Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone lives on a small Scottish Island?

444 replies

NewStartFamily · 29/04/2026 14:20

Specifically Eday or Tiree but thoughts and opinions of any others very welcome!

DP and I are considering a relocation from the south coast to Scotland, somewhere with land we can use.

We have found a couple of properties that we like but we’d like to hear thoughts from people who live there about how life works in the smaller communities and places where not everything is on your doorstep.

We have one home educated son aged 9 so nearby schools not an essential consideration.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
fuckweasel · 04/05/2026 21:20

AlwaysHungry123 · 04/05/2026 08:13

It’s been fascinating reading this thread. Off the topic a bit but what do pregnant women do on the islands when they’re about to give birth? Home birth?
As someone who had two very traumatic deliveries and wouldn’t survive without specialist intervention during the delivery I can’t help but think of what help the women get and how quickly when things go wrong

On the island I’m on, they will go to the mainland two weeks before due date and wait! For early labour then air ambulance, Coastguard helicopter or lifeboat will step in. As far as I am aware, home birth can be an option and two midwives stay on the island from two weeks before due date until birth. Women choose to go to either nearest hospitals on the mainland or one near family.

EarthSight · 04/05/2026 21:54

FullOfFresias · 04/05/2026 21:13

I’m nowhere near Scotland but I have found this thread very interesting! Love hearing experiences of people who live remotely

I live in rural Wales, in the far West. It's not an island, but it's very much like one. We're closer to Dublin that we are to London or even Cardiff. If I think it's a bit tough for teenagers here, then it would be even more so for people living that far North and remotely.

EarthSight · 04/05/2026 21:57

Gardenquestion22 · 04/05/2026 08:30

I live on an island, not northern Scotland and we have a full hospital. But we still have people who go to the UK for specialist appointments and fly over for the day or stay in UK, at own cost. There’s a helicopter for emergency transfers or the coastguard will help if that’s tied up.

You must be close to the U.K then, so I'm guessing somewhere around Ireland.

AlwaysHungry123 · 04/05/2026 22:19

fuckweasel · 04/05/2026 21:20

On the island I’m on, they will go to the mainland two weeks before due date and wait! For early labour then air ambulance, Coastguard helicopter or lifeboat will step in. As far as I am aware, home birth can be an option and two midwives stay on the island from two weeks before due date until birth. Women choose to go to either nearest hospitals on the mainland or one near family.

That sounds so hard especially if it’s not your first child. There are many compromises to be made to live on a remote island.
I travelled to many remote places in Asia before I had children, now I when I travel with my children it has to be somewhere with access to a hospital in case of emergency.

AlwaysHungry123 · 04/05/2026 22:26

ScotiaLass · 04/05/2026 13:15

Many pregnant women in the Highlands will decamp to a hotel or a family member or friend's house closer to a maternity hospital in the run up to their due date. That applies to women who live in remote-rural areas of Scotland as well as the islands. If you live in Arndamurhcan for example you'd need to drive 2.5+ hours to the nearest consultant-led maternity unit in Inverness (although there is a mid-wife led unit in Fort William). In an emergency you're likely to be transported to hospital by helicopter. I expect home births are more common, but as someone who had an unexpected emergency during my own second home birth I find that terrifying! (We had a good outcome because our nearest maternity hospital is 15 minutes away).

These are exactly my thoughts - terrifying. It is based on my own traumatic experience during my deliveries so my first thought when I started reading the thread was about the pregnant women.

Fibblet · 05/05/2026 06:40

AlwaysHungry123 · 04/05/2026 08:13

It’s been fascinating reading this thread. Off the topic a bit but what do pregnant women do on the islands when they’re about to give birth? Home birth?
As someone who had two very traumatic deliveries and wouldn’t survive without specialist intervention during the delivery I can’t help but think of what help the women get and how quickly when things go wrong

My mother went to the hospital on the Orkney mainland. Perhaps a little before due date, but there’s a good modern hospital right there in Kirkwall.

ArabellaScott · 05/05/2026 10:24

Igneococcus · 04/05/2026 21:10

Kerrera residents have priority and can (and do) jump the queue but the Kerrera ferry is the smallest in the Calmac fleet and it just keeps going back and forth until everyone who waits at either end is across.

Rhubodach used to do the same, but they've brought in a strict timetable now and it won't wait for a second - not even if it's the last ferry and it sees you driving down the fucking ramp.

See, someone has pressed my Calmac button, I could rant for hours. I'll stop.

Donniemac · 05/05/2026 14:27

EarthSight · 04/05/2026 20:35

I have noticed OP that you don't seem to be taking much notice of people's warnings and you just shrug them off. I think you're here to have lots of people go 'FAB - GO FOR IT'! and just want to stick fingers in your ears. Please think of your son and not your romanticised island dream. You can move there when he's grown up.

I think I know that story, and if it is, then that move was mental-it was to Rhum. The weather there is horrendous. I think they went up in the hills-Rhum is mountainous. Sea level on the Ross of Mull is completely different. Snow line in the worst weather is 600ft. At sea level it never freezes. I lived in Berkshire for 6 years-the winters there were much colder than in Mull (summers much warmer though). Mull a bit windier though.

Janeb1965 · 07/05/2026 01:17

TransportNerd · 01/05/2026 11:42

Yeah, I live near Edinburgh, and my mother in law recently moved to Orkney. She's frequently expressed disappointment that we hardly ever visit. I'm not sure what she expected, it takes twelve hours and costs hundreds of pounds to get there. With all the best will in the world, how often are we going to do that?

OK, its not cheap you can fly from Edinburgh to Kirkwall in an hour. Or drive to Aberdeen and get the longer boat - or drive to scrabster and get the Hamnavoe. If you really want cheap get the Eember bus Ed - Inverness- Scrabster and foot pax over to Stromness. Prob £50 per adult or so and a lovely 8 hours journey if you time it right.

TransportNerd · 07/05/2026 19:59

Janeb1965 · 07/05/2026 01:17

OK, its not cheap you can fly from Edinburgh to Kirkwall in an hour. Or drive to Aberdeen and get the longer boat - or drive to scrabster and get the Hamnavoe. If you really want cheap get the Eember bus Ed - Inverness- Scrabster and foot pax over to Stromness. Prob £50 per adult or so and a lovely 8 hours journey if you time it right.

Flying from Edinburgh to Kirkwall is prohibitively expensive, it costs almost as much as it does to fly to New York!

However lovely the journey is, it's still incredibly long. The point I'm making is we can't just drop in, it's a major undertaking and it isn't cheap.

IslandLifeOtter · 13/05/2026 09:05

FullOfFresias · 04/05/2026 08:59

I’ve enjoyed reading this thread too. Also started watching Highland Cops off the back of this thread - really is an eye opener.

Does anyone remember GentleOtter (I think that was her username) sure she had a thread on here about remote living and possibly the birth of her baby?

Edited

I think about Gentleotter often. She did have a blog for a while, but nothings been posted for years. I hope she's doing OK.

https://www.blogger.com/profile/04728896118931496934

FullOfFresias · 13/05/2026 10:03

IslandLifeOtter · 13/05/2026 09:05

I think about Gentleotter often. She did have a blog for a while, but nothings been posted for years. I hope she's doing OK.

https://www.blogger.com/profile/04728896118931496934

Edited

Thank you for this. I hope she’s doing well too.
I’m sure if she was still on MN she would have jumped on this thread. A lovely poster.

FrostyMorn · 13/05/2026 18:26

I have just read I am an Island by Tamsin Calidas having seen it mentioned by several pp on this thread. Wow, what a book! I was not prepared for how harrowing it would be but it's beautiful, too, in its description of Hebridean life. She does suggest towards the end that life and the people have changed a lot since she first moved there (I think in the early 2000s) to be more welcoming - and of course, there are two sides to every story.

If you're interested in the Hebrides or just enjoy a memoir i'd recommend this but do be warned about the content!

House12 · 16/05/2026 18:26

Libertoo · 02/05/2026 20:06

I think it sounds like a dream, but I’d prefer to be west coast mainland rather than on an island. I moved to a small town in NE Scotland a few years ago, and I think you need to be aware that some smaller communities can be incredibly insular and don’t like outsiders, including the English. It’s incredibly difficult to get a job because half the town is related to itself and family gets work first, going 10 miles down the road to the next town is the furthest a lot of people have got (and some not even that much) so limited worldviews and narrow minded, it has always reminded me of a corrupt western town in 70s USA where you’re still an outsider 5 years later, the mayors son is head of police, and no one likes change or modernity. If you want to integrate, I personally think it’d be easier to move somewhere with a larger community nearby even if you live more rurally.

You should probably leave if this the way you talk about the community you’ve moved to.

ArabellaScott · 16/05/2026 22:28

FrostyMorn · 13/05/2026 18:26

I have just read I am an Island by Tamsin Calidas having seen it mentioned by several pp on this thread. Wow, what a book! I was not prepared for how harrowing it would be but it's beautiful, too, in its description of Hebridean life. She does suggest towards the end that life and the people have changed a lot since she first moved there (I think in the early 2000s) to be more welcoming - and of course, there are two sides to every story.

If you're interested in the Hebrides or just enjoy a memoir i'd recommend this but do be warned about the content!

Hmm. And I've read some of what islanders have said about her and her story.

Two sides, for sure.

Valeyard15 · 16/05/2026 23:04

I think you need to be aware that some smaller communities can be incredibly insular and don’t like outsiders, including the English.

Aware this is a generalisation, but that won't stop me from generalising myself - often the problem is that outsiders (usually, but not always, English) move to such places with utterly unrealistic expectations and attitudes. I have seen people move to places thinking they'll be able to lord it over the dumb yokels, or expect to be treated with some kind of deference. I remember one person landing at the ferry terminal having made no arrangements for a moving van as they expected the whole island to turn out to help them move.

OhBuggerandArse · 17/05/2026 00:23

Valeyard15 · 16/05/2026 23:04

I think you need to be aware that some smaller communities can be incredibly insular and don’t like outsiders, including the English.

Aware this is a generalisation, but that won't stop me from generalising myself - often the problem is that outsiders (usually, but not always, English) move to such places with utterly unrealistic expectations and attitudes. I have seen people move to places thinking they'll be able to lord it over the dumb yokels, or expect to be treated with some kind of deference. I remember one person landing at the ferry terminal having made no arrangements for a moving van as they expected the whole island to turn out to help them move.

That is mad - how far did they have to move their stuff, and what happened in the end?

Valeyard15 · 17/05/2026 00:35

OhBuggerandArse · 17/05/2026 00:23

That is mad - how far did they have to move their stuff, and what happened in the end?

Someone found them and brought a van, so in a sense they were right, but the attitude was more "Jesus, we better help this idiot out before they die of exposure" than "Welcome, English overlord."

TakeALookAtTheseSwatches · 17/05/2026 10:20

I do think the reality is much different from the dream for all the reasons pps have stated. An only child who is homeschooled would be incredibly isolated, I couldn't do that to my child

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread