Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the media being unprofessional re Air India crash?

153 replies

rhomb · 12/06/2025 19:58

The Air India crash has at one survivor (so far). Heard that the media are bombarding the relatives of this survivor. I find this unprofessional and harassing, especially when the survivor’s brother was on the same flight.

I wish the media will stop trying to get stories from anybody as sensational. It’s not.

Also no need for news specials with presenters asking questions to correspondents and experts who don’t know the answer as the info hasn’t been available etc. Then rephrase it. Again so unprofessional.

OP posts:
OneSillyEagle · 12/06/2025 23:04

unsevered67 · 12/06/2025 20:00

Just watching bbc and screaming at the reporter to stop harassing the relatives of the man who has survived. The reporting seems so voyeuristic

Exactly the same on ITV.

PondGhost · 12/06/2025 23:05

Ponoka7 · 12/06/2025 22:55

"Then she said she’d heard the survivor had jumped out of the plane? Which sounded mad, but DH says there’s speculation about it online?)"

That's what's being said, along with the survivor being a terrorist and that's how he's managed to live (I don't believe that). We don't know how the family feel about the press, because if the terrorist rumour takes hold, it puts them in danger. Getting the truth out, helps stop the conspiracies. Without the doecial coverage, the press would be accused of ignoring a massive disaster and tragedy, because the majority of the location/victims wasn't white.

Oh, God. That poor family. The poor young brother reeling with shock and the camera poking in the door at a cluster of shellshocked family, including their mum…

ThePigandPear · 12/06/2025 23:06

Perhaps mumsnetters ought to stop reading and sharing links from the mail.
I always avoid them, and it usually tells me that the user has no emotional intelligence.

Just stop associating with and reading trash.

Lauralou19 · 12/06/2025 23:07

Sky News were just awful interviewing the brother of the survivor, even though he had just lost his other brother hours earlier. Awful. He wouldn’t have been in the right state of mind to agree to an interview, totally taking advantage of a family member in complete and utter shock. The grieving Mum was insight of where they were filming 😩

Embarrassing journalism from Sophie Ridge too - asking an expert if the survivor could have jumped before the plane crashed. It’s something (understandably) a child might ask, but not an intelligent adult.

DreamTheMoors · 12/06/2025 23:07

Cattenberg · 12/06/2025 22:34

This article from earlier today was written in response to the recent school shooting in Austria, but the comments about journalistic ethics seem very relevant to this thread:

When it comes to reporting on mass killings, some in Europe take a different approach from Americans

In America, sadly, we have had many mass shootings. It’s horrifying and terrifying.
They get reported monthly, often only briefly.
Almost the same news on every major news outlet. I’m certain of that because I live in America and I watch and read them.
Nobody competes for attention on that shitty news. And we react as Austria has reacted.
If msn chooses to refer to that as sensationalism or whatever they said, instead of focusing on our nation’s abhorrent gun laws, that’s the freedom of the press, as it should be.

YouWillFindMeInTheGarden · 12/06/2025 23:08

some on this thread are just as bad! Reposting what they’ve seen and heard and moaning about it being said in the first place….the irony!

noworklifebalance · 12/06/2025 23:08

SummerEve · 12/06/2025 20:39

It’s grotesque, so much so my husband has complained to OFCOM this evening.

I tried to do this, but it said I had to put in a complaint with the BBC first. How did your husband manage it, because I would also like to file a complaint?

saltandvinegarchipsticks · 12/06/2025 23:08

I turned over to BBC to find out what had happened and I was so disgusted by the exploitative and ghoulish questioning of family members that I turned it straight off. Awful.

DrCoconut · 12/06/2025 23:10

It's horrible how the reporters are behaving. Totally inappropriate. And the comments online are next level awful too. A few years ago people would have been ashamed to say such things. The racists are now dangerously emboldened.

ButterCrackers · 12/06/2025 23:10

It was when the media were not believing there was a survivor, that’s when I switched off the radio. I thought he’s survived and needs to be spoken of respectfully.

BeardofHagrid · 12/06/2025 23:15

Media will be bored of the story in two days’s time, for others it will last a lifetime.

SummerEve · 12/06/2025 23:16

noworklifebalance · 12/06/2025 23:08

I tried to do this, but it said I had to put in a complaint with the BBC first. How did your husband manage it, because I would also like to file a complaint?

He complained about SKY and went directly onto the OFCOM website where he tells me there is a section named “make a complaint”. Sorry I can’t be of more help.

noworklifebalance · 12/06/2025 23:19

SummerEve · 12/06/2025 23:16

He complained about SKY and went directly onto the OFCOM website where he tells me there is a section named “make a complaint”. Sorry I can’t be of more help.

Thanks for your reply and no need to apologise. I have put in a complaint on bbc website

Naddd · 12/06/2025 23:22

The racism is not at all surprising to me as an Asian.
People are incredibly racist and don't even bother to hide it. It has become acceptable. We are all illegal, claiming benefits and council homes, that only they should be entitled to and at the same time stealing jobs they'd get if only they'd stop the boats.
I didn't even bother reading comments in the dm as I knew as soon as I saw pictures of those that died in the hijab it would fuel the racists.
All those of you considering voting for the likes of Reform, do so if you wish but KNOW you are voting for a party that IS racist and is more than happy to fuel the anti brown/Muslim /immigrant rhetoric to get in to power. And if you actually think they will do anything other than make things a heck of a lot worse you are delusional.
Not the point of the thread but the number of people shocked at the racism is surprising. Did some of you think when they were spouting there nonsense they had a bit of a point? And that we were "playing the race card" when we called it out?
Anyway yes the media are vultures. Everything they print should be taken with a large dose of salt (a grain is insufficient), they have no morals, ethics or empathy. The fact they still refer to themselves as journalists is ludicrous.

Holluschickie · 12/06/2025 23:24

Naddd · 12/06/2025 23:22

The racism is not at all surprising to me as an Asian.
People are incredibly racist and don't even bother to hide it. It has become acceptable. We are all illegal, claiming benefits and council homes, that only they should be entitled to and at the same time stealing jobs they'd get if only they'd stop the boats.
I didn't even bother reading comments in the dm as I knew as soon as I saw pictures of those that died in the hijab it would fuel the racists.
All those of you considering voting for the likes of Reform, do so if you wish but KNOW you are voting for a party that IS racist and is more than happy to fuel the anti brown/Muslim /immigrant rhetoric to get in to power. And if you actually think they will do anything other than make things a heck of a lot worse you are delusional.
Not the point of the thread but the number of people shocked at the racism is surprising. Did some of you think when they were spouting there nonsense they had a bit of a point? And that we were "playing the race card" when we called it out?
Anyway yes the media are vultures. Everything they print should be taken with a large dose of salt (a grain is insufficient), they have no morals, ethics or empathy. The fact they still refer to themselves as journalists is ludicrous.

Nor me.

Hkakge · 12/06/2025 23:25

Magicpaintbrush · 12/06/2025 22:06

The bbc homepage had a video of the plane going down. I mean, why? So people can gawp at the imminent death of all those people? So goulish. I think the bbc used to be better than this?? Now it's getting to be like Yahoo News (which is a pile of unprofessional shite). This tragedy seems to have brought out the worst side of humanity where the press are concerned, and we have to breathe the same oxygen as these horrible 'journalists'. No conscience, no integrity, just a bunch of roaches feeding off the grief and terror of others.

The Guardian also had that video of the plane going down with no warning as to what it was, indeed the video was labelled video of crash site. I clicked on it assuming it would show, well, the crash site but no it was the plane going down and 200 people meeting their deaths. Inexcusable to put that video up and with no warning as to the content. It was later changed

Moonlightexpress · 12/06/2025 23:26

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 12/06/2025 20:02

I've also seen some media outlets posting videos from 2 men who were posting from the airport before they got on the plane. Absolutely horrendous behaviour

Let me guess... the daily fail by any chance ?

crazeekat · 12/06/2025 23:31

Sky news asking the brother of the two brothers onboard, “how do u feel?” Exactly after he described how he feels……
well how the fk do u think this guy feels? How would YOU feel!!! 🤡
I despair at the world. Humanity is lost for storylines.

Foolsgold74 · 12/06/2025 23:37

joanofaardvark · 12/06/2025 21:43

I agree. I’ve just seen a BBC reporter (on their news channel) speaking to a relative who went to the crash site. He speaks in local language. She then translates to camera that he was trying to pull bodies out - and more graphic detail that I won’t type here.
There is no justification for that. Exploitative, disrespectful and no justification.
I switched over.

I saw that and was shocked that she chose to repeat that particular detail. She could have just skipped over it. Appalling.

DBD1975 · 12/06/2025 23:44

SummerEve · 12/06/2025 20:39

It’s grotesque, so much so my husband has complained to OFCOM this evening.

Totally shocked watching the BBC news tonight. The hounding of that poor family, repeatedly asking the cousin and brother how they feel, over and over again, it was shameful.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/06/2025 23:44

If you wonder why the country has issues and who the people voting Reform are in a lot of cases - reading the comments should bring you bang up to speed - and if you do vote that way ( and plenty of Tory’s have these views too) you might want to reassess your thoughts on the idea that most aren’t racist - just ‘concerned’. -

InterestedDad37 · 12/06/2025 23:50

HonestOpalHelper · 12/06/2025 21:42

Watching the BBC coverage vs Channel 4 was insightful - Channel 4 went with concise reporting served up for adults. No wild speculation, just factual reporting.

Meanwhile the BBC Verify Team (as it is they) had compared aerial photographs of the uni halls with street shots to confirm what everyone else knew, that it landed on the uni halls - they had also verified that a bit of footage had been filmed from the airport, because er, it had been filmed from the airport. They then got a myriad of retired pilots who presumably had never flown this new model to postulate about how it crashed which may have been accurate or totally wrong - no one knows.

So on top of a huge human tragedy we learn yet again that BBC news is the televisual equivalent of the Daily Star (With apologies to the Daily Star)

Edited

Yes, BBC Verify is sometimes an excellent idea, particularly when false accounts are given by dodgy governments, for example. But if we know it took off from that airport and crashed onto that building, you don't need to waste time and resources 'proving' what we know to be true. And the bits about 'how we verified it' are not as interesting as they think. Like the last 10 minutes of 'how we made this nature programme' 😀 That last comment might prove controversial 🤔🙂

MyNeedyLilacBird · 12/06/2025 23:53

Absolutely disgraceful and shouldn't be allowed. That BBC journalist should be ashamed of himself for how he behaved

LadyGAgain · 12/06/2025 23:58

Thank you. Complaint raised.