Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Packed lunch = retired with £1m by 40.

370 replies

Allschoolsareartschools · 30/06/2026 07:53

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgdn3qqg7po
AIBU to say I've had a packed lunch for nearly 40 years but I dont have £1m & I'm not retired yet!
Am I doing something wrong?
Seriously how out of touch is this article? Good luck to them but its nothing to do with packed lunches.

Katie and Alan Donegan smile at the camera while both wearing glasses during a selfie in front of a lake and trees against a blue sky.

The people living hyper frugally so they can retire early

The Fire (Financially Independent, Retire Early) movement sees followers save as much as possible.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgdn3qqg7po

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DJPJ · 30/06/2026 12:14

Crocsarentslippers · 30/06/2026 11:50

They do, this article is like catnip to the mumsnet crowd that always banging on about topping up your pension pot/ overpaying your mortgage/not doing anything in lieu of a future that may never happen.

The smaller minority don't believe in gloating and smugness, and realise that for some, hard work and determination is still no match for a good start in life and a lot of good fortune.

My hard work and determination is mostly directed to the here and now planning exhilaration experiences with my loved ones. No regrets. I have a wide range of family and friends and have lost some untimely and unexpectedly - no regrets taking my 56 year old mother on an extravagant ski holiday with her 4 grandchildren when we lost her 3 months later out of the blue.

I invest in relationships with children, friends, family, etc. Some cost ££££ others cost ££. I also love my work and career so retirement isnt the goal for me.

I am conscious of my current privilege as well as my very poor childhood where we were barely surviving.

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:15

This couple are obviously extreme, I’ve never searched for receipts or deprived myself of heating but still managed to retire very early.

What I don’t understand from a lot of these comments is those saying “life is for living” “ you could drop dead tomorrow “ ….. so you’re working 40+ hours a week so that you can live your best life on weekends and during your 5 weeks of A/L??
Just doesn’t compute for me.

I spend my days doing exactly what I want to do based on the very fact that I could indeed drop dead tomorrow!

TheYorkshirePudding · 30/06/2026 12:23

Ridiculous. Some uneducated people will think that sitting in the cold in winter and stealing vouchers is a big part of how they’ve done that….but in reality it’s lucky investment and large salaries, no children neither. There’s got to be a balance - what if they die tomorrow? Living like that? Not for me!

Dokushozanmai · 30/06/2026 12:23

AnonyMumAuDHD · 30/06/2026 09:57

What tosh. Whether you have a packed lunch or not, to save £1m by 40 you needed to be putting away £50k a year for 20 years. Allowing for tax and the unavoidable costs of living (rent, utilities, food, etc) that’s an average base gross salary of £120-150k, isn’t it?

Sorry, but very very few people could achieve this on a normal salary and to promote this twaddle as realistically achievable is insulting to ordinary working people - and just fuels a cultural divide.

Or invest what you can early, and watch compound interest work its magic

TheYorkshirePudding · 30/06/2026 12:24

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:15

This couple are obviously extreme, I’ve never searched for receipts or deprived myself of heating but still managed to retire very early.

What I don’t understand from a lot of these comments is those saying “life is for living” “ you could drop dead tomorrow “ ….. so you’re working 40+ hours a week so that you can live your best life on weekends and during your 5 weeks of A/L??
Just doesn’t compute for me.

I spend my days doing exactly what I want to do based on the very fact that I could indeed drop dead tomorrow!

How did you do it? What age did you retire?

StrongPoison · 30/06/2026 12:25

The maths on this is fascinating. A US blogger has calculated it for various % of income saved. At the extreme, if you save 75% of your income then you can amass a pot to retire on within 7 years. Paring spending is the key but obviously a good income helps too, you can’t save if you only have enough to cover essentials. But once true essentials are covered then we all have our own view on other essentials. Then it is a case of how much deferred gratification we want. I found his blog in 2012, via a mumsnet thread as it happens. It has accelerated my retirement date by at least 10 years.

Packed lunch = retired with £1m by 40.
BreatheAndFocus · 30/06/2026 12:25

YANBU. I cringed when I read it this morning. How unaware and bloody patronising! What possessed them to feature in such an article? Have they no idea how they look?

Rich people with shitloads of money, save a bit more by forgoing things that many people can’t afford anyway, let alone on a daily basis 🙄

Now they’re retired, perhaps they could spend some time with the large numbers of people in this country struggling to put food on the table.

nomas · 30/06/2026 12:25

Dokushozanmai · 30/06/2026 12:23

Or invest what you can early, and watch compound interest work its magic

Invest it where though? A stocks and shares ISA?

Toooldtocare25 · 30/06/2026 12:27

Tommorow isn’t promised .. I’ve known people plough everything into retirement only to pass away before or just after they got there. Life’s to short you have to enjoy what you can and at the same time try and put some away.

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:28

TheYorkshirePudding · 30/06/2026 12:23

Ridiculous. Some uneducated people will think that sitting in the cold in winter and stealing vouchers is a big part of how they’ve done that….but in reality it’s lucky investment and large salaries, no children neither. There’s got to be a balance - what if they die tomorrow? Living like that? Not for me!

I’m quite uneducated to be fair 😏 left school at 16 due to pregnancy and I guess lucky that when I bought my home at 21 it was more affordable than it is now and has increased in value more than I’d hoped. But that’s all really, the rest was through aggressive and clever saving and frugality.

Living like they do? What, travelling the world? I’m sure they stick the heating on nowadays

SquirrelMadness · 30/06/2026 12:31

Toooldtocare25 · 30/06/2026 12:27

Tommorow isn’t promised .. I’ve known people plough everything into retirement only to pass away before or just after they got there. Life’s to short you have to enjoy what you can and at the same time try and put some away.

Exactly this! I wouldn't want to spend my 20s, 30s and 40s cold, uncomfortable and bored just so that I can hopefully have fun later in life. You could get diagnosed with a terminal or chronic illness, Putin could start a nuclear war, your partner could run off with a younger model, etc. I think it's more sensible to spread the joy.

omghereistrouble · 30/06/2026 12:32

Well we eat at home and often do not have heating on just because we cannot afford it. we are as poor as church mice I'm afraid

Beamsss · 30/06/2026 12:34

It's how I did it. Not at 40, but at 54.

Of course if you only earn so that a packed lunch is a necessity anyway you're not going to save a lot for retirement, but if you have a decent income, having a mindset that means you only spend on things that give you real value, makes a massive difference.

Dokushozanmai · 30/06/2026 12:36

nomas · 30/06/2026 12:25

Invest it where though? A stocks and shares ISA?

Why not? Its a good start. There are a lot of low cost trackers run by platforms like Vanguard which have given good returns over the last few years.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 30/06/2026 12:37

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:15

This couple are obviously extreme, I’ve never searched for receipts or deprived myself of heating but still managed to retire very early.

What I don’t understand from a lot of these comments is those saying “life is for living” “ you could drop dead tomorrow “ ….. so you’re working 40+ hours a week so that you can live your best life on weekends and during your 5 weeks of A/L??
Just doesn’t compute for me.

I spend my days doing exactly what I want to do based on the very fact that I could indeed drop dead tomorrow!

Yes, I think it's a bit twatty to call them joyless.

Re-evaluating what brings you joy is important. You can't look at someone else's life and call it joyless.

My health is really important to me, so I'm really focusing on it recently - very little caffeine and alcohol for various reasons. And I have lots of joy, even though people are always bugging me to have more stuff that makes me feel worse.

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:38

TheYorkshirePudding · 30/06/2026 12:24

How did you do it? What age did you retire?

42, we invested heavily in company shares (no risk), lived frugally but not in a joyless way. Always two holidays a year. Overpaid mortgage until mortgage free. Kids grown by now so could have 4/5 years of really aggressive saving. Both took voluntary redundancy.

BringBackCatsEyes · 30/06/2026 12:42

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:28

I’m quite uneducated to be fair 😏 left school at 16 due to pregnancy and I guess lucky that when I bought my home at 21 it was more affordable than it is now and has increased in value more than I’d hoped. But that’s all really, the rest was through aggressive and clever saving and frugality.

Living like they do? What, travelling the world? I’m sure they stick the heating on nowadays

How did you manage to buy a home at 21? Were you living at home with your child? Who provided childcare?

WanderingWellies · 30/06/2026 12:43

Meridas · 30/06/2026 08:00

It doesn't say what they're doing with their retirement. Do they still live equally frugally to make that £1M last another 40 odd years?

With waaaaaay more time to fill so hopefully not or they’re going to be very bored!

Beamsss · 30/06/2026 12:45

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 30/06/2026 12:37

Yes, I think it's a bit twatty to call them joyless.

Re-evaluating what brings you joy is important. You can't look at someone else's life and call it joyless.

My health is really important to me, so I'm really focusing on it recently - very little caffeine and alcohol for various reasons. And I have lots of joy, even though people are always bugging me to have more stuff that makes me feel worse.

Yes, and I think there's a lot of joy in simple things. Often big spenders are looking for joy that's missing fron their lives. I would far far rarher hike up a mountian with a packed lunch than have a fortnight in an exclusive hotel in Dubai.

I get far more joy out of finding something I already own and can repurpose than I do out of buying something new.

I haven't taken things as extrme as them. I enjoy good food, but by way of buying quality ingredients to prepare simple meals, and a very nice restaurant once in a blue moon for a special occasion, not eating out reguarly. I hate it if I get caught out and have to buy a bottle of water because that spending adds nothing to my life and is not necessary, but I wouldn't turn down drinks with friends to save money.

The mindset that "treats" and "joy" need to involve spending is harmful and not making anyone happy imo.

ShubmanBhaiya · 30/06/2026 12:46

BreatheAndFocus · 30/06/2026 12:25

YANBU. I cringed when I read it this morning. How unaware and bloody patronising! What possessed them to feature in such an article? Have they no idea how they look?

Rich people with shitloads of money, save a bit more by forgoing things that many people can’t afford anyway, let alone on a daily basis 🙄

Now they’re retired, perhaps they could spend some time with the large numbers of people in this country struggling to put food on the table.

Money they earned via hard work? The man had his successful business. The woman who had a skilled career as an actuary? Money they chose to save by scrimping and living like misers

ShubmanBhaiya · 30/06/2026 12:48

omghereistrouble · 30/06/2026 12:32

Well we eat at home and often do not have heating on just because we cannot afford it. we are as poor as church mice I'm afraid

What do you both do for work?

Newyearawaits · 30/06/2026 12:49

Stars26 · 30/06/2026 08:12

This! my mum had just gotten her pension and died suddenly after a terrible ten years of health. There is a balance in life. I work to live now. I don’t want to sit in a cold house and never do anything so i can retire early tbh. Tommorow isn’t guaranteed. Our health isn’t guardnteed. No good being frugal for a retirement you can’t enjoy!

Save for retirement sure ( i have a pension with tax free lump sump and plan to save more when the mortgage is done in afew years) but don’t forgo living now. Obviously those earning higher or with less outgoings often find it easier to save more for retirement too. Especially with how the cost of living is. So many now live month to month with no savings nevermind retirement savings.

This post sums it up perfectly.
Re the coup who took packed lunches to work to enable them to retire :it's important to acknowledge that most people could take pl to work every day and still not be able to pay off their mortgage early.
Important not to use that couple as a benchmark ; totally detached from the majority!

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:49

BringBackCatsEyes · 30/06/2026 12:42

How did you manage to buy a home at 21? Were you living at home with your child? Who provided childcare?

In the normal way I guess. I got a mortgage with my (now) DH. Granted 20+ years ago this was much more affordable than it is now but certainly nothing out of the ordinary. Yes my child was with me and I worked part time until they went to school.

WanderingWellies · 30/06/2026 12:49

FudgeFudy · 30/06/2026 08:06

These FIRE articles always boil down to the same thing - you can retire at 40 if you save excessively by living like a miser, live like a miser in retirement too...oh and either earn well into six figures by 25 or come into a substantial inheritance. Amazing!

Same with the ‘how I managed to get on the property ladder in my 20s without parental help’. In almost all cases, it involves a couple who both live at home (individually or with one set of parents) and don’t pay any rent so they can save for a deposit. So yeah, if you’re partnered up in your 20s and don’t count no rent or bills (plus in many cases at least some of your food and your washing included) as parental help, it’s possible to buy a flat or a house even in the south. Doesn’t make it realistic for everyone though.

42Retired · 30/06/2026 12:50

Beamsss · 30/06/2026 12:45

Yes, and I think there's a lot of joy in simple things. Often big spenders are looking for joy that's missing fron their lives. I would far far rarher hike up a mountian with a packed lunch than have a fortnight in an exclusive hotel in Dubai.

I get far more joy out of finding something I already own and can repurpose than I do out of buying something new.

I haven't taken things as extrme as them. I enjoy good food, but by way of buying quality ingredients to prepare simple meals, and a very nice restaurant once in a blue moon for a special occasion, not eating out reguarly. I hate it if I get caught out and have to buy a bottle of water because that spending adds nothing to my life and is not necessary, but I wouldn't turn down drinks with friends to save money.

The mindset that "treats" and "joy" need to involve spending is harmful and not making anyone happy imo.

Love this. We live exactly like this