I was pondering on this further today.
I’ve obviously not seen the clip but I guess the humour in using the Nazi salute is manifold.
Firstly, it’s the idea of making the Nazis a caricature, as has been done in countless comedies before. The idea that they’re taking part in a dancing show (which was the subject being discussed) makes them look silly.
And then there’s the humour in suggesting that a perfectly lovely person would break out into a spontaneous Nazi salute. It’s the suggestion of the ridiculous that makes it funny, plus of course the shock value. Pretty much the same for the wanking/sexual gesture. It’s the fact that it would be insanely out of character and out of place in a dancing show that provides humorous context.
I’m not saying I would find it funny. I’ve not seen the clip so I don’t know. I said earlier that I don’t really like David Walliams so probably not. Wouldn’t rule it out though.
I just don’t think using a Nazi salute within a humorous context is unacceptable. It might not be suitable for a mainstream BBC show and that’s understandable. But I can see it has a place as edgy humour and I would always defend that, even if it’s not something I find funny myself.
What is unacceptable is Elon Musk bashing out a Nazi salute-type gesture to whip up support from voters on the political right.
A comedian mocking Nazis and making inappropriate suggestions in the name of humour, I can’t get worked up about.