Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some people are more popular than others?

55 replies

shouldprobablyturnalighton · 03/12/2024 19:20

Especially those who don't seem to be particularly nice?!

There’s a child at my kids’ school who is incredibly popular. I’m there quite a bit for various reasons, and it’s astonishing how much attention this one child gets. Their name is constantly being called, for example if someone does something vaguely impressive, they want this kid to see it or if there’s a game going on, they want this kid to join. The school has noticed too and the parents called in at one point because the sheer level of attention was becoming too much.

We’ve known this kid for years. Back in nursery, their name was a regular feature on reports concerning my children (think hitting, arguments, that sort of thing). It was very much a love-hate dynamic as they and my DC often brought out the worst in each other but still sought each other’s company. This has calmed down a bit of late, but since we've hit school I now hear from
other parents that this child isn’t particularly kind. Stories like orchestrating games to leave others out, saying 'I hate you' or “If you do X mean thing to so-and-so, you can play with us.” This doesn't seem like completely off the wall behaviour for kids based on my memory of being one, but I always thought it would happen when they were bigger rather than reception/year 1. Showing my naïvity perhaps but it's not happening with the majority, haven't heard anything about the other 20+ children so does seem like the exception rather than the rule at this point.

I’m trying (often failing but still trying!) not to judge too harshly—they’re still very little, and so much can change. But it does make me wonder: why is it that people, even young children, often crave the approval of those who aren’t very kind? And what is it which makes some people SO much more popular than others?!

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 04/12/2024 11:13

Absolutely “would do anything for anyone” is not a quality I want in a friend. Sparky /interesting /fun / like minded / initiates fun stuff /soneone I click with that’s what most people are looking for in a friend.

shouldprobablyturnalighton · 04/12/2024 11:13

Manchesterbythesea · 04/12/2024 11:03

My ds20 was always very popular and still is. I’m not sure what it is about him but he’s extremely likeable.
Anyway this is a true story…A mother once phoned me and told me she was sick to death of her kids talking about my ds. She said ‘It’s Charlie this and Charlie that and I’m fucking sick of it!’
I was absolutely gobsmacked 😶

Edited

Blimey!! How did you respond??

Funnily enough early on in reception that was the sort of thing being said by some of the parents in the playground, in a more tongue in cheek. More 'Who is this x kid?? Are they handing out sweets at lunch or something? Y can't stop talking about them!'. Or someone did say to the parents 'ah so you're the ones with the popular kid! X would love to invite them round for a playdate', but it wasn't ever said meanly like in your experience.

It certainly stopped being so funny/lighthearted when it became apparent they were often rather mean though, sadly. Wonder if the playdates and invites have dried up to match.

OP posts:
Isitisit · 04/12/2024 11:13

Same as the reason that so many people are in toxic relationships. We are often drawn to people like this because the uncertainty is exciting. When they are then nice to you, it gives an adrenaline rush. Other more consistent relationships can seem boring in comparison.

shouldprobablyturnalighton · 04/12/2024 11:17

TheaBrandt · 04/12/2024 11:13

Absolutely “would do anything for anyone” is not a quality I want in a friend. Sparky /interesting /fun / like minded / initiates fun stuff /soneone I click with that’s what most people are looking for in a friend.

Can attest to this. I'd do anything for anyone, am intensely loyal and have had to learn both not to put myself out for others and also not to expect anyone out there to ever make as much effort as me. I'm not at all popular. Haven't ever been a bridesmaid, or a godparent, I hear after the fact that friends have hung out or gone on holidays together. Am just not top of the invite list. I think perhaps I'm just not that fun/funny. But I'll always show up if you need a friend, and will do things just to be kind. I like to do these things, but you're absolutely right it doesn't make you popular.

OP posts:
Arraminta · 04/12/2024 16:49

Wistfuller · 04/12/2024 11:09

I agree with your two posts, @anxioussister -- there's a real tendency on Mn, which has more than its fair share of posters who struggle socially, to demonise the socially-confident for just going about their business, and not dedicating themselves to 'including' random people they may barely know.

And yes, @TheYearOfSmallThings, you see that all the time on here. People saying 'Why don't people like me? I run around after other people all the time, I'd do anything for anyone, so why am I always left out?' Speaking for myself, I'm not interested in your capacity to provide services, I don't need you to rescue me or lend me money, I'm primarily interested in whether I find you good company. Which has nothing to do with your loyalty or kindness.

Me too. I really don't want a friend who is slavishly devoted to me and runs around after me, to be honest. If anything that would make me actively dislike them because it's a bit cringe.

I want a friend who shares my interests and sense of humour, who is chilled and open minded.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page