Haven't read the full thread, so apols if this has been mentioned.
Does anyone remember Andy Burnham's so-called 'death tax'? The idea was that the government would introduce a one-off charge or levy, to be paid by individuals as part of their estate after death. I can't remember how it worked, but let's say for example, anyone leaving an estate of 50k was exempt and then after that, on a sliding scale, you paid a small percentage. Maybe 5% if you left an estate of 500k.
The proceeds were intended to fund the social care system, so no-one ended up in this situation.
It was absolutely decried by the Conservatives, labelled a 'death tax' and was quickly shelved. But actually, what that would have meant was that the burden of care costs fell equally on everyone except the least well off, but you wouldn't ever need to pay it in your lifetime. It would have removed the total 'lottery' nature of care costs as they currently stand, where if you're unlucky enough to get a degenerative brain disease like Parkinson's or dementia you may well end up spending hundreds of thousands of pounds on care, but if you have another type of illness that doesn't require that type of care, you're fully funded by the NHS.
Because there are no insurance policies you can take out against the risk of potential care costs in the future, it is currently just pot luck whether you end up in the social care system and pay £000000s vs the NHS and pay nothing.
Personally, if I was leaving an estate of £500k but 5% of that went straight to the government as a 'death tax', I would be happy. I'd still be leaving an estate of £475k after all, and even if I'd never needed any care whatsoever, I'd have lived my final years in the knowledge that if I had needed it, it was covered by the system set up with the proceeds of the tax.
Obviously that's a brief and simplistic overview and there are all kinds of caveats, but I do agree with the general principle that the burden of care costs should be shared equally by society, not just the unlucky few. And if you're not even alive to see that money being paid out, it's not really an issue, is it?