Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to insist on details of husbands affair, he can’t / refuses to give and I can’t move on without details.

258 replies

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 09:46

NC and apols for long post. PLEASE read and advise me, I’m desperate!

Feels like My whole world has just fallen apart.
Been with DH 30 years, married for 22yr, we have 4 DC age 20, 18, 16 and 15.
I’ve just found out that DH has been having an emotional affair with OW at work for probably the last 4 -5 years and finding out has totally floored me. I had no idea, although now looking back all the signs were very much there. So for up to a quarter of our long marriage, he’s been “connected” to HER and not me. How could I have not known.
I can’t sleep, I’m running on adrenaline and having constant palpitations. The only thing I was ever 100% sure about in my life, was that my husband would always be faithful and that he was not capable of having an affair. 😳 Not in a million years did I believe he would ever do this.
DH is well liked, well respected, funny witty and charming and good at his job. There’s a lot of after work socialising which never bothered me because I 100% trusted him 😡
3 years ago his watsapp shows him / her “turning on disappearing messages” then turning it off again, over a couple of days and then left switched off. He says she was just showing him how it could be done as she’s a Wizz with tech and he so isn’t but loves learning new functions. This would have been around the same time that he switched off the watsapp notification banners from his phone.
From the few messages and call logs that he forgot to delete, I can see that whenever she messaged him, he would respond within minutes. I’ve gone thru my messages over 4 years, most of my messages went unanswered. He attends a lot of big sporting events thru work, she’s always there, in fact she’s arranged many of them. I’ve seen a few pics of them together at dinner or an event in a group (all male except HER). She’s always sat next to DH with a big ridiculous grin on her face, him clearly enjoying himself, I want to vomit.
We have a family app that shares all our locations, I often check it and screenshot it as our DD is ND, I don’t trust her when she’s out, she talks to all people and gets herself into difficult and risky situations (it’s a full time job trying to keep her safe.)
DP hadn’t told me he was going out on particular evening a few months ago (we weren’t talking at the time so I just assumed he was being his usual arsey disrespectful self in not telling me he had an event and would be late home). I took a few screenshots of his location that evening, which changed from a pub to a fancy hotel later in the evening (She lives some distance from work so sometimes stays in town when there’s an event)
Turns out he went back to her hotel room for over an hour at the end of the night (he denied this initially saying he only went to the bar in her hotel to have another drink with her, I’ve visited the hotel, it’s huge, the bar is at the far end of the hotel, his location at every check I made, was at the complete opposite end of the hotel where it shows the rooms are. He denies anything went on and he’d just gone up to look at the fancy room. He can’t remember what they talked about, they get on well, the conversation just flows and they enjoy each others company. He’d been drinking all evening, he can’t remember the details, assumes they had a cup of tea and a chat (He’d been with her at work since 9am that morning but still felt the need to stay in her company for over an hour more at 11pm.) He made 3 short calls to her upon arriving at the hotel that night, he can’t remember why but assumes that it was to arrange to meet her in the hotel, as they probably left the pub (5 mins away) separately so nobody from work would be suspicious. (If they are at that stage then I’m very sure that everyone at work will already suspect/know about the affair.) I feel physically sick and I am struggling to get past this without more information which he won’t give me.
He swore on the children’s lives that nothing physical went on. I am inclined to believe him as he struggles with ED and I don’t think he would have wanted to risk putting himself in a vulnerable position where he’d have no guarantee that he could “perform adequately” for her. I now 100% believe that if he didn’t struggle with ED, then the affair would have become physical also.
The same night DH received a message from HER daughter asking if “he’s with mum, cos she’s not picking up”. HER daughter also works for the company. There’s a few messages over the years from daughter asking about mums locations and asking DH to get her mum to call her. The cosiness of it all makes me feel sick. OW is married, her husband isn’t the father of the daughter.
There was a screenshot on his phone of a different hotel / different event / different day, he thinks it was probably the directions to “walk her back safely to her hotel” on that occasion but “can’t remember.”
Our relationship over the last 4 years has not been good. I’ve accused him so many times of being “emotionally abusive.” He’s been totally detached, returning from work either ignoring me completely or if I dared to speak to him he would shout at me or hurl insults. If I wanted to give him updates on the children, he’d shout asking why I was telling him that NOW, as “he’s just walked thru the door / just going to the gym / just eaten his dinner/ just going to bed.” Basically there was never a good time to talk to him, he had been getting his “fix” from HER throughout the day and had nothing left for me, she has been meeting all his emotional needs and sharing all the small talk, which should have been shared with me, his wife.
All he ever wanted to do when he was at home, was sit glued to the TV or his phone.
He’s had a few weekends abroad with his friends (I don’t doubt this as I know the friends). On his return he would barely say Hi to me as he walked thru the door, he would never share the details of his weekend away, he simply did not want to communicate with me. I’ve since seen in messages, he and HER would discuss his weekend away.
I took DD away for 5 days, he never called me once to chat or see how we were getting on.
I went away with my friends for a few days, he worked from home, he called her at 7:35am, he must have been waking up thinking of her. He spent 40 minutes on a call to her later that day. He couldn’t even spend 2 minutes talking to me when I returned home.
As things got worse between us over the 4 yrs, I always had hope that one day he’d calm down, stop being so distant, rude and aggressive towards me and the children. I even contacted his GP and asked him to consider changing his BP meds as they were causing mood changes and making him angry all the time ! As he was getting emotionally closer to her he was putting more distance between us to ease his guilt no doubt.
After admitting the emotional affair, He now recognises he “lost focus” and is really trying his best to be a better husband. We’re talking so much more, there’s hugs and we’ve had sex again. He wants to book more holidays, he’s told me to make enquiries about the loft extension I’ve wanted for 10 years and he wants us to renew our wedding vows. He is making a HUGE effort, I’d genuinly forgotten how good we could be together. Unfortunately the big light inside of me has switched off, yes I’m very much enjoying him showing me all the respect, interest and care that I’ve so craved and needed this last 4 years, but I’m struggling to get past all the lies and deceit and every time he shows me respect I’m totally conflicted, it reminds me of the hell I’ve been thru the last 4 years and what I have missed out on due to his selfish infidelity. He continued to lie about the details and extent of their “very good connection” even after I found out. It was only after me putting together the few messages he hadn’t deleted, his location screen shots and checking it all back to my personal diary that he eventually admitted and became truthful about some of their “togethers”. There must be millions of others that I don’t know about because the information is now all deleted.
He’s now refusing to answer anymore questions, says he’s told me everything he can and he can’t / won’t be telling me anymore, it’s too stressful for him. (He told me very little other than answer direct questions I asked about the content of a few messages I had actually seen.) He will show me by his actions from here on in, that he’s sorry and wants to be a better husband. I definitely see him making a big effort to show me he loves me and he’s sorry.
He keeps telling me how much he loves me and is desperate for me to say it back to him. I can’t as I no longer know what love is. I thought I loved him even during the 4 years that he treated me so appallingly and desperately tried to pin his changed behaviour / distance and aggression towards me on the BP meds. How bloody naive and trusting was I.
I am an incredibly strong and resilient woman but I don’t think that I can move on without knowing the details, I cannot process it unless I know exactly what I am processing and the depth of their relationship / deceit.
I’m awake in the middles of the night with all these scenarios and questions bashing my skull. I can’t think of anything else. I really feel I’m heading for a breakdown. I flit from thinking I need to speak to her, to I need to tell her husband, but really what I need, is for him to tell me, and be honest about all the “details”, it will no doubt be extremely painful for me (him too), but I’d like to think that once I know details, I can process them and in time hopefully think about them less, maybe come to terms with it and move on.
AIBU to insist on the details. Pressuring him for more may well tip him over the edge.
Without them, I don’t think we have a marriage if he can’t be honest with me after what he’s put me thru.
Thank you if you’ve read this far. I’m desperate for advice.

OP posts:
Fireangels · 31/08/2024 15:31

“Many, many thanks.
On top of everything else, If I knew they’d had sex then there would be no coming back.
I know most posters believe he has had sex with her.
I don’t believe he has. He would NEVER put himself in such a vulnerable position where he would be uncertain whether he could perform.
He is fiercely competitive, has to be the best at everything he does, no way would he expose himself to possible embarrassing failure in this way.”

Firstly, I wish you happiness and peace whatever you decide to do going forward. The thing that stands out for me in your reply is that you say he didn’t sleep with her because he couldn’t. So do you think he would’ve had he been physically capable? This is a question he will never answer so you’d need to use your judgment but will never know for sure.
Really it all boils down to are you prepared to draw a line under the last four years and move on together, or not?

LittleSeasideCottage · 31/08/2024 15:33

Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:27

Some of my friends have had affairs, or their partners have. The ones who managed to stay together (and some are happier than pre-affair due to the work they've done on their marriages since) did not insist on the "guilty" one sharing details of the affair. This was on therapists' advice. The thinking being that once you know those things, you can never un-know them, they're always in your head and you can't genuinely move on.

I would think hard about whether, after the extended length of this betrayal, you feel that you will be able to trust your husband again. If you think there's a chance, focus on what you BOTH need to do to strengthen your relationship. Affairs are rarely all the fault of one person (I speak as someone who was left for the affair partner).

She doesn't need to go into the minutiae but she needs to know the basic truth and not have her partner gaslight her. At the moment he is shutting down conversations because its too hard for him, so is basically controlling the narrative of their relationship.

Any therapist who doesn't encourage honesty when a partner needs to know the basic truth is not a very credible therapist. Remember not all therapists are good at what they do! there are some very questionable ones out there.

Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:38

@littleseasidecottage She knows about the affair. She doesn't need to know how many times they met, where, whether they kissed, what they talked about, where they went for dinner, etc. None of that changes anything other than by putting in her mind very specific details which she will then worry away at indefinitely.

He's cheated. For a long time. She can choose to end the marriage or try to make it work, which will only work if he's genuinely on board too. None of us can say what is right for this couple but I think it's fair to say that trust, or re-building trust, has to start with two way respect and demanding total visibility into your partner's life, tracking their location etc, is not that.

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 15:40

Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:27

Some of my friends have had affairs, or their partners have. The ones who managed to stay together (and some are happier than pre-affair due to the work they've done on their marriages since) did not insist on the "guilty" one sharing details of the affair. This was on therapists' advice. The thinking being that once you know those things, you can never un-know them, they're always in your head and you can't genuinely move on.

I would think hard about whether, after the extended length of this betrayal, you feel that you will be able to trust your husband again. If you think there's a chance, focus on what you BOTH need to do to strengthen your relationship. Affairs are rarely all the fault of one person (I speak as someone who was left for the affair partner).

I find your response very helpful, thanks.
I understand that being hell bent on all the details might not be a good idea, I’ve obviously been researching therapies around EA and that advice keeps cropping up.
I won’t EVER believe that I am in any way responsible for the affair. Those were his choices, his actions, his deceit.
However, I agree that the marriage wasn’t in a great place to start with. As he started putting distance between us, I stopped making effort with him or the marriage.
I am sorry you experienced similar in your marriage, it’s awful to be in that position.

OP posts:
Didimum · 31/08/2024 15:40

Please visit the Surviving Infidelity website forums, you will get good support there. Needing the details is common and not unreasonable.

You can be certain that their affair was physical in some manner. Adults conducting an emotional affair don’t disappear into hotel rooms together.

fuffymeloncauli · 31/08/2024 15:42

The details will not help you. It's over. I'm sorry

Meatwallet · 31/08/2024 15:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Pistachiochiochio · 31/08/2024 15:49

Look at your post. You have loads of details. Lack of detail is not the issue.

LittleSeasideCottage · 31/08/2024 15:49

Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:38

@littleseasidecottage She knows about the affair. She doesn't need to know how many times they met, where, whether they kissed, what they talked about, where they went for dinner, etc. None of that changes anything other than by putting in her mind very specific details which she will then worry away at indefinitely.

He's cheated. For a long time. She can choose to end the marriage or try to make it work, which will only work if he's genuinely on board too. None of us can say what is right for this couple but I think it's fair to say that trust, or re-building trust, has to start with two way respect and demanding total visibility into your partner's life, tracking their location etc, is not that.

I'm not sure I agree with you.

She's trying to make a life changing decision based on the crumbs of information he's deigned to throw to her. She's been emotionally abused, gaslighted and ignored. Even now he's playing the information control game to try to minimise the impact to himself. He's basically asking her to continue the relationship based only on his terms.

One thing I do agree with you on is that she does have a decision to make, it's just a shame he couldn't be honest about the true nature of the affair. Then the OP could make a decision about whether to end the marriage or not based on all the facts. It seems to me what he is actually doing is hedging his bets so he can deny everything to family and friends if you split up. He wants the option of saving face if you do split up.

notbelieved · 31/08/2024 15:50

Your marriage is over. He was unfaithful. He lied. He continues to lie. You will never know what the truth is, even if he deigns to tell you. Which he won’t. Because telling the truth will make it sordid and ungainly and he’ll be the villain in the story and what he needs is to be the prince. What difference would knowing the exact truth make? He’s still lied. He’s still cheated. You don’t want that for yourself. You deserve better - you need to get your head round that quickly. You deserve better. He won’t give you what you deserve. The only thing that will work for you now is to accept, file for divorce and move on.

You can do this. You really can. Thousands of us have and are proof of survival and moving on to a better life.

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 15:51

HazelPlayer · 31/08/2024 14:48

she couldn’t understand why I had labelled it an EA !

Just to add, a woman who - for four years - is exchanging an excess of messages with a married man with four children, having to turn on disappearing messages due to their content, who is receiving early morning personal calls from him, whose DD has his number & is calling him enquiring about her whereabouts, and who has done all this with a work colleague to boot ...... Is not exactly the most reliable arbiter of what is or isn't an emotional affair.

Women who have zero appropriate boundaries around other people's husbands (or in their workplace) don't get to define emotional affairs.

Edited

This made me laugh 😂 Thank you.

I may not have been clear in my messages but the “disappearing messages” between them was only “played with” but not left on (It was actually my DH who switched them off!)
HER DD is 25 and works at the same company so knows my DH well and that’s why she has his number (still makes me sick that she messaged him about whereabouts of mother tho)
Everybody within the company has each other’s numbers, there are so many sub groups for arranging different events etc.

OP posts:
Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:51

@Iwillcomeouttheotherend apologies, I didn't mean to say that the affair was your fault, only that when affairs happen it is rare that the marriage was in a great place and the unfaithful one just decided to have an affair. Communication, feeling unheard or not valued, these are things which both people in the marriage may feel unhappy about but one has an affair. The issues are still issues for both though. When I was left for the affair partner I was devastated and very angry. Over time I've come to accept that - while the affair was unacceptable and cruel - the way I was in the marriage did contribute to the affair happening (though I never thought my partner would be unfaithful as I believed we were solid together and equally committed).

Cardinalita90 · 31/08/2024 15:52

You will drive yourself mad with paranoia when she returns to work. Anyone would. Are you going to be comfortable with him continuing to go on work socials, knowing she'll be there?

Also, I'm not saying this to be cruel, but you keep saying he won't have done anything physical because of his insecurities about his ED. But there's nothing to say he hadn't been in her hotel room doing things to/for her - it seems impossible that he's been to her hotel room and nothing has happened. If they were just talking/have a cuppa why not stay in the bar? There's a reason they wanted privacy OP.

I wish you all the best with this but I'd be pressing him hard on what tangible things he's going to be changing about his behaviour to allay your insecurities now.

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 15:53

NetflixAndKill · 31/08/2024 14:56

I think he knows your draw the line at a sexual interaction and that’s why he’s playing this down. He’s admitting to a lesser offence so his penalty won’t be to lose you. I also think that, you know deep down that this EA has also been physical.

Thank you
But I know it hasn’t.

OP posts:
EC22 · 31/08/2024 15:55

Couple post

EC22 · 31/08/2024 15:55

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 15:53

Thank you
But I know it hasn’t.

No you don’t.

ChristmasFluff · 31/08/2024 15:57

Being willing to share whatever the cheated on partner wants to know is a basic sign of genuine remorse. It shows the cheater is willing to do anything necessary to save the marriage and to help their partner, whatever the cost to themselves.

The reconciliation industry spouts a lot of bollocks about how it's a 'relationship' issue rather than a 'personality and morals of the cheater' issue.

Relationship difficulties are rarely down to one person. Affairs ALWAYS are. Because there's always the option to tell the truth to your partner rather than cheat - to say you have been tempted and need to work on your relationship. Or if the issues are too great, to divorce and move on.

Chumplady is far healthier - she explains how affairs are abuse.

Respect is earned and it would be ridiculous to respect a person who has proven themselves to be immoral and dishonest over a prolonged period. This man is not worthy of respect, because of the way he has disrespected you, OP, time and time again, over 4 years.

HE needs to be the one rebuilding trust and trying to earn back your respect. but he can't be arsed.

OP, Chumplady.com is of more use than any forum that tries to keep people trapped with morally bankrupt selfish and dishonest individuals. Leave a cheater, gain a life.

Oh, and in my experience, the only people who swear on the lives of others are liars.

MrsMoastyToasty · 31/08/2024 16:01

Don't waste your emotions on such a weak man. A man who isn't strong enough to keep the promises he made 22 years ago to "forsake aothers".
Get angry, very very angry.
Get yourself tested directly STIs. He has obviously been dipping his nib in the office inkwell.
Seriously consider divorce.

RedHotWings · 31/08/2024 16:01

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 15:53

Thank you
But I know it hasn’t.

You may wish to unpack why the difference between him:

  1. wanting to have sex with OW and not being able to do so
  2. wanting to have sex with OW and being able to do so.

Is so significant in terms of your ability to have a loving and successful relationship with him moving forward. Ultimately, he disrespected, gaslight, and lied to you in both scenarios.

Grateful for your thoughts

notbelieved · 31/08/2024 16:03

@ChristmasFluff Being willing to share whatever the cheated on partner wants to know is a basic sign of genuine remorse. It shows the cheater is willing to do anything necessary to save the marriage and to help their partner, whatever the cost to themselves

jesus wept. That’s a load of all bollox isn’t it?! You can’t trust a cheater. They lie. That’s how it works. Remorse is common, Genuine remorse is proverbial hen’s teeth.

The marriage is over.

oakleaffy · 31/08/2024 16:03

@Iwillcomeouttheotherend He's lying to you about the lack of physical contact he has with her.

He'll be dosing up on Viagra.

My husband had a work colleague he said was just a friend, but I knew he has staying overnight at her place.

When confronted, he denied and denied and denied...only when confronted with irrefutable evidence did he go chalk white and admit to it.

He moved out into her place immediately he was confronted.

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 16:06

Elektra1 · 31/08/2024 15:51

@Iwillcomeouttheotherend apologies, I didn't mean to say that the affair was your fault, only that when affairs happen it is rare that the marriage was in a great place and the unfaithful one just decided to have an affair. Communication, feeling unheard or not valued, these are things which both people in the marriage may feel unhappy about but one has an affair. The issues are still issues for both though. When I was left for the affair partner I was devastated and very angry. Over time I've come to accept that - while the affair was unacceptable and cruel - the way I was in the marriage did contribute to the affair happening (though I never thought my partner would be unfaithful as I believed we were solid together and equally committed).

Thank you, I didn’t interpret your response in that way, I found your response helpful. I guess I am hyped up on the technical of each word, it’s like this at the moment with DH, He absolutely can’t say the right thing to me at the moment as I am flipping every little thing he says and relating it to his deceit.

He thanks me for making him a cup of tea, the mist comes down and I bark back at him “I bet SHE bloody well knows how many sugars you have in your cup of tea” 😳 I know I need to stop this, it’s not helpful and will add more flames to the fire.

Yes I agree that I also stopped putting effort into the marriage when things were bad.

OP posts:
TangerinePlate · 31/08/2024 16:07

Iwillcomeouttheotherend · 31/08/2024 13:40

Many, many thanks.
On top of everything else, If I knew they’d had sex then there would be no coming back.
I know most posters believe he has had sex with her.
I don’t believe he has. He would NEVER put himself in such a vulnerable position where he would be uncertain whether he could perform.
He is fiercely competitive, has to be the best at everything he does, no way would he expose himself to possible embarrassing failure in this way.

@Iwillcomeouttheotherend

my H is also on the meds for high BP. He has enlarged prostrate as well,that’s how he couldn’t perform with me(his explanation) His ED only manifested itself when he was with me.

OW got a horny bull ready to satisfy her all the time while I went without to stay faithful.

I’m not ugly or unattractive (that’s how H made me feel rejecting me sexually),I had a few ahem…offers but I turned them down because I was you know,married?

I wasn’t attractive enough to arouse him (I don’t look bad for my mid forties,OW has completely different physique.

You THINK your “D” H couldn’t perform,I thought mine couldn’t either. He couldn’t perform with me but he shagged OW senseless.

I asked him if there was somebody else.He swore there wasn’t and that he loved me and only me- guess what? He lied.

The reasons why your H doesn’t want to confess is because if he admits to having sex with OW he would lose you and he doesn’t want that. He wants to (Chump Lady speaking here) have his cake and eat it.
He knows having sex out of marriage is a dealbreaker for you so he won’t admit it.

Have a look at Chump Lady, it’s a real eye opener. I don’t agree 100% with what she said but it helped me massively to see through the bullshit H was feeding me.

My H was never the type to have an affair (until he had one,ha,ha).

We are all different. The stereotype is that cheating physically is the worst thing to happen to cheater’s spouse. To me it was the emotional side of it- a few years is a looong time and it’s a parallel relationship while I knew nothing about it.I didn’t sign up to polygamic one sided relationship in my marriage vows.

It the time,energy,effort that I invested in the marriage and family while my H CHOSE to give it to OW (and not me or his DC)but was happy to take from me,also the fact that he walked extra mile for OW but refused to do basics for me (and his children)

We are all different of course and have different views,experience,circumstances.

Good luck OP,whatever you decide 💐

Disenchantedone · 31/08/2024 16:09

Personally, i think an emotional affair is as bad if not worse than a physical one. He has been totally invested in this for years and years!! People at work must know, like you have said.

I think she has seen the light, that she is only ever going to be his bit on the side, or ... Management found out and disapprove of these sorts of dalliances.
If you found out now that it ended, by her, or problems at work and not by him, he knows that may be very different, as it is an indication he was never going to end it, and you would be stuck with his miserable side for many years more.

After four years of misery, he is doing well to still have you.

I think you will wake up one day and realise you are worth more, i hope so anyway.

TheBottomsOfMyTrousersAreRolled · 31/08/2024 16:11

I thought I loved him even during the 4 years that he treated me so appallingly and desperately tried to pin his changed behaviour / distance and aggression towards me on the BP meds. How bloody naive and trusting was I.
That is what you should be focused on. Stop focusing on how is had an affair and instead get angry about how he treated you.