@Agix
"Just eat less. If the weight doesn't come off, you're eating too much."
The absolute failure to understand the experience of being overweight and struggling to lose it.. Where do you start? 😞
I saw a doctor's post about a study on a new weight loss drug - Retatrutide - that's just going through a phase 3 clinical trial.
The control groups were the existing weight loss drugs + diet and exercise support, and a control group that had intensive diet and exercise support.
The group in the trial who had support with diet and exercise lost 4 kilos on average throughout the 12 weeks of the trial, which is pretty good. But the medication group lost many times that amount, with the Retatrutide group losing about 5 times as much as the support for lifestyle changes alone group.
By intensive support with lifestyle changes I mean they had 3 contacts with health professionals a week, a personal diet and exercise programme, and supervised exercise. That's about the standard of the most expensive and comprehensive weight loss programmes currently available on the NHS in the UK.
My DH signed up for one of these programmes earlier this year through his GP. 3 exercise classes a week. He had 1 to 1 and small group coaching and was encouraged to stop eating sugar and refined carbohydrates, which he did. He lost a few lbs and enjoyed the classes, but hasn't kept up the exercise habit since finishing - he's just so busy with his job and his elderly mum is so poorly. While he was doing that I took Mounjaro. I lost 50lbs, massively increased both my exercise capacity and my exercise habit, because it's now not painful or exhausting to to it.
I think the point I'm making is that people who've never experienced repeated failure to achieve or maintain significant weight loss really don't understand what the issues are. And actually those who've managed to achieve it who're now going around saying 'if I can do it, so can anyone' are in some ways worse, because they don't understand that we're not all made the same, and weight loss is vastly harder for some overweight people than others.