Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriends brother and family haven’t visited 3 1/2 month new baby AIBU

47 replies

AIBUmum2 · 10/07/2025 12:44

Hi everyone,
I just don’t know if I’m being unreasonable or not.

So basically my boyfriend’s brother and his girlfriend had a baby girl in March and I myself was due with my daughter at the end of the same month. They had their little girl on the 1st March and due to me and my partner being ill, we didn’t visit their little girl for two weeks. We travelled 24 miles with a newly potty trained girl to visit baby with a gift (outfit and little bits for baby that always come in handy for colic etc having been a mum already). Bear in mind I was heavily pregnant and due to have my baby within two weeks and also visited again a week before my due date and seen baby all excited knowing our babies would be so close in age in which they were too.
So I had my little girl on the 1st April after having complications was put to sleep minutes after c section was performed, so not exactly the best experience or recovery. So we get home everyone comes to visit in my family, boyfriends mum visits baby and his brother calls in to see baby for no more than 5-10 minutes and gets off after 3 weeks and then bids on a bike on eBay nearer to us and the boyfriend picks it up and he calls in again the week after and sees baby again for 5-10 minutes. So yeah he’s seen baby baring in mind I said ‘you need to bring the girlfriend and baby to meet baby’ to which he said I will.
So my baby is now a month old…they move house and again the brothers girlfriend is ordering off eBay (several things mirrors etc) nearer to us and my partner pays for it cash and drops it off at their house 24 miles away after being asked due to van etc. (baring in mind my partner has been going to see their baby and helping with the house move whilst I’m at home with new baby). The girlfriend is posting on days out walking, pub garden and his brother is painting his house and bleaching house (ocd) but still they haven’t been down to see my new baby.
I then receive a text asking me to save the date for their little girls christening, to which he has been told several times off my partner that I am taking it personal that they haven’t brought the girlfriend and baby to meet our baby. I message him to say I feel like I’ve done something wrong and he says no we are coming down they have just been busy but I had to be there as he wants us to be godparents! so I waited in but they didn’t turn up.

my baby turned three months and I said to my partner I can’t be godparent to their baby if they can’t be bothered to come and meet my baby, it’s a respect sort of thing. I don’t want a present just want to feel like my new baby matters.

My daughter is now 3 1/2 months old and they still haven’t been down so I have told my partner I won’t be attending the christening as they can’t respect me to come and see my baby like I did when it’s their baby.

Me and my partner have since been arguing and I have removed his brother and girlfriend from social media as their excuses are they have been busy (despite knowing that I know they have been going on days out etc so have to get in a car to go to them places but can’t come and visit) I have declined to be godparent. My partner is now saying what they have done isn’t disrespectful and me declining to be godparent is disrespectful more to them!?

AIBU for declining to be godparent???
AIBU for being upset/hurt for them not visiting my new baby and reciprocating the respect and happiness I showed him, his girlfriend and their new baby???
Am I being disrespectful by declining to be their daughter’s godparent? Or are they being disrespectful to me?

Also, my partner is still attending the christening to be godfather to his niece which I am fine with but is him going to stand up doing this showing them that I am in the wrong? He has said to me that I am wrong but no one else would think what they have done is bad and I am over reacting completely. But have I overreacted?

I feel like my feelings are just irrelevant and my partner isn’t really standing up for me or our new daughter and is pretty much taking their side.

Would just want to know if I am being crazy as a new mum or would other new mums also feel the same?

Thanks

OP posts:
clearglassclearmind · 10/07/2025 14:11

YABU

She's a first time mum, maybe deep in the baby blues/PND/PNA stage. You're an older, second time mum who's honestly just added fuel to the fire by cutting them both off on social media. You've probably just ruined what could have been a very easily sorted issue

Is it rude to just not bother visiting a new baby? Maybe, but you have no idea if there's a valid reason behind it

What a drama.

Mrsttcno1 · 10/07/2025 14:13

YABU and you need to get a grip, honestly.

Every first time mum feels differently for a start. I was very grateful to not struggle with my mental health postpartum but I have friends who for months after their baby was born really only wanted to see their husband/immediate family that are their safe space. I suppose when I think back I was a bit like that even though I didn’t suffer with PPD, I was overwhelmed, adjusting to being a new mum, I just wanted to be where I felt most comfortable with my little family.

You’re being a drama queen. Give the woman a bloody break.

Lmnop22 · 10/07/2025 14:33

You’re the one ruining the relationship!

It must be incredibly awkward for your BIL and his girlfriend to be told by your partner that you’ve taken offence to not having been visited in the first month. And that probably makes them not overly keen to visit because they already think they’ve offended you!

Now you’ve refused their christening invitation, refused to be godparent to their daughter yet you still expect them to visit you?

And at no point have you mentioned actually inviting them to anything specific so you expect them to invite you and your daughter to something? Or just knock on randomly and hope you’re not breastfeeding or sleeping or out?

Utterly bizarre. I had a baby a few months apart from my best friend and deliberately didn’t ask to see her for the first few weeks so she could enjoy her baby in her bubble. Then if I wanted to get together with the babies, I would text her and say “which days are you free for lunch next week?” not want an invite from her and get angry and block her when she didn’t send one….!

MayaPinion · 10/07/2025 14:37

You know, you could have just picked up the phone and called for a chat instead of writing out all that nonsense. People don’t really care about other people’s babies. It’s a baby, not a rocket surgeon.

Snorlaxo · 10/07/2025 15:09

How many times have you seen their baby since yours was born ?

If you don’t want to visit each other’s house then have you (or your h) suggested a meet up in a neutral location to break the deadlock?

If you don’t want to see SIL then have you suggested that h takes the baby (and your older child) to his brother’s house so the babies can be together?

Yanbu to decline being a godmother when you don’t see the baby and don’t like the parents. Also Yanbu to not prevent your h being godfather. I know that some people do christenings for school entry or as an excuse to party but if I was a godmother then I would take it more seriously than that. I don’t think it’s disrespectful unless how your declined was the problem.

I wouldn’t argue that it was disrespectful but I’d say it was bad manners that SIL didn’t do the first meeting thing that you did. Not sure why 24 miles and the newly potty trained older child mattered though? Are you sure that SIL is ok ? It’s good that BIL visited but are you sure that there’s no PND or similar ?

As for the holiday comment - the children playing with their cousins on holiday sound like a lovely fantasy. Did you read into this and assume it meant that SIL wanted to see your child regularly and be close? Maybe she imagined meeting up 4 times a year (Christmas, birthdays and holiday)? She won’t be the first mum to have an unrealistic vision for the future. As an example, my kids weren’t going to be fussy eaters but what did I know? 😂

Let go of the fact that she’s not interested in your child. It sounds like it’s not personal and she would be the same with any other niece or nephew. Stop hoping for a visit or following news about their eBay purchases. If this info comes from your h then tell him to stop telling you. You can’t be angry about what you don’t know.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 10/07/2025 16:22

The poor woman has just given birth. First baby is much harder than second. You should be reaching out to offer help or advice rather than causing trouble.

FiestaParty · 10/07/2025 16:31

ShallIstart · 10/07/2025 13:56

Well they have moved house with a new baby. Different people cope differently. I would give it some time. No need to blow up the family for this just yet.

Yes, they sound as if they have a lot going on. And the baby's uncle has seen the baby several times. No lack of 'respect' is involved. Have you forgotten what it was like being a first time mother? Maybe she's not coping. Maybe she's just holding it together and staying at home a lot. Maybe she has no headspace for anyone else's babies.

It's not a big deal, surely?

CurbsideProphet · 10/07/2025 17:51

At this stage it would be best to send a message "I'm so sorry with sleep deprivation and hormones I'm a bit all over the place. I really would love to see you all at the christening". And stop causing a big fall out.

You don't know what's going on with them. Not everyone gives birth and feels physically and mentally able to resume normal life in a few weeks.

Anxioustealady · 10/07/2025 18:49

I wouldn't want to get in the car with a baby to drive 24 miles. Maybe she's having a tough time with birth injuries, feeding, a tricky baby... I feel bad for her you're creating drama and deleting her on social media when she's a young new mom who's not done anything to you.

Bumblingbee101 · 10/07/2025 18:56

I personally feel like this has been taken majorly out of proportion @AIBUmum2 . You have 2 children and while fixating on your SIL if you want to call her that maybe focus on your recovery ans your little people as clearly the age differences is making a difference but also she is a first time mum and they've moved house. She also might be feeling extremely anxious as often socialmedia is a cover. Both stressful events. I think being asked to be a godparent is lovely and they clearly think a lot of you to ask you. I would reconsider. Your feelings are valid but have you actually spoken to her? As it doesn't sound like you've spoken to her? You also don't know what's going on for her atm, she might be worried you will judge her and sadly from what you've written perhaps that's is true? Your also nearly 10 years older.. deleting off social media maybe wasn't that helpful. I would make a call before there is a big falling out like a previous poster said as there may be no coming back from it and your partner will put the blame with you as you created it. It's his family too.

BebeBelle · 10/07/2025 19:59

@AIBUmum2 I don’t think you are being unreasonable. I think you are just a sensitive and caring person. You went out to see their baby when you should have been relaxing and were very respectful and celebrated their moment of joy with them. I really think that they should have made an effort with you too. 3.5 months is a long time for ‘family’ not to see your baby. Your sister in law should have done better but she maybe doesn’t know any better. Not sure if the christening has already happened but do all you can to be by your partner’s side cause you don’t want this issue becoming a thing between the two of you down the line since the rest of his family will be there. Just play nice but know that you can’t fully trust your sister in law. Your kids are going to be little cousins and you will always be in each other’s lives but don’t let her make you to be the horrible person to the rest of your partner’s family. You don’t have to be best friends with sister in law but just keep smiling around her and try and move on from her. Sounds like your husbands are quite close so for the sake of your relationship and you little family do what you can to maintain peace. I completely agree that your sister in law has been very disrespectful but people like that will tell everyone that you refused support them and not share that they were never there for you. Why is she getting a lot of eBay stuff from where you leave mostly? If you are in a better area than them - jealous is also dangerous and you need to play your cards close to your chest.
Congratulations on your baby 👶

NotEnoughRoom · 10/07/2025 20:10

Honestly, no one will ever be as interested in your baby as you are. And I’d say that to any parent (including myself).

so yes, it’s understandable that you feel upset they don’t seem to be interested/making an effort, but honestly, your baby will have no idea, and you getting all worked up about it isn’t doing anyone any good.

we all have ideas about what life will
be like once baby arrives. You say to your best mate/sister/cousin who is also pregnant - oh we’ll bring them up together, they’ll be so close, it’ll be lovely - and then the reality of sleepless nights and shitty nappies hits and plans go out the window.

just chill out, stop getting offended over everything, and focus on your own family. Once things calm down, and babies are a bit older, you might find you do end up spending more time together , but it’s not going to happen if you try to force it now!

Spidey66 · 11/07/2025 10:06

Why don't you take your kids and visit her, if you're that upset?

AIBUmum2 · 14/07/2025 16:39

Thank you for all your responses.

To answer some of the points some of you have made.

Yes I have specifically asked for them to visit and expressed that I can’t wait for my SIL (auntie x) and baby to meet my baby. Was asked if a Sunday is okay. I specifically said of course I will be in 100% but they didn’t turn up. No message to say baby isn’t too good or something has come up. My toddler is obsessed with her uncle and new baby and waited at the window with every car that came down the street. But was a no show.

I have messaged SIL before asking how her and baby are, which have all been read and no responses received but I understand people forget to reply so didn’t think much of it and just checked in with the BIL when on the phone to the OH. The BIL said she is good and I did say if she needs anything to give me a ring or text. I’m always happy to help.

Yes I understand they moved house and always said once your all settled, and I’m on my feet properly you can come and visit baby and was always told yeah we will. They have been fully settled but every invitation got brushed off with a ‘yeah we will’.

For whoever it was who remarked I’ve been a first time mum before and two is easier than one! Maybe it was easy for you….but in my eyes two is most certainly not a breeze and is much harder than one baby! Just because you found it easier doesn’t mean I have. The remark is like telling a new mum to sleep when baby sleeps…this is impossible unless you don’t need to make bottles or wash the soiled baby vests and baby grows! Sometimes you get them to sleep and is all you want to do is cry because you’ve been up every 3 hours or now at 4 months every five hours! I had a c section, was put to sleep for 6 hours after due to severe complications (which is still don’t know what happened but waiting for my debrief) was unable to pick anything up for 8 weeks that wasn’t my baby. Unable to walk up right for around 8 weeks. And within these 8 weeks my OH was helping the BIL and SIL move house. Which is fine they needed the help and I had my sister and mum step in and helping me with the house, baby, toddler and hospital visits etc.

The SIL and myself were really excited to the girls being born throughout the pregnancy. We messaged throughout and I was expecting her to share her joy in my girl being born as I did with her. (I have nieces that are born within months who are really close from being born and only wanted this for our girls, there is nothing wrong with that and with how the SIL was throughout the pregnancy and when I visited, I thought it would happen).

In regards to the social media, both BIL & SIL posting days out since moved home which they have drove to get to. I only thought they would have made the effort to share joy of a new baby. I have removed them from my social media because everything I was seeing upset me. I am a new mum too and since removing them I don’t have to see the lies and no longer will upset me.

I am sensitive and from what most of you have said ‘taken it personally’ but think of how you would feel if you made an effort to see your OH baby niece and your BIL & SIL didn’t make/show the same effort for you 14 weeks after you have your baby (18 weeks after they had their baby). I wasn’t expecting them to fly down as I knew they had a move and new baby but once they had all settled, I invited them. Yes the BIL called in for 5 minutes twice, first time because he was in the area and second to pick up a bike that my OH picked up for him from around our area, yeah he has done the right thing and said he would bring his baby and OH to meet her. But this still hasn’t happened.

In regards to the christening, they are not religious at all so believe this is for other reasons. I have declined god mother duties as I haven’t seen or heard from the SIL since a two weeks before I had my baby baring in mind I have messaged and not had any response…I have also not seen my OHs niece since a week before I had my baby… so don’t believe i can be the godmother to a child I will not know. And before you all say but it’s your fault…no it isn’t my fault, the relationship could have been strong but it has to work both ways. I am more than happy to travel 24 miles and make the effort but when that effort can’t be reciprocated it shouldn’t be for me to do the travelling with two kids because I have a new baby too. I have a little girl who throws up every time we have travelled there but it’s something we have to put up with and have done.

@BebeBelle Thank you. The christening hasn’t been yet but I’m going to sit this one out still. My OH is fine with going by himself and won’t be attending the after party (piss up most likely) as he doesn’t drink and wants to come home to his family. My OH understands why I am upset and he has seen the lies of how ‘busy’ they was after the move but just says it will be their loss down the line. He is equally annoyed but more at his brother for not making an effort considering everything he has done from the minute his SIL went into labour. (He’s helped his brother with money when he was in the hospital having baby for bills as his brother is self employed, helped him move, picked up his SILs orders that were purchased near us which he paid in cash, took them up to their new house in his van, then his brother was stressing over bills with losing money with moving house so helped him with money again which within days of giving him money for bills his brother then said they was having the christening so my OH thinks he’s pretty much paid for the christening instead of bills rent etc)
I have no idea why the SIL was bidding/buying mirrors, side units from near us when they don’t have a van to collect but then was asking the OH to pay cash and when he took it to the new house, she stays upstairs with the baby but then within this time she’s posting story work out pictures, didn’t thank him for spending hours going getting them and taking them to them or anything.
The OH is genuinely flabbergasted with everything to he’s done for them both and how his SIL has been since.
I don’t live in a nicer area so it is rather weird as I wouldn’t buy something from somewhere miles away without asking before hand if that person can do me a favour, I wouldn’t just assume it’s a yeah when that person has a new baby too so is just as busy with work and family. I am not a judgmental person at all, I’m just quiet and very family orientated but my cards are to my chest and will just get on with my own family life now.
My girls have lots of older cousins and my own cousins kids around them so will not lose out or need anything.

I know my feelings are not unjustified, I feel how I feel…I just wanted to know if anyone else would feel the same way.

thanks again

OP posts:
CheerybleBrothers · 14/07/2025 16:54

Your feelings are totally unjustified, and you’re a self-centered drama queen who seems to thrive on low-level accusations of ‘disrespect’ and neglect. People asked you if you remembered how challenging being a first time mother was, and you turned it into a long whinge about how hard you had it with two. It’s not a big deal, OP. Your baby is still new. She’s not going to go past her sell-by date at 3.5 months. You all have plenty of time. If your DH isn’t happy to lend his brother money, or help him out, then surely he should stop, and not keep doing it while you both resent it?

And has it not occurred to you that asking you to be godmother was their way of saying they wanted you in their child’s life? You seem to view it as you doing them a big favour. And now you’ve refused, removed them from your SM and are refusing to attend the christening, while compiling a long list of grievances..if you want these people in your life, contact them.

(And travelling unnecessarily with a routinely car sick toddler is completely mad! Why would you do that?)

MangaMoo · 14/07/2025 16:55

AIBUmum2 · 14/07/2025 16:39

Thank you for all your responses.

To answer some of the points some of you have made.

Yes I have specifically asked for them to visit and expressed that I can’t wait for my SIL (auntie x) and baby to meet my baby. Was asked if a Sunday is okay. I specifically said of course I will be in 100% but they didn’t turn up. No message to say baby isn’t too good or something has come up. My toddler is obsessed with her uncle and new baby and waited at the window with every car that came down the street. But was a no show.

I have messaged SIL before asking how her and baby are, which have all been read and no responses received but I understand people forget to reply so didn’t think much of it and just checked in with the BIL when on the phone to the OH. The BIL said she is good and I did say if she needs anything to give me a ring or text. I’m always happy to help.

Yes I understand they moved house and always said once your all settled, and I’m on my feet properly you can come and visit baby and was always told yeah we will. They have been fully settled but every invitation got brushed off with a ‘yeah we will’.

For whoever it was who remarked I’ve been a first time mum before and two is easier than one! Maybe it was easy for you….but in my eyes two is most certainly not a breeze and is much harder than one baby! Just because you found it easier doesn’t mean I have. The remark is like telling a new mum to sleep when baby sleeps…this is impossible unless you don’t need to make bottles or wash the soiled baby vests and baby grows! Sometimes you get them to sleep and is all you want to do is cry because you’ve been up every 3 hours or now at 4 months every five hours! I had a c section, was put to sleep for 6 hours after due to severe complications (which is still don’t know what happened but waiting for my debrief) was unable to pick anything up for 8 weeks that wasn’t my baby. Unable to walk up right for around 8 weeks. And within these 8 weeks my OH was helping the BIL and SIL move house. Which is fine they needed the help and I had my sister and mum step in and helping me with the house, baby, toddler and hospital visits etc.

The SIL and myself were really excited to the girls being born throughout the pregnancy. We messaged throughout and I was expecting her to share her joy in my girl being born as I did with her. (I have nieces that are born within months who are really close from being born and only wanted this for our girls, there is nothing wrong with that and with how the SIL was throughout the pregnancy and when I visited, I thought it would happen).

In regards to the social media, both BIL & SIL posting days out since moved home which they have drove to get to. I only thought they would have made the effort to share joy of a new baby. I have removed them from my social media because everything I was seeing upset me. I am a new mum too and since removing them I don’t have to see the lies and no longer will upset me.

I am sensitive and from what most of you have said ‘taken it personally’ but think of how you would feel if you made an effort to see your OH baby niece and your BIL & SIL didn’t make/show the same effort for you 14 weeks after you have your baby (18 weeks after they had their baby). I wasn’t expecting them to fly down as I knew they had a move and new baby but once they had all settled, I invited them. Yes the BIL called in for 5 minutes twice, first time because he was in the area and second to pick up a bike that my OH picked up for him from around our area, yeah he has done the right thing and said he would bring his baby and OH to meet her. But this still hasn’t happened.

In regards to the christening, they are not religious at all so believe this is for other reasons. I have declined god mother duties as I haven’t seen or heard from the SIL since a two weeks before I had my baby baring in mind I have messaged and not had any response…I have also not seen my OHs niece since a week before I had my baby… so don’t believe i can be the godmother to a child I will not know. And before you all say but it’s your fault…no it isn’t my fault, the relationship could have been strong but it has to work both ways. I am more than happy to travel 24 miles and make the effort but when that effort can’t be reciprocated it shouldn’t be for me to do the travelling with two kids because I have a new baby too. I have a little girl who throws up every time we have travelled there but it’s something we have to put up with and have done.

@BebeBelle Thank you. The christening hasn’t been yet but I’m going to sit this one out still. My OH is fine with going by himself and won’t be attending the after party (piss up most likely) as he doesn’t drink and wants to come home to his family. My OH understands why I am upset and he has seen the lies of how ‘busy’ they was after the move but just says it will be their loss down the line. He is equally annoyed but more at his brother for not making an effort considering everything he has done from the minute his SIL went into labour. (He’s helped his brother with money when he was in the hospital having baby for bills as his brother is self employed, helped him move, picked up his SILs orders that were purchased near us which he paid in cash, took them up to their new house in his van, then his brother was stressing over bills with losing money with moving house so helped him with money again which within days of giving him money for bills his brother then said they was having the christening so my OH thinks he’s pretty much paid for the christening instead of bills rent etc)
I have no idea why the SIL was bidding/buying mirrors, side units from near us when they don’t have a van to collect but then was asking the OH to pay cash and when he took it to the new house, she stays upstairs with the baby but then within this time she’s posting story work out pictures, didn’t thank him for spending hours going getting them and taking them to them or anything.
The OH is genuinely flabbergasted with everything to he’s done for them both and how his SIL has been since.
I don’t live in a nicer area so it is rather weird as I wouldn’t buy something from somewhere miles away without asking before hand if that person can do me a favour, I wouldn’t just assume it’s a yeah when that person has a new baby too so is just as busy with work and family. I am not a judgmental person at all, I’m just quiet and very family orientated but my cards are to my chest and will just get on with my own family life now.
My girls have lots of older cousins and my own cousins kids around them so will not lose out or need anything.

I know my feelings are not unjustified, I feel how I feel…I just wanted to know if anyone else would feel the same way.

thanks again

Ok so in light of your update, I would revise a little of my earlier judgements and can see more fully why you have been offended by some things that have happened. I do think though that by declining the godparent role and deleting them off social media you have put a degree of permanency in to this fall out as some things are more difficult to move past. However, sometimes your own peace is more important and if a bit of distance brings you that and you’re happier that way then good luck to you. Sounds like your OH is supportive of your decisions now too which would be my main priority as you don’t want issues within your relationship because of outside influences- that happens far too often and really isn’t worth it in my book.

bellamorgan · 14/07/2025 17:11

Clearly somethings going on with why they haven’t visited.

However you have nuked the relationship even further with the removing from social media and snapping their olive branch.

And no matter how much work baby 2 may well add. Nothing compares going from 0 babies to 1 because you go in all unicorns and glitter and then reality slaps you in the face hard.

Baby three was my easiest they had no choice slot in. One is the shock to the system.

Remember those parent who won’t ever let their children watch tv or have an iPad and they will eat everything and not be fussy. No chocolate or mc don’t till they are teenagers, naive pre parent facts actual parents laugh at.

UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 14/07/2025 17:30

NicolaCasanova · 10/07/2025 14:05

YABVU. If you don’t want to be godparent, decline, but YABU to expect a first-time mother to do anything within the first few months of giving birth.

Who was put to sleep?

I think OP means she was given sleeping pills to get her to rest?

Not that anyone was "put to sleep" the way you do with animals 🤣

waterrat · 14/07/2025 17:33

this is all so incredibly immature. I think you are massively over reacting tbh.

she has a small baby and has moved house - cut her some slack. When you visited you didn't have a newborn in tow.

AIBUmum2 · 14/07/2025 19:08

UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 14/07/2025 17:30

I think OP means she was given sleeping pills to get her to rest?

Not that anyone was "put to sleep" the way you do with animals 🤣

No I was put to sleep via general anaesthetic not given pills to rest.

OP posts:
UsingAMansNameInAWomensWorld · 15/07/2025 12:24

AIBUmum2 · 14/07/2025 19:08

No I was put to sleep via general anaesthetic not given pills to rest.

You weren't "put to sleep" in the sense I, and I think PP, initially thought though

HoppingPavlova · 15/07/2025 15:16

No I was put to sleep via general anaesthetic

🤣🤣🤣OP, the term would be ‘put under’ if talking about a general. Being ‘put to sleep’ is what you do with an overdose of anaesthetic, most typically for animals for the purpose of end of life. You can do it with a person, but not legal most places.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread