Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am completely fucked if PIP changes happen?

1000 replies

PIPsqueakybum · 31/03/2025 23:40

I get standard rate PIP due to having CFS. I’ve had CFS for 10 years and at the moment I’m going through one of my ‘better’ phases, during the bad phases, which can last weeks or months, I am virtually bed bound, and although I manage my condition as much as possible through pacing, stress is a big factor in making it worse so one majorly stressful event and I’ll be back to square one. I am self employed and manage at the moment maybe 10 hours of work a week, which is better than no hours which is where I was for many years. This is in part due to finally winning my battle for PIP and being able to afford therapies which have helped me have at least some kind of a life.

To give you an idea of an average day (bearing in mind this is as good as my health gets), here’s what I did today:

7.30am woke up as usual feeling completely unrested, aching and like I’d been hit by a truck.

8.30am drove teenage DD to school. Already felt completely exhausted and had to stop at a garage on the way home for a rest and to buy a can of coke to try and wake myself up enough to drive home.

9.30am got home and got back into bed to rest, as I had a meeting at 1.30pm and I felt too tired to manage a conversation. Fell asleep for a couple of hours.

12.30pm got up, had a pot noodle for breakfast/lunch, as I didn’t have the energy to make anything else.

1.30pm met up with potential client, which went well and I have some work as a result of it, but was left completely wiped out by having to be ‘on’ for an hour.

2.30pm got back home, tried to do some jobs around the house but was too tired and went back to bed to rest and then slept for another hour.

6pm got up and put a pizza in the oven for tea.

7pm - now, rested in bed, aching all over and watched TV/zoned out for the evening.

This is a typical day, and I repeat this is as good as things get for me. The fact that I was able to get DD to school and go to a meeting is a HUGE improvement on where I was for years, but CFS is a fluctuating condition and I could very easily be back to being completely useless.

If the proposed PIP changes happen, I will lose my PIP, and ergo also lose the LCWRA element of UC. It was a long battle to get PIP and I don’t have any more than 2 points in any descriptor. I will then be on the basic rate of UC, and my self employment will not be seen as gainful so I will be expected to job search for 40 hours per week, and will be sanctioned and lose further money when I can’t do this. I honestly can’t do any more than I’m doing, and even what I am doing now is a struggle. I’m doomed aren’t I?

OP posts:
Nothinglikeagoodbook · 01/04/2025 09:53

verysmellyjelly · 01/04/2025 09:39

You sound like the people who attack low income parents for not cooking from scratch because it’s so easy and affordable…

And you sound like someone who is avoiding answering the specific points that have been made.

I'm sorry life is so difficult for you, but the posters on here are talking about what would be possible for the OP, not you. Microwaving a potato takes about 4 minutes, heating an individual pot of beans one minute, opening a bag if grated cheese ten seconds. There’s nothing to suggest the OP can’t stay out of bed for six minutes. And if she has the mental acuity to drive (even with hand controls) she can do stuff like work out how to microwave two things.

Breezybetty · 01/04/2025 09:53

Pistachioitaliano · 01/04/2025 09:45

You have a husband, doesn't he pay the bills? In sickness and health vows. Must be more challenging to those who are alone.

I think benefits should be reserved for those with no other options. Plenty of people live off one salary. The thought of downsizing to be able to live off one salary, or moving back in with parents who may well be able to help doesn’t seem to occur to people. It seems to be the government’s responsibility to ensure you have exactly the same life as you had without the disability. Like you shouldn’t look to the resources you have available to you first and any sort of hardship is intolerable. Disabilities should be financially compensated for by the state.

It’s a big change from the attitudes of the past and I think goes a long way to explaining why our public finances are like they are.

verysmellyjelly · 01/04/2025 09:55

Nothinglikeagoodbook · 01/04/2025 09:53

And you sound like someone who is avoiding answering the specific points that have been made.

I'm sorry life is so difficult for you, but the posters on here are talking about what would be possible for the OP, not you. Microwaving a potato takes about 4 minutes, heating an individual pot of beans one minute, opening a bag if grated cheese ten seconds. There’s nothing to suggest the OP can’t stay out of bed for six minutes. And if she has the mental acuity to drive (even with hand controls) she can do stuff like work out how to microwave two things.

Edited

I’ve answered dozens of specific points and received the exact same dismissive replies every time. Feel free to reread the thread if you missed it,

Wanderergirl · 01/04/2025 09:56

PIPsqueakybum · 31/03/2025 23:40

I get standard rate PIP due to having CFS. I’ve had CFS for 10 years and at the moment I’m going through one of my ‘better’ phases, during the bad phases, which can last weeks or months, I am virtually bed bound, and although I manage my condition as much as possible through pacing, stress is a big factor in making it worse so one majorly stressful event and I’ll be back to square one. I am self employed and manage at the moment maybe 10 hours of work a week, which is better than no hours which is where I was for many years. This is in part due to finally winning my battle for PIP and being able to afford therapies which have helped me have at least some kind of a life.

To give you an idea of an average day (bearing in mind this is as good as my health gets), here’s what I did today:

7.30am woke up as usual feeling completely unrested, aching and like I’d been hit by a truck.

8.30am drove teenage DD to school. Already felt completely exhausted and had to stop at a garage on the way home for a rest and to buy a can of coke to try and wake myself up enough to drive home.

9.30am got home and got back into bed to rest, as I had a meeting at 1.30pm and I felt too tired to manage a conversation. Fell asleep for a couple of hours.

12.30pm got up, had a pot noodle for breakfast/lunch, as I didn’t have the energy to make anything else.

1.30pm met up with potential client, which went well and I have some work as a result of it, but was left completely wiped out by having to be ‘on’ for an hour.

2.30pm got back home, tried to do some jobs around the house but was too tired and went back to bed to rest and then slept for another hour.

6pm got up and put a pizza in the oven for tea.

7pm - now, rested in bed, aching all over and watched TV/zoned out for the evening.

This is a typical day, and I repeat this is as good as things get for me. The fact that I was able to get DD to school and go to a meeting is a HUGE improvement on where I was for years, but CFS is a fluctuating condition and I could very easily be back to being completely useless.

If the proposed PIP changes happen, I will lose my PIP, and ergo also lose the LCWRA element of UC. It was a long battle to get PIP and I don’t have any more than 2 points in any descriptor. I will then be on the basic rate of UC, and my self employment will not be seen as gainful so I will be expected to job search for 40 hours per week, and will be sanctioned and lose further money when I can’t do this. I honestly can’t do any more than I’m doing, and even what I am doing now is a struggle. I’m doomed aren’t I?

I might be stating the obvious, but have you ever considered therapy? My friend managed to reach remission and her life back on this condition by sorting out her past traumas.

Pistachioitaliano · 01/04/2025 09:56

bestcatlife · 01/04/2025 09:48

@Pistachioitaliano The other option is to move abroad to a country you feel would be more suited to you.
I'd love to but the government took away my right to freedom of movement

Plenty of people move abroad. I know people who have moved recently. Also numerous threads on it.

There have been numerous suggestions but none seem to be acceptable. The only thing that people seem to expect is the government to throw money at them. That is no longer going to happen, people will need to rely on family / adapt. Being in denial is certainly not the answer, if anything makes the adjustment harder.

PandoraSox · 01/04/2025 09:56

Hoggyhoghog · 01/04/2025 09:41

Another quick fix anyone who is able, safe and well enough to drive should be reassessed as priority because unless you are severely disabled I can’t see many scoring a 4 and being able to safely manage driving a car.

Edited

My DH needs help with personal care, dressing, needs help to prepare meals etc. and uses a wheelchair. But he can drive. It is something he really enjoys too, and is good at. Should he lose his PIP?

Frowningprovidence · 01/04/2025 09:57

Just as an aside, my son likes pot noodles and he had a restricted diet at one point for autism related reasons. I actually looked at the salt, fat, nutrition of pot noodles v a number of other ready meals as i was worried, and it wasnt that different.

I'm not suggesting they are a health food, but some of the healthier looking ready meals are also low in protein, high in salt and sugar.

Ihad2Strokes · 01/04/2025 09:58

Livelovebehappy · 01/04/2025 09:34

Food is not ‘therapy’. Eating is something every one of us does to survive. And where did I say exercise is not therapeutic? It’s therapeutic of course to certain disabilities. And that’s exactly the sort of therapy PIP should pay for. I’d still argue that going and having your hair done is not a necessity. Many people don’t have their hair done because they can’t afford it. To suggest there are situations where someone can’t put a brush through their hair is madness.

It's not madness and just being very bloody grateful you've never felt like that.

I can't be bothered to try and find it on the thread again, but I'm pretty sure she was talking about her hair being washed not brushed anyway wasn't she?

Ask my name states I have had strokes, I can't manipulate things in my hand or hold them very tight so yes brushing my hair is a complete fucking nightmare, washing my hair is hit and miss, I can't feel my head and my head can't feel my hands, so I just have to hope that by doing it every day my hair will all get washed and be clean over a few days even if not washed well each day.

So maybe just count your lucky stars and stop telling other people their experience isn't real

Breezybetty · 01/04/2025 10:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lentilweaver · 01/04/2025 10:02

I would just like to know which country people would have moved to, if not for Brexit. I know countries where life is cheap, but I don't think such countries offer disability benefits, do they? Cheap countries tend to rely on family help.

Hoggyhoghog · 01/04/2025 10:03

PandoraSox · 01/04/2025 09:56

My DH needs help with personal care, dressing, needs help to prepare meals etc. and uses a wheelchair. But he can drive. It is something he really enjoys too, and is good at. Should he lose his PIP?

As I said some will still score a 4 but driving and being responsible for controlling and maneuvering a car is a physical and mental ability so every claimant who can do this needs to be assessed first.

Pistachioitaliano · 01/04/2025 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Absolutely. It is the unreasonable expectations of some that will cause the system to collapse, leaving nothing for even the most severely disabled which would be catastrophic.

Ihad2Strokes · 01/04/2025 10:04

Livelovebehappy · 01/04/2025 09:26

People don’t always apply for something just because they need it. Many will apply just because they want it. I guess the incentive is there where money is concerned, however difficult it might be. The end goal for many would be worth the ‘difficulty*.

you really are the gift that keeps giving🙇🏻‍♀️🙇🏻‍♀️

Why have you put difficulty in inverted commas??

It is a long and difficult form to fill-in, I had to ask a friend to do it for me because I was physically and mentally unable to do it myself.

I received my Pip award letter yesterday, the person that did the assessment on the phone was very nice, but she's written contradictory things that make no sense, so now I have to decide whether it is worth going through an appeal tribunal to put it right or not and just live with the Assessment they have made.

PandoraSox · 01/04/2025 10:06

Hoggyhoghog · 01/04/2025 10:03

As I said some will still score a 4 but driving and being responsible for controlling and maneuvering a car is a physical and mental ability so every claimant who can do this needs to be assessed first.

DVLA are happy for him to continue driving with hand controls. Many disabled people use them.

EasternStandard · 01/04/2025 10:06

It does look like you’ll lose money with Labour’s proposals.

Hard to know what will happen with people in the same situation.

Also same as @Lentilweaverif life is hard for the op now I doubt the energy is there to move countries, or that it’s easy for those in a similar position. Had Brexit not happened.

Rachelsthorns · 01/04/2025 10:08

Sourwitch · 01/04/2025 00:12

Your day describes mine almost. I often say I think I have ME as I feel constantly exhausted and can’t do too much. DP doesn’t understand and thinks I should do more exercise but doesn’t realise that tires me out more. I totally feel your pain with that regards.

I’ve never bothered going to the GP because I don’t feel they’ll believe me because there isn’t an actual test and is down to individual experience. I don’t think everyone feels this tired but I feel people would think I’m telling lies so I rarely tell anyone. I don’t receive any government help financially as my DH supports me but I’d be screwed if he left.

It’s a sad state of affairs but you’re NBU to worry as it seems it’s easy pickings for them

Edited

I've went to the doctor with very similar symptoms. They did a blood test and diagnosed a vitamin D deficiency and an under active thryroid.
Vitamin D deficiency is common and the doctor said that probably most people should be taking a vitamin D supplement or spending at least 15 minutes every day outside in the sun.

I'm now on supplements and medication for the thyroid and I feel so much better.

Go to your doctor. It might not be ME.

verysmellyjelly · 01/04/2025 10:09

Rachelsthorns · 01/04/2025 10:08

I've went to the doctor with very similar symptoms. They did a blood test and diagnosed a vitamin D deficiency and an under active thryroid.
Vitamin D deficiency is common and the doctor said that probably most people should be taking a vitamin D supplement or spending at least 15 minutes every day outside in the sun.

I'm now on supplements and medication for the thyroid and I feel so much better.

Go to your doctor. It might not be ME.

Agree with this! @Sourwitch You should definitely see your GP and ask for some blood tests, as it might be something very treatable and then you’d feel better.

AlphaApple · 01/04/2025 10:10

I know nothing about CFS and I have nothing but the utmost sympathy for sufferers.

There should be better treatments available. And more research.

I am also one of those people, possibly unreasonably, hyper-focused on the OP's diet though. Is it possible to use PIP to pay for a service that delivers better nutrition? Even as a completely healthy person, that diet would absolutely floor me.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 01/04/2025 10:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's in the name. Personal independence payments.

billybear · 01/04/2025 10:11

agree its a big worry. try adding vitamins i know they can boost you up, i am not well and really eat lots of fruit and veg they can also boost you up, try not to worry ,

Lentilweaver · 01/04/2025 10:12

I have been saying for a while that the UK is going to become like many Asian or Mediterranean countries: intergenerational living, community over individual, reduced help from the state, people relying on families.

I am not saying that this is a good thing. I just think it's going to happen because the benefits bill is not sustainable.

Pinepeak2434 · 01/04/2025 10:13

I don’t get PIP but was recently diagnosed with ME/CFS and seem to have been left to get on with it. It’s hell, I have tried everything to improve the way I feel, and I have always eaten very healthy food.

SecretSoul · 01/04/2025 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Do you understand that you can’t actually compel another person to help? Even your husband?

Fucking hell, half the posters on these boards can’t even get their partners to pick up their own pants off the floor - do you imagine they’re going to willingly cut toenails and brush hair?!

I mean, if you’ve got a willing partner then lovely, you don’t need the salon. Although quite often with disability, expert podiatry is actually needed for reasons other than just cutting nails. And of course, that’s assuming they’re capable.

My DM has a husband. He doesn’t do her personal care because he’s terrible at it. He’s cut her accidentally on more than one occasion. She’s on blood thinners so it’s actually really dangerous. It’s actually quite awkward doing personal care in someone else.

Your responses are mind blowing in their ignorance. A spouse does not have a legal responsibility to cut his or her partner’s toenails. It’s entirely reasonable to use PIP to get this type of personal care.

Don’t like it? Campaign to get the law changed to force people to help others. A authoritarian state essentially - but go for it. Careful what you wish for though…it might end up legally forcing you to actually help someone yourself one day.

Rachelsthorns · 01/04/2025 10:15

Pistachioitaliano · 01/04/2025 10:03

Absolutely. It is the unreasonable expectations of some that will cause the system to collapse, leaving nothing for even the most severely disabled which would be catastrophic.

Podiatry is not an unreasonable expectation for many illnesses and disabilities. One that comes to mind is diabetes: it cannot be managed by a husband cutting your nails.

TheWorminLabyrinth · 01/04/2025 10:15

Breezybetty · 01/04/2025 09:47

They should pay their bills either by working or claiming benefits. The extra money they get for PIP is to be spent on the disability. If the non-PIP benefits are not enough to live off how are those without PIP getting by?

Nobody seems to appreciate the need to reduce benefit spending at all. The extent to which it is totally unaffordable.

I work, i'm my husbands' carer. My wage is £81.90 per week.

The benefits you are suggesting should pay our bills are not enough. So I have to use his PIP to help pay them.

Would you like to swap lives? Show me how it should be done?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread