Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to Buy.

226 replies

Differentforgirls · 03/04/2026 18:35

Was “Right to Buy” a policy that has created the current housing crisis? I think it was.

OP posts:
MsGreying · 03/04/2026 20:22

Differentforgirls · 03/04/2026 18:46

The fact they bought their house took it out of council ownership though.

But they'd live in it until they died and are allowed one succession.
If they had three kids then there'd be two kids wanting their own family home.

The population has increased.
From when David Attenborough started on TV the world population was 4bn. It's now 8bn.

Itsmetheflamingo · 03/04/2026 20:23

GreenGodiva · 03/04/2026 20:14

Our council regularly buys property that’s for sale, I know because my dad got into a bidding war with them to buy back an ex council property ( the council won). Our local paper is full of articles from the council and we have regular consultations about planning etc and go to meetings about them in the local area as they are destroying green spaces left right and centre and we’re have several endangered animal populations locally. But sure. You totally and definitely know more than me even though they send local tenants information leaflets explaining it all etc. our council DO reinvest money into new housing stock. But affordable housing is often multiple developers and x amount is given to the council in exchange for planning.

Your council buys back old stock at market prices at volume?! wtf? What a waste of money.

BIWI · 03/04/2026 20:26

It was a complete travesty that people were allowed to sell/buy council houses.

Totally destroyed the notion that councils should be able to provide affordable homes for those on lower incomes. There was no need to introduce capitalism/profiteering into the sector.

ExtraOnions · 03/04/2026 20:41

It wasn’t HTB itself that was the problem, it was that the legislation (thanks Maggie) prevent the Councils from using that money to build new / replacement houses. Councils were not allowed to spend the money on Capital Projects

Consequently, the rate of council house building dropped dramatically. In 1980, 94,140 new social homes were built in England; by 1983, this number had halved, and by the 1990s, the average fell to below 5,000 per year.

Ramping that up isn’t easy, land is owned by speculators, the skills are all sat in private construction firms (who want to make a big fat profit), every housing development is met with local protests, and no housing developer is building the infrastructure.. so more expenditure for councils who don’t have the money (and also planning skills are in short supply in most councils)

TheOnlyAletheia · 03/04/2026 20:43

Councils for many years weren’t allowed to use RTB receipts to build new houses. So that combined with the loss of stock was a big factor in reducing availability.

TheOnlyAletheia · 03/04/2026 20:45

Itsmetheflamingo · 03/04/2026 20:23

Your council buys back old stock at market prices at volume?! wtf? What a waste of money.

Not really stupid as it reduces the temporary accommodation bills which are soaring

previouslyknownas · 03/04/2026 20:46

I bought my council house back

I was given it at age 20 a large 2.5 beds
semi detached end of a small close
lovely big garden and drive
you would have no idea it’s an ex council house

still live in it - no mortgage

my late parents bought their council house as well
When they passed away I sold it and my son was able to use the money to buy his own house with a very small mortgage

my sister bought hers as well and still lives in it

lots of people I know had council houses and bought them and pretty much most of them still live in them they haven’t sold them or rented them out

for some people like myself and my extended family & friends RTB was great deal

I don’t feel any guilt about buying it either ,

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 20:49

Yes. Thatcher has a lot to answer for.

BansheeOfTheSouth · 03/04/2026 20:52

Differentforgirls · 03/04/2026 18:53

I used to work for a council. I remember when they built new council housing after the “right to buy” legislation, the people who moved in had the right to buy after two years. The council had to give in. It wasn’t sustainable to build new houses the sell them at a loss.

The Right to Buy scheme was abolished in Scotland in 2016. We still have a housing crisis but at least the housing associations are building new properties because they are continously receiving rent payments.

IMO it has also made it less desirable for people who can afford to get mortgages to apply for social housing as they won't ever be able to buy them.

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 20:52

rwalker · 03/04/2026 19:00

yes but if it was council owned that lifetime tenant it wouldn’t make any housing stock available

but I do think discount should be paid back at market rate if it was ever sold

Edited

Lifetime tenancies need to go too.

LlynTegid · 03/04/2026 20:53

I think it played a part. The worst bit was discounts with no sell on clause.

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:01

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 20:52

Lifetime tenancies need to go too.

Why?

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 21:03

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:01

Why?

It’s massively contributing to the shortage and people shouldn’t be in council properties once they are well off.

ProudCat · 03/04/2026 21:03

Differentforgirls · 03/04/2026 18:35

Was “Right to Buy” a policy that has created the current housing crisis? I think it was.

Largest council estate near where I live, about 50% of RTB properties from the 1980s are now owned by corporate landlords and rented to Chinese students that the local university can't get enough of. Yes, that's created a huge housing crisis here.

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:05

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 21:03

It’s massively contributing to the shortage and people shouldn’t be in council properties once they are well off.

So it's down to SH tenants to sort out the housing crisis?

XenoBitch · 03/04/2026 21:06

I am getting a sense of deja vu here. Was one council tenant bashing thread today not enough?

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 21:07

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:05

So it's down to SH tenants to sort out the housing crisis?

No, it’s down to councils to ensure that the people in SH actually need to be.

ChangePrivacyQuestion · 03/04/2026 21:11

If you ask me, lack of flat living culture is what's killing us, housing-wise. Leasehold are partly to blame, but in a country where a third of the population is single, a third lives in couples and a third of the remaining third stops at one child, houses are a madness. It drives an exorbitant price of housing. RTB and all the other schemes are just robbing Peter to pay Paul. Look to Nordic countries, Germany, France... norm is a 2 bed flat. We're too space greedy for the size of the island we're living on.

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:12

User79853257976 · 03/04/2026 21:07

No, it’s down to councils to ensure that the people in SH actually need to be.

Or it's down to people not being arsey and jealous because some people on lower incomes have secure affordable housing.

SeriousFaffing · 03/04/2026 21:18

Partly, yes. But it’s multifaceted.

I’d strongly recommend watching the BBC’s ‘Britain’s housing crisis: what went wrong?’.

A very big part of it is the monetisation of property (obviously further enabled by council houses not being readily available). A home should be a right, not an asset. But now people think it’s the norm and a business idea to build their ‘portfolio’ of houses to rent out to people in order to build profit for themselves. Again, a home is a home, not an asset. It is a right to have a roof over your head to keep you warm and safe.

Another aspect is the volume builders only building out their sites by a restricted amount each year. Research has proven that they do this. They release homes like they are diamonds to retain their profit margins. And yet the UK has charged the volume builders with ‘solving’ our housing crisis.

Yet another facet is that pension funds are HEAVILY invested in property in the UK, thus increasing the price of land. This is partly because the birth rate continues to fall, life expectancy continues to rise, and people still expect their pensions. Pension funds companies all over the world (particularly Australia) are investing in UK land, because they have to have a certain investment and there is little that is as certain to increase profits as property.

I could go on but I think this gives a good flavour…

BIWI · 03/04/2026 21:19

previouslyknownas · 03/04/2026 20:46

I bought my council house back

I was given it at age 20 a large 2.5 beds
semi detached end of a small close
lovely big garden and drive
you would have no idea it’s an ex council house

still live in it - no mortgage

my late parents bought their council house as well
When they passed away I sold it and my son was able to use the money to buy his own house with a very small mortgage

my sister bought hers as well and still lives in it

lots of people I know had council houses and bought them and pretty much most of them still live in them they haven’t sold them or rented them out

for some people like myself and my extended family & friends RTB was great deal

I don’t feel any guilt about buying it either ,

But the problem with this is that for every property you bought/sold, there was one less to rent for someone who needed it.

So reducing the stock of social housing for those in need.

SeriousFaffing · 03/04/2026 21:20

SeriousFaffing · 03/04/2026 21:18

Partly, yes. But it’s multifaceted.

I’d strongly recommend watching the BBC’s ‘Britain’s housing crisis: what went wrong?’.

A very big part of it is the monetisation of property (obviously further enabled by council houses not being readily available). A home should be a right, not an asset. But now people think it’s the norm and a business idea to build their ‘portfolio’ of houses to rent out to people in order to build profit for themselves. Again, a home is a home, not an asset. It is a right to have a roof over your head to keep you warm and safe.

Another aspect is the volume builders only building out their sites by a restricted amount each year. Research has proven that they do this. They release homes like they are diamonds to retain their profit margins. And yet the UK has charged the volume builders with ‘solving’ our housing crisis.

Yet another facet is that pension funds are HEAVILY invested in property in the UK, thus increasing the price of land. This is partly because the birth rate continues to fall, life expectancy continues to rise, and people still expect their pensions. Pension funds companies all over the world (particularly Australia) are investing in UK land, because they have to have a certain investment and there is little that is as certain to increase profits as property.

I could go on but I think this gives a good flavour…

PS not rescinding Right to Buy in England is a political decision - particularly when it has been retracted elsewhere in the UK.

BIWI · 03/04/2026 21:21

XenoBitch · 03/04/2026 21:06

I am getting a sense of deja vu here. Was one council tenant bashing thread today not enough?

It's not about bashing tenants though - it's about the whole principal of councils selling off housing, thus depriving those who might need it.

UnhappyHobbit · 03/04/2026 21:24

It’s difficult to know but some people have seriously benefited financially from the right to buy. I know someone a family that bought their council house. Recently they sold up for a pretty £500k but before they did, they split the massive garden and created a building plot and sold that.

Great for them, but it feels very profiteering to say they got a huge discount from
the council due to the length of their tenancy.

hazelberry · 03/04/2026 21:25

BIWI · 03/04/2026 21:21

It's not about bashing tenants though - it's about the whole principal of councils selling off housing, thus depriving those who might need it.

It will turn into a SH bashing thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread