Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a little heartbroken about having a boy

408 replies

bm2b · 03/09/2025 20:52

I already have a daughter and recently found out that this baby is a boy. I feel incredibly grateful to be pregnant again, and I know how lucky I am to be carrying a healthy baby. I already love him, and I know I’ll adore him completely when he arrives. But I’ve been caught off guard by this quiet feeling of sadness that I didn’t expect.

I’m very close to my mum. We speak every day, go on little trips together, help each other out, and are part of each other’s daily lives. I’ve started to build something similar with my daughter, even though she’s still young, and I suppose I imagined continuing that dynamic with another girl.

With a boy, I’m not sure what that relationship will look like in the long term. In so many families I’ve seen, sons gradually become more distant from their parents as they get older, especially once they have partners and children of their own. It often ends up being the wife’s parents who are more involved, while his own mum becomes more of an occasional visitor.

Of course there are exceptions. I can think of the odd “friend of a friend’s cousin” whose son stayed close and prioritised both sides of the family equally, or doesn’t automatically side with his partner when she’s being unfair. But in my experience, that feels like the exception rather than the norm.

I also worry about what raising a boy will be like day to day. I know it’s a stereotype, but the boys I’ve been around — nephews, friends’ kids — tend to be more energetic, more physical, and more chaotic. I’m a bit afraid I won’t enjoy that stage as much, or that I won’t know how to connect with him in the same way.

If anyone has felt this way too, I’d love to hear from you. Especially mums of older boys — did the bond end up being just as close, even if it looked a bit different? What parts of having a son surprised you in a good way?

OP posts:
Openyoureyes102733 · 04/09/2025 01:05

I wasn’t heartbroken but I was nervous about having a little boy because we have an all girl family and I “didn’t know” what to do with a boy. Of course I could imagine myself with a DD mini me.

i went on to have my first child - a boy
he is the best thing to ever happen to my life. I cannot imagine life without him

Openyoureyes102733 · 04/09/2025 01:06

Also to add… growing up I had a difficult relationship with my mum, however my mum and brother are two peas in a pod

YankSplaining · 04/09/2025 04:19

Controversial opinion, it seems, but no, you’re not being unreasonable. How many people here can say they know grown men who enjoy going out for mother-son days, just them and their mothers? And matrilineal advantage/“maternal grandparent advantage” is a real (though not universal) phenomenon that’s been studied by researchers.

I don’t think little boys are necessarily more energetic than little girls, but they don’t mature as quickly as little girls. So on average, an energetic little girl is going to be better than an energetic little boy of the same age at listening to adults and realizing when it’s time to settle down and pay attention.

I’m sure your baby will be a lovely little boy, but I don’t blame you for worrying that your odds of staying close to him throughout his life are lower than your odds of staying close to your daughter.

SugarPlumpFairyCakes · 04/09/2025 05:29

You’re going to adore your boy. It’s all a bit abstract now but you will cherish him. Like you do your daughter.

verycloakanddaggers · 04/09/2025 05:29

bm2b · 03/09/2025 21:15

Yes, I have a brother and a sister. My sister is really close to our mum — they talk every day, go shopping together, and she always invites her to the kids’ events or just over for a chat “because she was nearby.” They have this natural, everyday closeness in the same way I do with her.

My brother’s relationship with our mum is very different. He’s not distant or unkind, but everything is more formal and a bit hands-off. Any visits are arranged well in advance and usually come with a time slot, “we can do Sunday, but just from 12 to 3.” And I know his wife doesn’t appreciate it when my mum “oversteps” by bringing food or asking if she should help with pickups. Meanwhile, his wife’s parents are round all the time — her mum picks the kids up from school, drops off little meals, even goes on holiday with them. Our mum doesn’t get that same level of access. I know my brother asked about mum coming to one of the kids’ plays and the wife said there’s not enough tickets - her parents went.

It’s the same story in my husband’s family. He has a sister who’s incredibly close to their mum — constant calls, spontaneous visits etc. My husband’s relationship with her is friendly, but distant by comparison. And not because he doesn’t care, but just because he’s not as naturally in that rhythm, he’s busy with work and in all honesty I find her a bit overstepping when she does some things my mum does, and some things she does with her own daughter. I think everyone is just more welcoming of their own mum.

And I think that’s the case in most families I’ve seen — the woman tends to set the tone for how involved grandparents are, and understandably, she leans toward her own side. So yes, seeing that dynamic play out in both of our families (and most friends) does shape how I’m feeling now. Not because I think boys love their mums any less but because I’m afraid I just won’t get to stay as close.

Might be worth you thinking about self-fulfilling prophecies.

You've decided you can predict the future based on the stereotypes you subscribe to.

You've decided you'll be close to one child and not the other, which will put you on different paths with each of them.

Ihavetoask · 04/09/2025 05:34

All this is really worrying.

ProfessorRizz · 04/09/2025 05:40

I’m a mum of two boys, 12 and 9. They are brilliant, because they’ve been given equal parts love and clear guidelines. Yes, they were quite exuberant as toddlers, but they do chill out as they grow!

I also welcomed our new Year 7s into school yesterday. The boys were unfailingly polite, smiley, nervous, chatty and friendly.

I’m afraid you’ve fallen for a whole pile of propaganda about ‘what boys are like’.

Katemax82 · 04/09/2025 05:43

I never wanted boys as I already had 2 stepsons. I now have 1 girl and 3 boys! My daughter is the hardest work out of all 3. My boys are adorable (I love all my kids equally)

Anabla · 04/09/2025 05:58

I can sympathise with people saying they are perhaps experiencing some sadness about a gender but can't understand being heartbroken and it does make me feel sad for your son. It seems you've written off a relationship with him already and have bought into this stereotypical narrative about boys.

I have 2 sons. One is 3 and the other 3 months. My 3 year old is the most loving, adorable child I could imagine and I couldn't possibly imagine being closer to another child and I was delighted to find out I was having another boy.

My husband and his brother are closer to their mum than I am to mine and speak several times a week to my MIL. My dad had a brother and again they were a very close family and were very close to my grandmother. All the men in my family and male friends I know have remained close to their parents and there's no difference between the females in my life.

Relationship to parents and personality are nothing to do with gender.

IDreamOfElectricSheep · 04/09/2025 06:57

Build what your building with your dd with your ds. Yes, your boy may be energetic but it won’t be anything you can’t handle.
Build activity into your life. When kids are young, they’re happy to go on walks and to parks. Dress for the weather and it’s fine.
Go cycling, swimming and throw a ball around. Later, they’ll probably be doing some clubs.
Activity is good for everyone.
Dont worry. Build a good family life and do your best by both dcs.

HighLadyofTheNightCourt · 04/09/2025 07:18

I have one boy. He’s an only child so I can’t really compare it with having a girl BUT I don’t think I would have done anything differently anyway. I think a lot of the issues snd concerns are due to stereotypes and people treating boys and girls differently.

DS is almost 11. He’s very active and sporty but so are lots of the girls in his class.
We encourage a range of interests so we’ve always got something to talk about and do together. Fantasy films/books are our thing at the moment and he loves a musical!
He is so unbelievably loving too ❤️

If you assume you aren’t going to be close to a boy it’s likely to be a self fulfilling prophecy.

CalmLemonCrab · 04/09/2025 07:45

“Heartbroken” about having a boy? That’s offensive, pathetic and honestly quite disgusting. Relationships aren’t prescribed by gender - they’re built through love, effort and respect. Your daughter could just as easily grow up to hate you, resent you, move across the world, or cut contact, by the way.

What will actually drive your son away is the exact attitude you’re showing here. If he grows up feeling like you preferred his sister and saw him as some stereotype of “energetic and distant” because of his genitals, then yes, you’ll get the outcome you fear.

Be ashamed of yourself for projecting this nonsense onto your child before he’s even born. He deserves so much better.

ishimbob · 04/09/2025 07:47

HonorLulu · 04/09/2025 00:14

In my experience, parents who see a difference in raising boys and girls, and assume they’ll be closer to a daughter, end up with a self fulfilling prophecy of adult sons who aren’t close to them

What a curious life experience.

In my own experience, nearly every parent I know expected some differences in raising boys and girls, and plenty of mothers who expected to understand their daughters better and forge a closeness based on their shared femaleness, that may or may not have come to pass. There are countless books dedicated to the subject. I don't know one who then suffered a 'self fulfilling prophecy' of absent closeness with their sons, never mind because of their thoughts or expectations during pregnancy.

I'm one of several sisters, all my cousins are female, my father died when I was a child, I had no male influence in my life at all. For that reason, I was worried that I wouldn't be a good 'boy mom.'

At least, until l had my beloved DS, then I just worried about being a 'good mom.'

This is exactly what happened with my MIL.

She always assumed she would be closer to her DD than her sons and she made that happen with her actions.

She did this in countless ways - but most of all by moving thousands of miles to live near her DD, now refuses to ever travel to see her sons, has never spent a Christmas apart from her DD, babysits for her DD's children etc etc. She puts ridiculous amounts more energy into her DD than her sons and always has.

One Christmas when we all travelled to her, she handed out her presents - you'll think I am making this up, but I'm not: her DD got three thoughtfully chosen gifts, each of her sons were given a kallax storage box "because they are always useful"

She declares now "see, I was right, DDs are always closer to their mums" and it doesn't seem to occur to her that she made this so.

Chiefangel · 04/09/2025 07:51

You are heartbroken? Really? Be grateful you can conceive and can carry a child to full term. Boy or girl, they are a gift.

ChessorBuckaroo · 04/09/2025 07:55

CalmLemonCrab · 04/09/2025 07:45

“Heartbroken” about having a boy? That’s offensive, pathetic and honestly quite disgusting. Relationships aren’t prescribed by gender - they’re built through love, effort and respect. Your daughter could just as easily grow up to hate you, resent you, move across the world, or cut contact, by the way.

What will actually drive your son away is the exact attitude you’re showing here. If he grows up feeling like you preferred his sister and saw him as some stereotype of “energetic and distant” because of his genitals, then yes, you’ll get the outcome you fear.

Be ashamed of yourself for projecting this nonsense onto your child before he’s even born. He deserves so much better.

Conditional love based on sex is disgusting.

The good news is almost 90% say she's disgusting.

That does mean though that 10% of this site, made up of predominantly English women, hold similar coldness towards their child depending on their sex.

It's just so alien to me as an Irish person.

I'd like to see any woman that does hold such views to consider giving their child up for adoption to a warmer person who doesn't hold such a view. That child will be damaged otherwise.

Thiswaythatwayforwardandbackway · 04/09/2025 08:13

You are having a child to raise them to be self sufficient, capable human beings not so you have a lifelong companion when you're older.

Anabla · 04/09/2025 08:18

Lotsofpots · 03/09/2025 21:33

There is so much to unpick here. I come back to my earlier point “it’s not boys, it’s families”.

Of course I’m closer to my parents than my in laws, but I don’t treat them any differently. If I feel my MIL is overstepping when she does something that my own DM does, I reflect on myself rather than distancing her. And I chose to marry someone who loved his parents and actively involves them in his/our life - I can’t imagine being with someone who didn’t have this relationship (assuming his parents weren’t toxic). It’s part of my value base.
And seeing my in laws love for our DC is just wonderful.

rather than assuming that your brother’s relationship with your DM is because of his sex, or his wife, maybe you should look at how your DM treats him compared to you and your sister, including when you were children. My anecdotal experience is that boys who are raised to anticipate closeness, who are involved with both sides of grandparents, whose parents revel in being in their company, are less likely to marry someone who can easily distance them from a family they were previously close to.

You and your DP set the tone for your son as he grows up. Worth remembering when you think about how involved your MIL is compared to your own DM, and the standards you hold your DH to in his relationships with his family.

Absolutely this. I just don't identify or see this thing of boys never speaking to their parents. Both my husband and his brother are incredibly close to their parents and subsequently me and my SIL are also close to them and the six of us and our children are all very close as a unit and have a group chat we post in daily. We've been on trips and weekends away with them and I'll happily take my kids to see my in laws without my husband there as I have a wonderful relationship with them.

Even my cousins who are male and have kids are just as close to their parents as their sisters. Likewise my male friends. I'm not the slightest bit worried my children won't be close to me when they are older just because they are boys. Why on earth would I be?

Close family relationships have nothing to do with gender.

ishimbob · 04/09/2025 08:23

rather than assuming that your brother’s relationship with your DM is because of his sex, or his wife, maybe you should look at how your DM treats him compared to you and your sister, including when you were children. My anecdotal experience is that boys who are raised to anticipate closeness, who are involved with both sides of grandparents, whose parents revel in being in their company, are less likely to marry someone who can easily distance them from a family they were previously close to.

I think this is spot on and I do think the OP needs to think carefully about whether she will end up replaying this family dynamic of investing more in her DD than her DS.

mumofoneAloneandwell · 04/09/2025 08:47

Flor457 · 03/09/2025 23:51

@mumofoneAloneandwell didnt mean to reply to your post specifically. Sorry.

That's okay, happens xx

LJGFD · 04/09/2025 08:54

Having boys has been the biggest blessing of my life. To typecast what your adult relationship might be like based on their gender is absolute madness to me.

I will raise my boys to be good, decent humans who value their parents and will choose a husband or wife with good family values. I will have an open door to my future DILs/SILs, I will support, I won’t judge and I won’t demand/overstep. I will just be a good friend to them, I hope.

As a DIL, I honestly treat both sets of grandparents the same - I make a point of it. I bombard them all with the same photos and little updates and stories, I include them in everything etc. What I’m doing now will set the tone for what my sons know and expect when they build their own families - both sides will have equal involvement.

Enjoy your children for who they are, life is too short to obsess about 20-30 years down the line.

CremeBruhlee · 04/09/2025 08:55

YankSplaining · 04/09/2025 04:19

Controversial opinion, it seems, but no, you’re not being unreasonable. How many people here can say they know grown men who enjoy going out for mother-son days, just them and their mothers? And matrilineal advantage/“maternal grandparent advantage” is a real (though not universal) phenomenon that’s been studied by researchers.

I don’t think little boys are necessarily more energetic than little girls, but they don’t mature as quickly as little girls. So on average, an energetic little girl is going to be better than an energetic little boy of the same age at listening to adults and realizing when it’s time to settle down and pay attention.

I’m sure your baby will be a lovely little boy, but I don’t blame you for worrying that your odds of staying close to him throughout his life are lower than your odds of staying close to your daughter.

Yes my husband and his mum. Days and meals out and trips to cinema and she comes on half of our family holidays. She is a widow but we also went on holiday with his mum and dad and visited often (several times a week). I am close to my family too and we spend time together. This isn’t a boy problem it’s a lazy person problem or bringing children up to enjoy spending time with people and building strong family relationships. We also go to restaurants once a quarter with my auntie and uncle who we enjoy the company of as 2 couples (us and them) as well as relatives.

fateisdestined2025 · 04/09/2025 08:58

Don’t compare other people having sons to what your experience will be like. You don’t always get a clear picture. I’ve seen lots of cases where the sons normally worship their mothers even after marriage. Your experience will be what you make of it. Trust yourself.

irregularegular · 04/09/2025 09:04

You can't help the way you feel, so I am not going to have a go at you.

I have a 23 year old daughter and 21 year old son. I have a much closer, relaxed, more comfortable relationship with my son than with my daughter and I always have done. She has always been prickly and tricky whereas he has always been warm, affectionate, kind and easy going. It is true that my daughter and I have slightly more interests in common eg we go on city breaks together, which is not really my son's thing (though they usually end up a bit stressful at some point!). I hate admitting that I enjoy one child's company more than the others, but I do, and it is my son.

BatchCookBabe · 04/09/2025 09:08

irregularegular · 04/09/2025 09:04

You can't help the way you feel, so I am not going to have a go at you.

I have a 23 year old daughter and 21 year old son. I have a much closer, relaxed, more comfortable relationship with my son than with my daughter and I always have done. She has always been prickly and tricky whereas he has always been warm, affectionate, kind and easy going. It is true that my daughter and I have slightly more interests in common eg we go on city breaks together, which is not really my son's thing (though they usually end up a bit stressful at some point!). I hate admitting that I enjoy one child's company more than the others, but I do, and it is my son.

Maybe, just MAYBE, your daughter is picking up that you prefer her brother? You're not saying as much exactly, but it's pretty obvious, reading between the lines.... Children do pick up on things....

BatchCookBabe · 04/09/2025 09:12

fateisdestined2025 · 04/09/2025 08:58

Don’t compare other people having sons to what your experience will be like. You don’t always get a clear picture. I’ve seen lots of cases where the sons normally worship their mothers even after marriage. Your experience will be what you make of it. Trust yourself.

Do boys/men actually 'worship their mothers?' Or are they made to feel like they have to pretend they do, (even if they don't!) by the over-zealous and needy mother who actually worships her son? And God help the daughter-in-law!