Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so protective of my child?

53 replies

OnTheJourneyOnwards · 20/10/2025 18:43

I was chatting with another mum (close friend) today and we were talking about how important it is to have school mums to help out with pick ups from time to time.

She was telling me she had found a lovely couple through school and they clicked well and had similar parenting styles. And she said that from time to time they picked up each other’s kids from school.

I said I wished I could trust other parents with my daughter but I just don’t.

I’ve got mum friends at school but they are always talking about how they yell at their kids, and how they fight with their husbands. They are perfectly nice women generally and I enjoy their company, but one admits to drinking a bottle of wine a night. The other had a day when her child didn’t go to school but her child turned up the next day with a black eye and she was a bit nervous about talking about what happened but mentioned a grumpy husband. They have otherwise perfectly ordinary middle class looking lives from the outside but to me these little things are little red flags for leaving my child alone with them or relying on them for the occasional pick up.

I brought this up with my friend and said I just don’t trust anyone else enough with my DD. Simply, you just can’t tell and abuse often happens to kids from people who are known to the child.

But she said maybe they just ARE ordinary people who trust me enough to share their feelings and vulnerable moments with me.

It made me wonder… am I being too overprotective?

I would never shout at my DD for anything except if she was in danger, like running into the road for example. DD is very sensitive and gentle but has signs of ADHD so doesn’t always pay attention, so the thought that another parent might yell at her worries me.

Would you let another parent pick up your child from school? AIBU to not allow this?

OP posts:
Fishingboatbobbingnight · 21/10/2025 10:00

That level of anxiety about the pretty normal every-day-life scenario whereby your dc will want to go on play dates , without you ..is something you may need to keep an eye on.
Extensive research by University of Sussex regarding parental anxiety and the high chance of anxiety and over protective behaviour causing similar issues in your child are well documented. Maybe have a read and form your own opinion.

https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/54942

To equate a mother having the occasional shout at their kids and bickering with their husbands to a child who came to school with a black eye , shows a worrying lack of ability to judge risk and end up catastrophizing normal behaviour. All of which will ultimately impact your DC negatively. Probably time for you to seek some good therapy in this area .

Parenting in a time of anxiety: Psychologists seek 2,000 anxious parent volunteers for major new study

Professor Sam Cartwright-Hatton and her team are launching their new online Parenting with Anxiety programme.

https://www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/54942

ThirtysomethingMummy · 21/10/2025 11:44

My Mum was like this. She never let me go to other people’s houses, never liked me going on play dates, was always the parent helper on school trips etc. guess what? I got abused by a family member anyway and I’ve grown up resentful of her as I left school with basically no friends due to her controlling behaviours. I do get it. DC are very precious to me and I do get anxious when they go to others houses but I need to not show this so that they can enjoy their childhood x

Spinmerightroundbaby · 21/10/2025 21:09

Finsburyfancy · 20/10/2025 18:54

It's good that you"re a perfect parent. I've shouted at my children a handful of times (literally), so despite devoting my life to them and putting my career on hold, you're absolutely right, there is zero chance I could keep your child safe on a ten minute journey home 🙄

Hear hear. OP is ridiculous.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page