Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be concerned about Green candidates and antisemitism?

248 replies

Twiglets1 · 24/04/2026 08:23

Ironically, given that the Green party is led by a Jewish man, the party has become home to political candidates causing distress and fear for many in the Jewish community.

Dr Phil Brookes, the Green Party candidate for Manor Park, Newcastle stated in a social media post that “it takes serious effort not to be a tiny bit anti-Semitic”.

Then there’s Sabine Mairey, the Green candidate for Clapham Town in south London. She posted a video on social media stating that a terrorist attack on a synagogue was “not anti-Semitism” but “revenge”.

Councillor Hau-Yu Tam is the Green candidate in the Deptford ward of Lewisham. She has expressed support for her “brilliant comrade and lawyer” Franck Magennis whose law firm Riverway to the Sea has sought the de-proscription of Hamas – the anti-Semitic terrorist group responsible for the mass murder and rape of October 7. She said she was extremely proud of Magennis for “blazing the way on this intervention”.

Ifhat Shaheen is a Green candidate in Stoke Newington. She has defended the October 7 attacks and suggested that Israel is harvesting organs from Palestinians.

Also in London is council candidate Saiqa Ali who posted an image of the Earth being strangled by a snake clothed in an Israeli flag, accompanied by the caption “It’s time to cut the head of this snake”.

Chandni Chopra is the Green Party candidate for Heaton, Newcastle. She has questioned whether Hamas used rape during their attacks despite the horrific evidence and previously described Zionism as a “mental illness”.

A second irony is that many Green Party voters will pride themselves on their anti-racist credentials. Why then is there growing support for a party whose candidates expressed such overt racism towards one of Britain’s minority communities?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
inamarina · Yesterday 12:22

HermioneWeasley · 24/04/2026 15:28

I’m not Jewish and I find the open anti semitism really scary. It seems that arson attacks on Jewish property are happening every other day now.

I will always stand with the Jewish community but it feels like we’re trying to hold back the tide. It feels very dark at the moment.

This is how I feel too, and I find the tide analogy very apt.
I keep seeing the same arguments again and again, for example about anti-Zionism vs antisemitism and how not all Jews are Zionists, as if that made questioning the existence of the only Jewish state acceptable.

inamarina · Yesterday 12:45

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 07:07

Googling Sharah Ali sent me down a rabbit hole @Whatifitallgoesright & discovered this article about Polanski:

Beware the bankrupt hellscape of Polanski Land

The Green Party leader’s plan to banish Right-wingers is as comical as it is chilling

It was on his podcast Bold Politics that he wondered out loud whether Right-wingers should have a place in society. He said he’s down with the idea of building a “complete utopia” but first we might have to do something about those nasty people who refuse to genuflect at the altar of his own wet-Left bonkers politics.

“There are people,” he said, “who identify as Right-wing or indeed even far-Right. And no matter what humanity or community we put them in, they are set on destroying [things] or pushing this toxicity”.

Could we really live with this ideological riff-raff, he wondered, or should we fence them off? “Do we think we can change their minds? Or is it a case of building a society that doesn’t include them?”

Even his guest, the broadcaster Zakia Sewell, seemed startled by his Stalinist dream of a society made up of hellish zones, where Lefties get to play a full role while Right-wingers are herded into a limbo of unpersonhood. Might you be “in danger of alienating people who are perhaps more moderate”, she asked?

It’s horrendous that the leader of a party that looks set to clean up among the keffiyeh classes in the leafier bits of Britain can so cavalierly gab about exiling people on the basis of their beliefs.

www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/35cb6024ae06af63

The statements he made in this interview are absolutely chilling.

inamarina · Yesterday 13:11

ThatCyanCat · Yesterday 09:15

Denies that Hamas raped women on October 7 (and kind of implies that October 7 was sort of acceptable if mass rapes hadn't taken place, which obviously they did) and weaponises a scandal from 30+ years ago in which law and protocol were broken, and action taken against the perpetrator (entirely rightly), as some sort of evidence that the Jewish state routinely and continuously steals organs.

And lectures us on antisemitism.

It’s mind-boggling, isn’t it?
And what’s happening in Lebanon is apparently “part of a deliberate strategy to make it impossible to grow food/ live safely”, no mention of Hezbollah and their firing rockets at Israel.

SharonEllis · Yesterday 13:33

I think we know Israel is just supposed to roll over and take it.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 13:39

SharonEllis · Yesterday 13:33

I think we know Israel is just supposed to roll over and take it.

Apparently so.

I don’t know why - would any other country be expected to?

Rhetoric question. Of course they would not.

OP posts:
Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · Yesterday 13:48

inamarina · Yesterday 13:11

It’s mind-boggling, isn’t it?
And what’s happening in Lebanon is apparently “part of a deliberate strategy to make it impossible to grow food/ live safely”, no mention of Hezbollah and their firing rockets at Israel.

You don't need to spray glyphosates on fields, loot people's homes or smash their pianos in order to stop Hezbollah firing rockets...
What happened to Israel's "smart drones"?

inamarina · Yesterday 13:56

Thank you for the link, very interesting!

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 13:57

Something doesn’t stack up @Longtimelurkerfinallyposts

You campaign & educate people about rape yet are choosing not to believe the testimony of Jewish women saying they experienced sexual violence or rape by Hamas, or witnessed it in others.

Is that how you normally advise people to respond to allegations of rape - disbelieve them?

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · Yesterday 14:00

The Polanski Principle indeed @SharonEllis thanks for the link.

OP posts:
inamarina · Yesterday 14:06

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · Yesterday 13:48

You don't need to spray glyphosates on fields, loot people's homes or smash their pianos in order to stop Hezbollah firing rockets...
What happened to Israel's "smart drones"?

So you believe the reports of looting in Lebanon but not those of Israeli women being raped on October 7th?
How do you pick and choose what to believe?

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · Yesterday 14:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 14:44

@Longtimelurkerfinallyposts you’re choosing to believe Hamas over women saying they suffered sexual violence & rape.

What is it about Hamas that makes them more believable than their Israeli women? I mean, they literally filmed themselves killing civilians.

OP posts:
ParmaVioletTea · Yesterday 14:55

So @Longtimelurkerfinallyposts you believe fanatical murderous psychopaths who want to destroy the state of Israel, over Jews?

We see you ...

Another example of casual fundamental anti-Semitism, so casual & fundamental to your world iew that you don't even notice it. Despicable.

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 15:13

I actually am super confused about what forensic evidence you are looking for from people who were kidnapped…

Whatever. Anyone who thinks Hamas is some sort of innocent party here is no one I really need to engage with any further. I understand exactly who you are and I hope you live far away from me.

SharonEllis · Yesterday 15:22

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 15:13

I actually am super confused about what forensic evidence you are looking for from people who were kidnapped…

Whatever. Anyone who thinks Hamas is some sort of innocent party here is no one I really need to engage with any further. I understand exactly who you are and I hope you live far away from me.

Couldn't agree more. Disgusting post.

inamarina · Yesterday 15:37

@Longtimelurkerfinallyposts
If you really believe that the hostages were treated well in captivity I’m really not sure what to say to you.

• Amit Soussana, the first released hostage to speak publicly about her experience, testified that she was sexually assaulted at gunpoint by a captor while being held in a private home in Gaza
• Arbel Yehoud reported being raped every day during her captivity
• Rom Braslavski testified to being stripped naked, tied up and subjected to sexual assaults
• Guy Gilboa-Dalal described being blindfolded and tied to a chair while a captor made explicit sexual threats, pressed a gun to his head, and sexually assaulted him
• Yarden Bibas was mocked after being told of his wife’s and children’s deaths by saying it "didn't matter" because he could just get a "new and better" wife and children
• Eli Sharabi was told during his 491 days in captivity that his wife and daughters were still alive despite them being killed on October 7th and even asked by a masked Hamas operative during the ridiculous release ceremony how he was feeling, to which Eli responded he was looking forward to seeing his wife and daughters again

These are just a few examples.

Did you just deliberately choose not to see any of these reports?

inamarina · Yesterday 15:38

SharonEllis · Yesterday 15:22

Couldn't agree more. Disgusting post.

Utterly disgusting. Twisting reality to suit their own agenda.

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 15:46

That detail is horrific, @inamarina , and I know is only part of the atrocities.
It makes for difficult reading.
I have no idea why people would believe perpetrators rather than victims. 💛

SharonEllis · Yesterday 15:50

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 15:46

That detail is horrific, @inamarina , and I know is only part of the atrocities.
It makes for difficult reading.
I have no idea why people would believe perpetrators rather than victims. 💛

And its just a tiny fraction of what happened.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 15:51

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 15:13

I actually am super confused about what forensic evidence you are looking for from people who were kidnapped…

Whatever. Anyone who thinks Hamas is some sort of innocent party here is no one I really need to engage with any further. I understand exactly who you are and I hope you live far away from me.

Thankfully the law means posts will be deleted.

inamarina · Yesterday 15:51

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 15:46

That detail is horrific, @inamarina , and I know is only part of the atrocities.
It makes for difficult reading.
I have no idea why people would believe perpetrators rather than victims. 💛

I just really don’t get it why some people are so determined to pretend all these reports don’t exist.

SharonEllis · Yesterday 15:59

inamarina · Yesterday 15:51

I just really don’t get it why some people are so determined to pretend all these reports don’t exist.

Because we must not ever believe Jews or have any sympathy for them. The empathy gap is critical to the whole system. And the propaganda and manipulation tropes must be reinforced.

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 16:00

inamarina · Yesterday 15:51

I just really don’t get it why some people are so determined to pretend all these reports don’t exist.

Nor me. Just be human. Acknowledge atrocities, even if they happen to Israelis, because these were innocent people and it was visited on them in their homes.
It doesn't mean to say that you therefore agree with the Netanyahu government and it's actions.

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 16:01

SharonEllis · Yesterday 15:59

Because we must not ever believe Jews or have any sympathy for them. The empathy gap is critical to the whole system. And the propaganda and manipulation tropes must be reinforced.

That's horrific, because it takes humanity away from Jews, and they cease to be equals, they are "other", and that makes me shudder.

SharonEllis · Yesterday 16:06

OrangeAxolotyl · Yesterday 16:01

That's horrific, because it takes humanity away from Jews, and they cease to be equals, they are "other", and that makes me shudder.

Its how antisemitism has always worked

Swipe left for the next trending thread