class. AIBU or overreacting here... but why don't they stay home until clear? Even if 'feeling 95% better' wouldn't you wait until potentially exposing others? I can't help but feel mad at them both for being so selfish. I often look after an elderly relative and can't risk passing Covid on to her as she is frail. I get life can't be on pause forever but my manager can get paid sick leave and my friend can miss a class, it isn't like there's anything at stake...

My work, a school, have told us that unless we are feeling really ill we have to be in.

aliasfrog · Yesterday 19:14

Fiftyandme · Yesterday 19:08

And unfortunately people can’t be taking 10 days off every time they catch it over winter - they have jobs to go to, bills to pay, people to feed.

id much rather stay at home but one year I had it six times.

You say that, but equally I can't afford to be off sick and potentially lose my job if I get covid again.
My health and my job matters less in society to those of healthy/non-disabled people it seems.
And as soon as I lose my job I'll be told to get in work and stop claiming disability benefits.

We can't win.

HappyLizard23 · Yesterday 19:14

HelenHywater · Yesterday 19:12

I don't expect people to go without pay or lose their jobs in order to stay at home if they have covid.

I personally would test and would wfh if i had covid - not least because I don't want my colleagues to get ill. My colleagues would do the same. I appreciate I'm lucky to be able to do this.

I think there is something wrong with our society (employers mostly I think) that they value attendance in an office over the health and wellbeing of their employees and the wider population, including those who are vulnerable.

I also think that maybe mask wearing on public transport would be a good thing, although i don't know how effective that is. But given the Japanese do it, I think maybe it is a good thing....(before you all @ me, I'm just speculating that this would be beneficial to those who are more vulnerable)

Not everyone has an office job and can work from home. My partner is a retail manager and has to work in the store, he also doesn’t get paid for being sick.

EverythingIsComputer · Yesterday 19:14

I think just out of decency people should adapt, same when they have a cold. Masks, stay at home if you can, be mindful of fresh air and handwashing etc. but people are more selfish now post pandemic than before so I hold out very little hope.

inamarina · Yesterday 19:15

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · Yesterday 18:29

I care about your family's fortunes to exactly the same degree you care about disabled people.

But pp isn’t expecting you to care about their family?
Of course people should try to be mindful of others, but what do you want them to do if their employer expects them to come in?
Most people won’t be willing to compromise their family’s financial stability, especially not in the current economic climate.

bababamama · Yesterday 19:15

Who even has tests now, my dr didn’t even mention Covid as a possibility when I went last month, 4 weeks on and I’m still not 100% better and my symptoms match that of this new strain. My dr simply said hot drinks, paracetamol and prescribed antibiotics for the secondary tonsillitis

Swipe left for the next trending thread