Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Landlords response to Labour proposal

248 replies

Stellaris22 · 11/09/2024 08:01

Surely it’s becoming increasingly difficult to defend landlords.

In response to proposals to make renting fairer and better for tenants landlords have responded with typical ‘we’ll increase rents’.

Yes there are good and bad tenants just as there are good and bad landlords. LLs need to stop the saviour attitude of thinking they’re helping people who can’t afford to buy. They can’t afford to buy because of their high rents!

Good to see Labour (hopefully) tackling the private rental sector.

OP posts:
Iwishicouldflyhigh · 11/09/2024 11:03

UncharteredWaters · 11/09/2024 08:43

Unfortunately if enough landlords sell it will crash the house prices in that sector, the landlord can probably take the hit. The wee couple who saved to buy theirs on a 90% mortgage probably can’t and now are stuck in negative equity.

whilst people run their hands in glee at the big bad landlord, spare a thought for the families this will affect.

Market crashes and then LL's will buy the stock again as the yields will be high.

Beefcurtains79 · 11/09/2024 11:04

GasPanic · 11/09/2024 10:24

There is no such thing as an "accidental landlord".

No one "accidentally" decides to let their house out and comply with all renting rules and regulations. It's a choice they make. Probably because they don't want to incur what is perceived at the time as a loss.

I had to work away for a year, I couldn’t afford to leave my flat empty as despite the protests of ill informed posters on here, we aren’t all loaded.

Perplexed20 · 11/09/2024 11:05

Sciencestyle · 11/09/2024 08:43

I'm a landlord, had the same tenants for 20 years, rent is slightly below what it could be because I want them to stay.
So from my perspective the changes are welcome, I've seen landlords use section 21 for all sorts of daft reasons. We will still be able to get the property back if we want to move in / sell or Tennant doesn't pay rent - seems fair to me.

Same.
Except we inherited our Tennant from our mother. Think she's been there 45 years. Rent is less but absolutely no hassle.

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 11/09/2024 11:06

Booksandflowers · 11/09/2024 10:02

I’m a new landlord and not worried. When it comes in I can only evict due to a good reason - well I would anyway. House is well maintained and rent will increase annually by as much as I am allowed to so there’s never a big jump (that’s not allowed)

Don't be too unworried. We've had similar in Scotland for years and it is a problem. One of the eviction clauses is that you can evict to sell. One of my LLs wants to do this (bereaved, wants to clear debts and move overseas) and the tenant is refusing to budge, has got free solicitor and the Tribunal keeps asking for more info (from both sides). My LL is about £2500 down on legal fees and still no eviction date.

GingerPirate · 11/09/2024 11:06

Well of course we'll raise rents.
Any other appropriate response/reaction?

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 11/09/2024 11:07

Perplexed20 · 11/09/2024 11:05

Same.
Except we inherited our Tennant from our mother. Think she's been there 45 years. Rent is less but absolutely no hassle.

Because you've had the tenant for so long, it won't apply to your current tenant anyway (unless you put them on a new style lease).

Carrotmccarrotface · 11/09/2024 11:07

The Scottish government tries out crazy housing policies so the UK doesn’t have to. The rent freeze sent rents increasing faster than anywhere else in the UK. It also meant that the plug was pulled on some major build-to-rent construction projects. Disastrous.

BellaBlythe · 11/09/2024 11:07

@wombat15 I have not interrogated them on their health issues obviously. I rely on minor remarks. They intimated that Life Insurance for the period of the loan is impossible.
Do you doubt otherwise? They have been with me over 6years.

ginger2026 · 11/09/2024 11:08

DrArchieMorrisIsVeryFunnyInSeason12 · 11/09/2024 10:44

I've been a landlord to two properties but would never do it again.

I guess I would be classed as a good landlord as the properties were maintained to a high standard and furnished really well right down to posh coffee machine, egg cups etc. More what you would expect in a airbnb I guess. They even had a better sofa that me. I guess it was pride in wanting to provide a 'nice place to live'.

However - make no mistake about it. It was a business and I charged what I thought I could. When I thought I could put rents up I did. When the tenant asked me to reconsider I increased it by less but still an increase (she was a good tenant). I felt I was providing a desirable place to live, furnished to a high standard and maintained properly and thus I should be rewarded for that. The demand for the flat was massive when I advertised it.

The second tenant to live there got the same treatment but he did not look after the place and as my concerns grew about damage I decided the easiest thing to do was just sell up rather than try and change his behaviour or remove him for a fake reason. I didn't care about the inconvenience to him, I cared about the inconvenience to myself of him not looking after the place.

These flats were very small but in the centre of Edinburgh. At the time I was renting them for about £650 which increased to about £750 a few years later.

These flats are now renting out for £950-£1150 because there is such a rental shortage in Edinburgh. I still wouldn't do it again. To do it right there is alot of admin, practical stuff and the constant worrying of someone damaging an asset which they don't own. Also in Edinburgh where the flats are often tenements and the majority are rented out, nobody is looking after the overall building as they don't have factors so roof repairs etc go unnoticed etc

I now have my money in S&S ISA's, Pensions and when they are maxed out GIA (general investment accounts invested in stock market).

I make more money with far less effort.

I feel for tenants who are good tenants and look after the property and are now being subject to higher and higher rents. However your landlord is in it for the money. Yes they might want to provide a nice flat and maintain it well etc but they are not your friend. If they can raise the rent because that is what the market is dictating then yes they will. If they are charging out less than market rate then honestly why are they doing it?

If I was a tenant now (and I have been in the past so I understand the frustration) I would beg, borrow or steal to buy somewhere even if it is a tiny hole. At least that way you are out of the cycle of renting with it's insecurity and lack of control over your own home. Once you own somewhere even if tiny, you can start to build equity.

I would live in a bedsit I owned rather than rent a posh house. I understand some people need a certain amount of space for kids etc but honestly if you can, get out of the rental market and buy whatever you can afford even if tiny and work from there. (obviously does not apply to those temporary in a city for 6 months etc)

Much as I would never be a landlord again I would also do everything in my power to avoid being a tenant again living with the fear of being ask to leave at anytime and paying over large sums of money that I never saw again

its easy to do that when you start young. I bought when I was 26 and DH was 29. that plus fertility issues mean that we are still fairly comfortable in our 2 bed flat and don't need to move (but even I started looking at larger flats when we were thinking of ttc but its not really necessary if we don't have kids or our only kid is much delayed).

the average FTB is in their 30s now and fertility can be a ticking time bomb (plus most couples even in their mid 30s seem to conceive faster than us). if you live in somewhere for 2 years you would hardly build equity.

Alwaystired94 · 11/09/2024 11:08

Parsley1234 · 11/09/2024 08:25

@MidnightPatrol only if they can afford a mortgage most tenants choose to rent

what planet are you on? the vast vast majority who privately rent would prefer to buy and have security. most cannot as the high rents make saving for a deposit impossible.

oakleaffy · 11/09/2024 11:11

Beefcurtains79 · 11/09/2024 11:04

I had to work away for a year, I couldn’t afford to leave my flat empty as despite the protests of ill informed posters on here, we aren’t all loaded.

That was how we were able to rent {at approx 50% less than going rate} a lovely 1 bedroomed flat near Richmond Park.
It was 'Landlady's'' home, {She was elsewhere } and she just wanted it lived in - we stayed there for a year.
Zero security, and nothing in writing - it seems crazy now, but it worked out for both parties.

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 11/09/2024 11:11

Carrotmccarrotface · 11/09/2024 11:07

The Scottish government tries out crazy housing policies so the UK doesn’t have to. The rent freeze sent rents increasing faster than anywhere else in the UK. It also meant that the plug was pulled on some major build-to-rent construction projects. Disastrous.

Totally agree - the minute that rents could be raised (when tenants left), they were.

This has meant increased rents and tenants feeling unable to move (as they'd have to rent at a far higher price).

The reason LL's hugely increase rent when the flat's vacant is because when it's let, there is a 12% rent cap - so they increase whilst they can.

It's a shit show.

Superworm24 · 11/09/2024 11:11

This doesn't actually solve anything though does it. The underlying issues are still there. You can hate landlord all you want but they haven't caused this issue.

wombat15 · 11/09/2024 11:13

BellaBlythe · 11/09/2024 11:07

@wombat15 I have not interrogated them on their health issues obviously. I rely on minor remarks. They intimated that Life Insurance for the period of the loan is impossible.
Do you doubt otherwise? They have been with me over 6years.

They don't have to have life insurance for a mortgage. While some lenders might ask for one it is certainly not all.

BellaBlythe · 11/09/2024 11:16

Thanks@wombat15, I learn something new everyday. We have always had Insurance. Thought it was standard.

vivainsomnia · 11/09/2024 11:23

Being a landlord is a job, a profession, and should be treated as such. I'm hoping that those wishing to be landlords understand that better. It's a long haul job and should not be undertaken on a whim
What about tenants who treat their home like a trash house?

I had a respectful couple moving in. All on the surface. The reality is:
They decided to repaint all the room themselves and the quality was so poor, even my kids would have done a better job. It had all been professionally painted before they moved.
They decided to cut a square foot hole in an original door to let their dog out in the garden.
They failed to ventilate and dried clothes on radiators,and all the rooms were full of mould (was never an issue before, nor after).
They left the garden in such a bad state, branches were growing through the vents.
They cut down two beautiful trees. Claimed they'd fallen down during a storm. Neighbours had another story.
They failed to pay for two months, but always made sure to pay something to not go over.

Do you really think landlords should put up and shut up with tenants like this who gradually destroy the property through neglect?

Superworm24 · 11/09/2024 11:30

With regards to terrible tenants who don't pay I do like the idea of rental payments being shown on your credit file. Maybe then there could be some kind of scheme where if you've paid on time in full for x number of years you could get a 100pc mortgage or access to some kind of help to buy deposit scheme.

oakleaffy · 11/09/2024 11:32

Superworm24 · 11/09/2024 11:30

With regards to terrible tenants who don't pay I do like the idea of rental payments being shown on your credit file. Maybe then there could be some kind of scheme where if you've paid on time in full for x number of years you could get a 100pc mortgage or access to some kind of help to buy deposit scheme.

That would be a great idea.

oakleaffy · 11/09/2024 11:38

vivainsomnia · 11/09/2024 11:23

Being a landlord is a job, a profession, and should be treated as such. I'm hoping that those wishing to be landlords understand that better. It's a long haul job and should not be undertaken on a whim
What about tenants who treat their home like a trash house?

I had a respectful couple moving in. All on the surface. The reality is:
They decided to repaint all the room themselves and the quality was so poor, even my kids would have done a better job. It had all been professionally painted before they moved.
They decided to cut a square foot hole in an original door to let their dog out in the garden.
They failed to ventilate and dried clothes on radiators,and all the rooms were full of mould (was never an issue before, nor after).
They left the garden in such a bad state, branches were growing through the vents.
They cut down two beautiful trees. Claimed they'd fallen down during a storm. Neighbours had another story.
They failed to pay for two months, but always made sure to pay something to not go over.

Do you really think landlords should put up and shut up with tenants like this who gradually destroy the property through neglect?

Did they not have a deposit left against damage?

This is why a lot of landlords won't allow children or pets.

Cutting a hole in your door for a dog flap is so cheeky and sounds like they were leaving the dog for hours on it's own - plus dog flaps can be easily accessed by small people for burglaries.

A female murderer in USA infamously gained access via her victim's dog flap.

Ohdoboreoff · 11/09/2024 11:39

MountUnpleasant · 11/09/2024 09:01

YANBU. They don't do it to provide a service, they do it to avoid work. Absolute scroungers.

I had to give up work due to illness that lead to disability. Got my first job at 13 and worked till 40.
Did hope and pray the NHS would act in time to prevent the illness becoming a permanent disability, but hey thats for another thread.

The only thing keeping me from being homeless destitute and starving, is the small amount I earn in rent.
The system doesnt see fit to provide disabled claimants with enough money to eat and keep the heating / lights on. But again, thats for another thread.

Yeah, proper scroungers us LLs. Workshy, lazy, absolute parasites. How dare we.

Hoppinggreen · 11/09/2024 11:41

oakleaffy · 11/09/2024 11:38

Did they not have a deposit left against damage?

This is why a lot of landlords won't allow children or pets.

Cutting a hole in your door for a dog flap is so cheeky and sounds like they were leaving the dog for hours on it's own - plus dog flaps can be easily accessed by small people for burglaries.

A female murderer in USA infamously gained access via her victim's dog flap.

Max deposit is 5 weeks rent, its unlikely to cover all that.
In many cases just repairing and repainting walls (unless normal wear and tear) can cost more than the deposit

marmite2023 · 11/09/2024 11:48

This will only work if they prevent massive property funds buying up the released buy to lets, which is what has fucked the US property market. I reckon they should cap property ownership eg no more than 10 properties, including those held by funds (never gonna happen).

small landlords like me, letting out my old flat as my dh massively out-earns me and the flat is my back-up plan and pension, tend to care about our tenants and look after the property as I previously lived there and will one day again. Same as those forced to move for work. Most of the recent legislation impacts us disproportionately, when it’s large-scale landlords and property funds that run the majority of the slum lets and price gouging and they still get away with it, and can afford to absorb the cost of legislation like this trough economies of scale.

Thebaguette · 11/09/2024 11:49

MidnightPatrol · 11/09/2024 08:21

Well… the houses they sell will home people still.

The crisis is caused by a lack of available housing full stop, not because massively over-leveraged slum lords can no longer make their sums work in a higher interest rate environment.

Or maybe the foreign investors will buy them and leave them vacant or use them as holiday let.

wombat15 · 11/09/2024 11:55

BellaBlythe · 11/09/2024 11:16

Thanks@wombat15, I learn something new everyday. We have always had Insurance. Thought it was standard.

Definitely not.

PfishFood · 11/09/2024 11:59

TinyYellow · 11/09/2024 08:14

The court system is going to be fucked.

Landlords don’t need to be defended. The ones that do things wrong don’t deserve defence and the ones who run their properties well deserve as much consideration as tenants.

Couldn't have said it better.

Unfortunately the worst landlords and the worst tenants make the whole rental sector worse for all the decent tenants and landlords.