Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so upset and betrayed

65 replies

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 08:43

My husband was diagnosed with cancer at the end of July. We told some trusted friends (friends we’ve known since he was 16 and I was 18 and we’re almost 40 now) with strict wishes not to tell anyone else as we were in shock and so much to process. He had the affected organ removed in the second week of September. We have two young children who know daddy had a poorly organ and needed an operation to remove it. We didn’t mention cancer as our 8 year old understands what it is and there’s a slim chance my husband may not need further treatment. We wanted to hold off having that difficult conversation if it may not be needed. We won’t find out pathology for 6-8 weeks and until the tumour is finally graded and the suspected lymph nodes biopsied.

The issue - the friends we told, who have been great with childcare, emotional support and bringing food etc chose to tell their sister (and dad, so the family has discussed it and they are a close family who hang out all the time). The sister’s kid is best friends with our 8 year old - they hang out every day in school and sit on the same table. We are worried kids may overhear things and then pass things to ours when we are not ready to tell them.

I guess I am hurt and pissed off they told their sister when we specifically told them not to. They asked a couple of times if they wanted us to tell people (close mutual friends) and we repeatedly said no. They said they wouldn’t.

My husband was not ready to tell a lot of people - it’s been such a rollercoaster since finding out to trying to understand staging and grading and different opinions from surgeons and oncology. We’ve gone from it’s not curable, only treatable, to it may be curative to remove the organ, let’s have the surgery and see. We’ve been navigating summer holidays and managing our emotions without it affecting our children, who are our biggest concern. We desperately don’t want to cast a dark shadow over them and their childhood when 6 weeks since diagnosis, there’s a small chance this surgery may be curative. We will have the conversation with them and I think that’s what’s so upsetting, feeling forced to have that chat with our children before we wanted to. Terrified they’ll hear something from someone at school and we will then lose trust between us and create other issues.

Our deepest darkest moments feel like gossip they’ve shared. The friend and her sister’s mum also had cancer of the same organ so it’s a trauma that will bring up bad memories for our friend but we very clearly stated we didn’t want anyone else knowing. The friend could have talked to her partner about it, it wasn’t as she didn’t have anyone to talk to.

We feel upset and disrespected and almost now forced into telling and worrying our kids to protect them from hearing anything on the playground they weren’t prepared to hear.

I know they’re capable of keeping medical things private - they kept a close mutual friend’s fertility issues to themselves for years. I have no issue that this mutual friend didn’t want to share with me - I’m old enough to respect people’s wishes and understand that I’ll know if I’m supposed to. (I know now because this mutual friend has now told me btw and yay, she now has a beautiful baby). So I feel even more upset they’ve been so loosey goosey with us.

What do I do? Confront them?

Sorry this post is so long and rambling, I’ve been quite upset by it and slept on it, and still feel so angry. Why do we have this on top of everything else, feel like I can’t trust people we love and relied on.

OP posts:
VainAbigail · 20/09/2025 08:49

What do I do? Confront them?

You listen to what your husband wants to do and go from there, after all, he’s the one that’s ill, not you.

JadziaD · 20/09/2025 08:49

I understand why you are upset. But j also undrrstand why rhey have told.family. I think the key thing is the risk that their children hear. I would be very very clear with them that the reason you are keeping this quiet is largely because you want to choose how and when to tell your children, once you have more information and that you feel very concerned that there is now a risk that they will have to be told sooner.

They will deny it and assure you they are not letting the dc know.

You have every right nonetheless to reiterate the point.

BlueJuniper94 · 20/09/2025 08:52

I'm so sorry your husband is unwell and hope he makes a full recovery Xx

PinkyFlamingo · 20/09/2025 08:53

Of course you say something, they promised not to say anything and they did

MynameisJune · 20/09/2025 08:55

I’m sorry your family is going through this. I think that you are maybe projecting some of the hurt and upset you feel at your husband’s diagnosis onto the friendship.

They’ve been a great help for you, in your words. But maybe your friend needed to talk to her sister and Dad about it because it triggered emotions around her mums death. And the only people who really know what that loss feels like is her sister and her Dad.

I appreciate the added complication of your children being friends and maybe hearing something. So by all means explain why you didn’t want anyone else to know. But you risk losing the friendship if you go in too hard on this when emotions are understandably very high right now.

thepariscrimefiles · 20/09/2025 08:56

VainAbigail · 20/09/2025 08:49

What do I do? Confront them?

You listen to what your husband wants to do and go from there, after all, he’s the one that’s ill, not you.

What a twatty post to an obviously distressed OP. OP isn't ill but they are her children and she is worrying about them finding out about their dad's cancer from her friend's children.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/09/2025 08:59

Ita a tricky one. Yes you told them in confidence. Yes they shouldn't have passed this on.

However I imagine if I had a very close friend who I'd known most of my life who had a life threatening illness, who I was providing some practical support to, and it was the same type of cancer which was triggering difficult memories for me...I'd want to tell someone close to talk it through as I'd also be very upset.

There are lots of threads on here from people who have been dropped by friends as soon as they're ill, and it sounds like they've been supportive. So I wouldn't fall out with them but I would tell them that you're worried your chd would find out and please could they make sure that their daughter is not told anything

RogerR4bbit · 20/09/2025 09:00

I would give them the benefit of the doubt.

It sounds like they have been doing a lot for you; childcare, bringing food, emotional support etc and that would have taken up a lot of time and energy.

It could be, for example, that they were invited to a family event and couldn’t go because they were watching your kids and needed to explain the situation so they didn’t offend anyone.

Unless you know they told just to gossip, which is an entirely different thing.

so sorry you are having to go through this x

nomas · 20/09/2025 09:05

the friends we told, who have been great with childcare, emotional support and bringing food

This is the bit to focus on. These are good people who have made a small mistake. They haven’t told their child.

I would be grateful to have such good friends.

If you did confront them, it will affect your friendship and you may even lose the friendship, so be aware of that.

I hope your husband makes a full recovery.

Livelaughlurgy · 20/09/2025 09:07

What would be the value of confronting them? It won't undo the secret. I can understand your fear, but the chances are the sisters daughter knows nothing.

CeciliaMars · 20/09/2025 09:07

You felt the need to share the news so you could access some support - maybe she felt the same way?

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 09:52

CeciliaMars · 20/09/2025 09:07

You felt the need to share the news so you could access some support - maybe she felt the same way?

Come on. It’s a bit different. He and I asked her not to tell anyone. He’s currently going through the worst time of his life and worried about it affecting our children. His biggest concern, even more than his own mortality, is how will it affect our children. Everyone says it, but he really is the best dad.

The friends knew our biggest worry and still chose to talk about it. The friends are married and have been together for 15 years. They could have talked to each other for support instead of deliberately disrespecting not just my wish, but my husband’s wish. He’s been friends with this friend since high school.

Why is it ok for them to keep other people’s medical issues private but not his?

OP posts:
SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 09:59

nomas · 20/09/2025 09:05

the friends we told, who have been great with childcare, emotional support and bringing food

This is the bit to focus on. These are good people who have made a small mistake. They haven’t told their child.

I would be grateful to have such good friends.

If you did confront them, it will affect your friendship and you may even lose the friendship, so be aware of that.

I hope your husband makes a full recovery.

Thank you.

We don’t want to lose friendships, we have all been there for each other through hard times over the last 20 years. Maybe that’s why it feels so shocking to be betrayed on something so important.

I feel like it needs to be said it’s not ok. But aware it may hurt friendships.

We often let things slide in the name of not upsetting the applecart but this just hurts. A lot. Why are we not worthy of keeping things private but other people are? Is our pain and grief just dinner table conversation?

OP posts:
AmberJumps · 20/09/2025 10:01

That is not ok at all in my book OP. I am so sorry you are both having to deal with this along with your husband's Dx. I wouldnt react, just detact yourself from them. I think it unlikely your children know, but just be on the lookout for signs of distress.

I am so sorry this is happening to you and hope in 10 years you can look back and think how the hell did we get through that. You do though, you just manage and you will.

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 10:03

thepariscrimefiles · 20/09/2025 08:56

What a twatty post to an obviously distressed OP. OP isn't ill but they are her children and she is worrying about them finding out about their dad's cancer from her friend's children.

Thank you.

For clarity, me and my husband feel the same. Upset they’ve broken our confidence and worried about our children finding out before we’re ready to tell them properly.

OP posts:
Oneeyedonkey · 20/09/2025 10:04

I think you were wrong not to tell your children
They aren't stupid and will have picked up on conversations, atmosphere etc

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 10:09

RogerR4bbit · 20/09/2025 09:00

I would give them the benefit of the doubt.

It sounds like they have been doing a lot for you; childcare, bringing food, emotional support etc and that would have taken up a lot of time and energy.

It could be, for example, that they were invited to a family event and couldn’t go because they were watching your kids and needed to explain the situation so they didn’t offend anyone.

Unless you know they told just to gossip, which is an entirely different thing.

so sorry you are having to go through this x

Thank you.

We are so grateful and appreciative of their help. We have helped them plenty in the past too and there is no scoreboard or tally we keep, we just all muck in.

We both just feel hurt and upset when we asked them to keep it private.

Question is - do we say how we feel?

OP posts:
SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 10:11

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/09/2025 08:59

Ita a tricky one. Yes you told them in confidence. Yes they shouldn't have passed this on.

However I imagine if I had a very close friend who I'd known most of my life who had a life threatening illness, who I was providing some practical support to, and it was the same type of cancer which was triggering difficult memories for me...I'd want to tell someone close to talk it through as I'd also be very upset.

There are lots of threads on here from people who have been dropped by friends as soon as they're ill, and it sounds like they've been supportive. So I wouldn't fall out with them but I would tell them that you're worried your chd would find out and please could they make sure that their daughter is not told anything

It is tricky.

I feel like that’s a low bar - they’ve been supportive so it’s kind of a pass that they’ve broken our trust?

A good deed outweighs a bad one?

Would you want to know as a friend how hurt another friend has felt by your actions? Or should the friend just quietly move on because their feelings don’t matter because you’re generally a good friend otherwise?

OP posts:
AgDulAmach · 20/09/2025 10:12

If you say how you feel, what are you hoping for?

My family had a habit of keeping secrets and acting as though things like illness were shameful. It was a completely toxic way to behave and a big part of why I'm not close to them these days. They directed all their energy into hiding things rather than into actually dealing with the difficult subject. I understand your hurt but it may be worth looking at why you're so invested in hiding this, particularly from your own children. If your son comes to you at a later stage and says 'why didn't you tell me dad had cancer?' what will you tell him? Half truths are so hard for children to handle.

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 10:12

VainAbigail · 20/09/2025 08:49

What do I do? Confront them?

You listen to what your husband wants to do and go from there, after all, he’s the one that’s ill, not you.

I wasn’t clear. He feels the same as I do. Hurt and upset. It’s the one thing he’s actually asked of anyone, was for it not to go further.

OP posts:
AgDulAmach · 20/09/2025 10:17

I would add that if my adored best friend said her DH had cancer but I could tell no one and her son could find out by accident, the first thing I'd do is give her a kind but direct talking to about how dangerous that is. It's one thing for your mother and father to tell you and support you, it's another for you to stumble across the information in a situation where you feel totally lied to, with the message that it's a topic that must not be discussed.

AltitudeCheck · 20/09/2025 10:22

How did you come to find out they had talked to their family?

I would say something so that you aren't holding resentment when you need the emotional bandwidth to be focusing on other things. Can you thank them for everything they have done and say how much you appreciate their friendship and say tou have something you need to getboff your chest then reiterate how important it is to you that you get to control what your kids know and how you feel they have put that at risk by breaking a very clear confidence you had asked them to keep. Express your disappointment and how it's hurt you and then move on. Longstanding deep friendship is too valuable to throw away for this mistake.

MargaretThursday · 20/09/2025 10:42

RogerR4bbit · 20/09/2025 09:00

I would give them the benefit of the doubt.

It sounds like they have been doing a lot for you; childcare, bringing food, emotional support etc and that would have taken up a lot of time and energy.

It could be, for example, that they were invited to a family event and couldn’t go because they were watching your kids and needed to explain the situation so they didn’t offend anyone.

Unless you know they told just to gossip, which is an entirely different thing.

so sorry you are having to go through this x

That would be what I'd suspect.

"Why are you doing so much for them? Why can't you come on the day out with them - you're prioritising them over us?"

I'd go back and just ask them to make sure that nothing is said in front of the children.

SVDW1136 · 20/09/2025 11:06

AgDulAmach · 20/09/2025 10:17

I would add that if my adored best friend said her DH had cancer but I could tell no one and her son could find out by accident, the first thing I'd do is give her a kind but direct talking to about how dangerous that is. It's one thing for your mother and father to tell you and support you, it's another for you to stumble across the information in a situation where you feel totally lied to, with the message that it's a topic that must not be discussed.

We know this. We have had support in how to deal with this with our children. We have told them daddy is poorly. We just haven’t mentioned cancer as there may be a chance he may not need further treatment. We then intend to tell them that after pathology, it was cancer but we have a positive path forward, (or whatever the path forward is, we will tell them).

If they were older, 10+ perhaps, we would have told them from the outset. They are just 8 and 5. How do you shatter their worlds when you don’t have a clear path? This is also our first time navigating a major illness as parents that affect us. We have been in a total spin being told stage 4 to potentially surgery may be curative.

Furthermore, please don’t judge us. There is no real right or wrong way to tell children. We have sought support from Maggie’s (a cancer support charity), and we know our children and decided as a couple, in a very considered manner, how we want to broach it with them. We don’t want to hide it, but just have the opportunity to tell them when we feel it’s right.

We just wanted to be able trust people in this trying time with our wishes.

OP posts:
GhostLivesHere · 20/09/2025 11:10

You are reacting in a hyper sensitive way. Understandably due to high emotional situation.

Words like betrayal are just amplifying this reaction

People are fallible

And if something is secret don't tell anyone, otherwise it's not a secret