Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like I might never spend the holidays with my family again

55 replies

MaLanny · 28/12/2024 19:22

Hi all,

I feel awful writing this but I need some perspective. This year I was really lucky and had the most amazing Christmas with my fiancés family. For various reasons we haven't done Christmas with his family before, my parents always guilted me into spending it with them.

Christmas with my family has always been a little underwhelming, even as a kid. My parents were never the type to make a show of Christmas, decorations were minimal, dinner was all premade stuff and the whole day just sort of dragged. They have never been thoughtful gift givers preferring to just give money to get your own thing etc.
Now I don't fault this, if this is how they like Christmas then great.

Fiancés family are the opposite. His aunt and uncle hosted for us, his brother, his parents and grandparents and for his cousin and her lovely little girl.
In the morning we woke up late, and opened presents, my fiancé had put so much thought into the gifts, and he was genuinely excited to see me open them. Even down to the wrapping which included bows and ribbons and he was like a kid excitedly saying "look it has polar bears and it's green it's your two favourites" like he really thought it all through. We then got dressed up which is totally alien to me at Christmas as a pyjama family but it was lovely.
When we got to his aunt and uncles we did the gift exchange there and it was the same, all gorgeously wrapped, really well thought out considerate presents. His family have a rule where the "grandparent" generation cook, so his aunt and uncle and his parents sorted all of dinner. Apparently it's so as our generation have more kids (only his cousin has a kid so far) we get to spend Christmas with them and playing with them without worrying about cooking. Which again just feels so thoughtful. So when they went off to cook, my fiancé and his brother and cousin set up the toy car race track they'd got for the little girl and everyone raced their cars. She loved it and it was so refreshing as if it was my parents, we'd have been sat silently in front of the telly!
Dinner was incredible, salmon roulade starter, goose and beef wellington for main with all the trimmings, proper Christmas pudding and a lovely trifle.
After dinner we all went a walk and stopped in the pub, which again was just nice to be out for a little as my family would never do that.
Back in, film on but there was no pressure to be quiet and watch, half of us were on the floor with the little girl playing with her toys, it just felt so festive. The conversation was lovely, no one was shouting or arguing.
Once the little girl went to bed we all played games.

In all my life I've never had such a lovely Christmas. I've never felt so cared about. The effort was incredible and you could tell they all really loved doing it.

His family also go all out for new years, host a party etc.

Now we are TTC and my mum knows. She keeps going on about how if I get pregnant soon she will get babies first Christmas since we spent this one with my fiancés side. But honestly I don't know if I could go back to my parents for Christmas ever again. It's so much more festive and well thought out at my fiancés and it felt so welcoming and fun.

AIBU to think that for as long as I'm with my fiancé and his family are hosting Christmas like this (which they have done more or less every year of his whole life so not likely to stop soon), id rather go there and have a lazy Boxing Day with my parents? Or is it on me to make sure i see my parents at Christmas too even if I enjoy it less?

OP posts:
ASimpleLampoon · 01/01/2025 23:23

MaLanny · 28/12/2024 19:54

It's not so much it being quiet, I do love how festive it was at my fiancés but it's also the lack or arguing and tension. There were no expectations to do anything and everything was very opt in and hiccups were just absorbed and laughed at rather than stressed over (like the little one knocked over a glass it smashed, no one shouted or got upset, it was laughed at, said oops must be more careful and drinking wine out of a champagne glass became a little funny part of the day). Everyone also just chipped in to stop it being stressful and with 4 adults with no kids on dinner they didn't seem overly stressed vs it being one person doing all the heavy lifting.
If it was just quiet I think I could handle it.

Also the attention to detail made it special. The little 3 year old had coloured in the name cards for place settings which was just so sweet and the presents all being wrapped so nicely - it's a small thing but it was just nice that everyone cared so much.

Why is only your mum doing the heavy lifting? Maybe your mum kept things low key due to not having any help? What prevented you and your brother, who I assume are both adults, from chipping in and helping. Your Dad's stance on Christmas is obvious but what's your excuse as adults? My daughter offers to help me and she's just 12.

BlueSilverCats · 01/01/2025 23:58

@ASimpleLampoon maybe your daughter helps because she's not afraid of doing something wrong or cause an argument and ruin Christmas/whatever or being shouted at.

So maybe get off your high horse and consider the environment OP grew up in and the conditioning she had. An environment that made , as a full grown ass adult, worry and expect shouting over a 3 yo knocking a glass over!

lifesrichpageant · 02/01/2025 00:05

OP just here to say that your partner's family sound lovely. I am very happy for you. Some families are just generally more grounded, easygoing, "adult" and emotionally regulated than others. Being born into one is the ultimate blessing and privilege, and marrying into one is the next best thing. I am also glad for your future children. Good luck with TTC.

InspectorGidget · 02/01/2025 12:10

You definitely need to start drawing boundary lines now....

Do you in laws live nearer?

We alternated Xmas as my IL live 4 hours away and it was a similar dynamic to yours.

They came to us one year and I hosted and all my family turned up late and half cut as the pub is more important on Xmas day. My DH and MIL were so upset for me and I haven't hosted since.

Once dd arrived I made it very clear we were not travelling or hosting a dinner but we have an open house where people are free to come and go.

My family come round mid morning before the pub and then leave us to it. MIL passed away and FIL has remarried so we have no real reason to travel at Christmas so have been able to do what we want to do.

This year we were invited to a friends and we wandered around at 4pm and had a lovely evening.

You have to set the scene to make Christmas what you want for your family. If you make it clear Christmas will be at home for your little one and certainly the first Christmas morning just the 3 of you but they are welcome later / Boxing Day and if you happen to wander to your in laws for 'an hour' they can't claim you owe them.

Families hey!

Good luck with TTC x x

wizzywig · 02/01/2025 12:14

Honestly it's lovely to finally read a happy Christmas story!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread