Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex, birthday and rage

50 replies

Lilylove2 · 18/05/2026 18:40

Long history of difficult co-parenting and years of court proceedings. There is now a barring order because of the repeated litigation history. So this is not just “normal” separated parent friction for me emotionally. t.

My DS is turning 10. He is absolutely obsessed with Formula 1 and we’ve organised a go karting/F1-themed session at a race track which he is incredibly excited about. I’m also heavily pregnant and in the middle of moving house so everything has been planned carefully around the court-ordered handover arrangements.

The order states a Wednesday 2pm handover during the holidays and that holidays are shared. His dad messaged to say he had arranged a birthday celebration with his family on the Wednesday (5 days after DS’s actual birthday) and therefore needed to return him later in the evening instead of 2pm.

I politely no because we already had plans arranged from 3pm onwards linked to DS’s birthday.
Then suddenly I get this:
“Having reviewed the school holiday dates properly, my understanding is that this holiday period is split equally at 6 nights each, which is consistent with the 50/50 arrangement set out in the order.”

He then went on to say he would therefore return DS on Thursday instead of Wednesday.

The thing that has absolutely sent me west is the trajectory of it. He says he needs extra time because of plans he’s arranged, I say sorry no because we already have plans, and then suddenly there’s a technical reinterpretation of the order which conveniently gives him the exact outcome he wanted anyway.

The order says holidays are shared, but the Wednesday handover has been the established arrangement. What I cannot get past emotionally is the timing and the unilateral tone of “I will therefore return him on Thursday.”

I honestly feel like for the sake of an extra 20 hours (most of which my son will spend asleep), he is willing to make him miss part of a birthday celebration he is massively excited about because he doesn’t like being told no.

I know my response was emotional. I said I thought the behaviour was grim and ego-driven. Probably not ideal, but I’m just exhausted by years of feeling like everything becomes a positional battle where I’m expected to absorb changes after plans have already been made.

I think what I’m struggling with most is the powerlessness. Once DS is there, realistically what do I do? I can’t physically go and get him. So how do people emotionally regulate when they feel someone can just bulldoze plans and there are no consequences?

Genuinely asking how people detach and stop feeling so activated by this stuff because I feel sick with rage tonight.

OP posts:
Ophy83 · 19/05/2026 09:02

He's a dick.

But for the sake of your son and not making him feel torn between you both - can you call up the racing place and explain what has happened and see if it is possible to move it?

Tuesdayschild50 · 19/05/2026 18:23

Biggest hug to you this must be absolutely exhausting and being pregnant aswell....Always try and remember this,
He wants a rise out of you..
He thinks he is superior..
You say no and argue he will double down you feel anger turmoil exhaustion...

Don't take the bait,give one word answers like ok because to people like this ok is a sentence you arnt giving in you are stepping away from his abuse because that's what this is.
He is trying to control and provoke you to control you.

Change how you respond you don't need to win as he does .. all you need to do is protect your peace refuse to play his game find calm in stepping away xx

Butterme · 19/05/2026 18:42

Why would he plan his birthday do on the Wednesday - 5 days after his birthday! That’s ridiculous!!

Obviously he is just trying to be difficult

If he is legally wrong then I would be fighting over it.

But if he’s not legally wrong and there’s nothing you can do then I’d not act hurt at all - in fact I would say something like - “that actually works a lot better for me as I have been offered alternative plans on Wednesday evening but felt it was better to see DS instead. What time shall I pick him up on Thursday?”

I would be petty and act like he’s done you a favour.

Mumofoneandone · 19/05/2026 18:47

Can you get an emergency court appearance, as ex isn't sticking to court ordered access.
Could you take legal advice and possibly not allow your son to go to his dad's because the dad is basically refusing to follow court orders. Or advice as to what to do when the ex is following court orders.
This is just another way to get at you because he's banned from going through the courts.

JLou08 · 19/05/2026 19:02

Lilylove2 · 18/05/2026 19:34

I don’t think it’s awkward at all to make plans based on a legal order that has been in place for years.

My son’s birthday is on the Friday. He goes to his dad’s after school that day and stays there over half term until the Wednesday handover at 2/3pm (depending on school holiday wording). The order has always operated on the basis of a Wednesday handover.

The wednesday handover is the first day I'll see after his birthday. My parents live near a racing track and as part of his 10th birthday present he and his cousins are going karting afterwards, then having a birthday tea. It’s a discounted midweek session, and because we are literally moving house in the days immediately after, we organised things this way.

So yes, I absolutely did make plans on the basis that the court-ordered Wednesday handover would happen at the normal time. I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to organise my life on the assumption the order may suddenly be reinterpreted after plans are already made.

Also, if his dad wanted a family birthday celebration, he had from Friday to Wednesday to arrange one. That’s what I find difficult here. The issue isn’t “he wants to celebrate his birthday”, it’s that he knowingly arranged it on the one afternoon where there is a legal handover already in place and then effectively informed me afterwards that the timing would need to change.

Knowing the timing of his birthday and that he will be with his dad for his birthday until the Wednesday does make it clearer why you are upset and made plans on that day. It wasn't clear in your original post.
I agree with PP who said to tell his dad that he will have to explain to DS that he can't go to the event. A reasonable co-parent wouldn't want their DS to miss out on a birthday celebration with his mum and maternal family, unfortunately he doesn't sound like a reasonable person.

CamillaMcCauley · 19/05/2026 19:05

I don’t know what your options are for rearranging the go-kart experience but despite what people are saying about enforced handovers, I would think changing your own plans is the only realistic way forward.

I really sympathize with you and no, you are not being unreasonable to feel upset and nor were you to say what you did. Frankly, “grim, ego-driven decision” is a phrase I will file away to use on my ex at some point in the future, as he has a history of doing spiteful things just to get back at me for leaving him.

As others have suggested, I would be clear with your son that plans had to be canceled or rearranged because of his father. Don’t get mad over-emotional, just state the facts and empathize with his upset. Over time he will come to see how his dad operates and will make his own choices.

Your learning going forward is to build in as many defences as you can against your ex hurting you. You weren’t unreasonable to organize plans when you did, but now you’ve learned what he is prepared to do, so adjust accordingly. I have virtually no contact with my ex outside what is necessary, ask nothing of him, expect nothing of him. It’s probably exactly what he wants but for me, the peace of mind is worth it.

It won’t last forever, once your son gets wise to the game, he will push back himself.

Lollipop81 · 19/05/2026 19:06

Maybe remind him the most important thing is your son, not scoring points against each other. Does he really want your son to miss out? If so then he needs to explain it to his son. Simple as that really. Poor child in the middle of a tug of a war. As others have said I wouldn’t be hiding it from your son either if he doesn’t change his mind.

BudgetBuster · 19/05/2026 19:29

I think maybe your order is written poorly? You've said in a few different places it split equally, then that Wednesday at 2pm is the changeover time and separately Wednesday 3pm is the time. You say he is reinterpreting which means it can't be 100% clearcut.

Is this an ongoing issue where he tries to break the access order? Or is this the first time?

For your own peace, I would just try to rearrange the birthday celebration you have booked... its unfortunate but you can't trust that he'll return him.

ByKeenMintViper · 19/05/2026 20:43

If he doesn’t return your son at the time specified in the court order then isn’t this considered kidnap and a matter for the police? It would be extremely unpleasant for your son, however. Can you seek advice from your/a lawyer before sending your son off with his dad? Or play him at his own game and text saying that you won’t be sending him until Saturday instead as you have plans and move the go-karting experience to Friday/Saturday.

Ifallelsefails · 19/05/2026 21:36

I had years of this behaviour & it does wear you down, you're forever waiting for the next time, and the next time.

Maybe your ex is having a quiet tantrum - is he with someone else, and happy?
If you've got a house move going on and you're heavily pregnant maybe that's more important than arguing with a tosser. It sounds like he's done this on purpose - he knows when handover is normally and probably already guessed you'd have plans for DS when he came back if he's been with him since Friday.

Don't question DS when he comes back, just listen to what he says and you'll get the answers x

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 19/05/2026 21:46

Lilylove2 · 18/05/2026 19:34

I don’t think it’s awkward at all to make plans based on a legal order that has been in place for years.

My son’s birthday is on the Friday. He goes to his dad’s after school that day and stays there over half term until the Wednesday handover at 2/3pm (depending on school holiday wording). The order has always operated on the basis of a Wednesday handover.

The wednesday handover is the first day I'll see after his birthday. My parents live near a racing track and as part of his 10th birthday present he and his cousins are going karting afterwards, then having a birthday tea. It’s a discounted midweek session, and because we are literally moving house in the days immediately after, we organised things this way.

So yes, I absolutely did make plans on the basis that the court-ordered Wednesday handover would happen at the normal time. I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to organise my life on the assumption the order may suddenly be reinterpreted after plans are already made.

Also, if his dad wanted a family birthday celebration, he had from Friday to Wednesday to arrange one. That’s what I find difficult here. The issue isn’t “he wants to celebrate his birthday”, it’s that he knowingly arranged it on the one afternoon where there is a legal handover already in place and then effectively informed me afterwards that the timing would need to change.

Whilst I understand why you booked it for the Wednesday there is literally no way I would have planned something like this on the day of the handover from the prick ex.
I'd class Wednesday evenings as dangerous territory and as such wouldn't make plans that would disappoint DS if they had to be cancelled.
Yes his Dad is an utter arse hole but you clearly already knew that.

Sunisgettinganewhaton · 19/05/2026 21:55

I once organised a party for ds's birthday.. His bastard df simply didn't bring him back . May I suggest you tell him it's fine you have changed the date of the event.. Even if you haven't /can't. And I guarantee he will bring him back the Wednesday..

BookArt55 · 19/05/2026 21:59

So sorry you're going through this, this is exactly the type of thing my ex would do

  • would your chikd have told your ex about it, excited? The moment that happens my ex pulls something. I've purposely hidden my daughter's birthday day out next week from the kids abd will only tell them once they are back with me.
-never plan anything for handover day. This is my rule as they love to ruin it. -call the gokarting place on the morning, say the birthday child has a sickness and diarrhea bug and can you postpone... not ideal but not losing money -if the court order is very clear with 3om on a Wednesday for holiday handover, then I would respond to ex that the olan is X. This has been in place since X. I will meet you at the handover location at 3pm, if you choose to not follow the court order then unfortunately I will have to take next steps.

I so understand yiur upset. Before you respond to anything else, rant into chat gpt and then ask AI to make it BIFF for a high conflict coparenting dynamic. You then get it off your chest, and your ex doesn't get to hear that he has got to you- he will love it, thrive off of it, and keep hitting you in the weak spot you have shown him... sorry I know that isn't easy!

Hope you get him back and can celebrate his birthday the way you planned.

Hummingbird10 · Yesterday 01:03

Does your ex know what you have planned ? I wonder if this could help. He sounds like an arsehole, but regardless you need to communicate with him. Just wondering if it would be an idea to explain what the plan is?

99bottlesofkombucha · Yesterday 03:23

What happens if he breaches the court order? As the obvious response is we have a court order for Wednesday 2pm handover, refer line 16 of the court order /section 6/whatever the reference. Return ds at 2pm or you are in breach of the court order. In future to avoid upsetting ds don’t schedule plans for ds that involve breaching the court order unless I have agreed in advance (I would only say this if you do sometimes agree variations). I do not agree to any changes to next weeks plan, we have plans of our own for ds’ birthday.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · Yesterday 03:33

Hi op,
youve got the court order. I would say
we have always done the handover on Wednesdays as per court order. You’ve now unilaterally warned me you plan to withold contact. Unless you confirm in writing you’ll return him at 2pm Wednesday I will not be sending him to stay with you, so he doesn’t risk missing his bday plans, and in this case you can collect him on the Thursday if you wish. I hope this will not be the case though.
what can he do, he is barred from taking you back to court for enforcement and even if he does, the judge wouldn’t do much for this one off.

GloriousGoosebumps · Yesterday 07:57

Your ex is clearly having great fun at your expense and his desire to piss you off is so great that even the thought of his son’s disappointment can’t stop him. I’m not sure how long it is to the Formula 1 birthday treat you have arranged, but you should lodge an application for a Specific Issue Order under the Children Act 1975 and have the Court order that he return your son at 2pm on the Wednesday, ie the usual time. Your husband really needs to learn that he can’t make unilateral decisions about handover.

Londonrach1 · Yesterday 08:03

There's only one person who matters in this...your son. Can he enjoy his birthday celebration with his extended family and that what you had planned. Abit of flexibility on both parents sides and not scored against each other.

RandomMess · Yesterday 08:05

If you have it in writing that he will not be returning DS 2pm Wednesday then I would tell DS he can go as usual and he will miss the karting because his Dad has said he will not return him OR he not go to his Dad’s.

It is reasonable for you to disrupt the court order and lodge a specific one in the meantime when he has put in writing that he will not complying with it.

Wish44 · Yesterday 08:07

sympathy Op. I have had years of this ( children are older now and it’s a great relief) . All the posters here saying you just need to talk to him and explain just don’t get it. This man does not want to do anything other than control you. He doesn’t give a shit about his DC. My DC missed a family occasion due to this . He used to count up literal hours.

will your ex actually stick to what he says? Mine often threatened but in the end didn’t always follow through. He had achieved his aim which was to make me an emotional mess.

be honest with your son though.

sympathy to you. It’s horrid being tied to these people for years x

LalaPaloosa2024 · Yesterday 09:07

I’ve had similar experiences. I’ve had to get court orders to go on holidays and even over 3 hours in a day. He insisted he needed our child for February half term and because I was permitted to take her skiing one year, he was told he could have the following February. When it came, he insisted on the same weekly split and didn’t take our child anywhere. Meanwhile she missed out on skiing that year for no reason. He would also fight for “his days” and leave the child with a babysitter.

It’s petty, pathetic and it drove me mad too. All I can say is that as they get older, children have more of a voice. They won’t be able to pull these games on a teenager.

gardenflowergirl · Yesterday 11:03

Speak to your son about what's happening, he's getting to the age where his voice matters. Let him know what he would be missing so he can be involved in talking to his dad about what he'd like to do, so it's not just about you and your ex.

BookArt55 · Yesterday 18:16

Feel for you. Some posters saying you need to talk to ex can't have dealt with this type of coparenting situation. Hope you're okay.

DearDenimEagle · Yesterday 20:17

I’d point out that your son will grow up and will be taking notes as he does so. He will remember his father’s behaviours, the things he has to miss because of father’s spite and it will do nothing to enhance an ongoing relationship once the boy has options and the court no longer decides for him.

I have never forgiven my carbon maternal unit, and it’s been decades, literally, for blocking my father out whenever possible. My brother, much the same- won’t speak to her and moved abroad to get away from her..as did I, just not as far.

Lilylove2 · Today 18:33

Thanks for all the comments, particularly from those who understand what it’s like dealing with people who just push and push boundaries and then act as though you’re unreasonable for eventually standing your ground.

I’ve now engaged a solicitor and, honestly, it has been incredibly helpful because it gives me confidence that I’m not being a bellend and imagining things and I have acted reasonably and in good faith throughout.

He is still refusing to comply, but my solicitor was very clear that his argument is ridiculous and that the behaviour is provocative and designed to cause maximum stress and disruption.

It actually feels quite validating to have the situation seen for what it is, rather than feeling like I’m constantly being pressured to absorb it all to “keep the peace”.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread