Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel that these comments were intended to make me feel like a sh*t parent

55 replies

RachM84 · 12/08/2024 12:19

Ok this may be a long one I apologise in advance. Why do I let other people’s opinions get to me and make me doubt myself and then end up overthinking things and questioning if what I’m doing is right. Is anyone else like this? Today my sister messaged me to chat and she ended up making me feel bad and quite anxious (I have anxiety) Ok so a few weeks ago I got an email to say I’d won a competition for a 7 night cruise for two. I enter competitions as a hobby and never expect to win I just do it for fun so I was gobsmacked. Anyway once everything was confirmed with the cruise company i asked if I could possibly book my kids on the cruise if they want to come and was told I could at an extra cost of us of course.

My kids are 21, 18 and 13. I asked them did they want to come and all three of them said no. They like the idea of cruising just not this particular ship as it’s for old people apparently lol. I know my 13 year old shouldn’t really get a choice in the matter as he’s a child after all but there is not much on board for him to do aside from a kids club which he refused to go to and swimming which he also won’t do. You see he is autistic and very sensory to things. I’ve told him if he changes his mind of course he can come and we’ll book him on but up to now the plan is for him to stay home with his brother and sister who are more than capable. We sail on the 1st of September so he will be in school a couple days later and his routine is important to him eg we never take him out of school usually. I did feel guilty at first at the thought of leaving him at home but then everyone I’ve spoken to eg friends and family have all said he will be fine in his own home with two capable siblings and friends and family on hand to check in on him. So then why have I allowed my sister to make me feel like crap.

She messaged me this morning to chat and we got on to the subject of the cruise. She assumed I’d be going with my daughter as she had an expressed an interest in going to the destination we’re going to, but when she Googled the ship and cruise line she changed her mind. She said it’s too posh and not for her age so that was that. So I explained to my sister that I’d be going with my husband and she messaged back saying that I was brave leaving my son (who will be 14 by then) at home for a week and that she could never do that to her own kids as she’d feel to guilty. I explained that I had arranged for people to be on hand to check in on him and that he’d be in school most of the week anyway. She then messaged saying that she’s never even left my nephew for more than a couple of days and he’s 18 years old. I mean why can’t she just be happy for me? If she had won a cruise I’d never dream of questioning her choice to go alone with her partner. Instead I’d offer to help out or check in on her kids. I mean I am leaving my son with two full grown capable adults who happen to be his siblings and he is staying in his own home (as opposed to going to stay elsewhere) keeping his routine going. So why do I now feel like I’m a sh*t parent?

OP posts:
ZeldaFighter · 12/08/2024 12:22

Not unreasonable at all. It's the chance of a lifetime and you ate leaving your son with 2 grown adults in his own home. Go and have fun!

itsmylife7 · 12/08/2024 12:22

I'd say your sister has "anxiety " she's never left her 18 Yr old alone.

Your plan sounds brilliant don't let her spoil your cruise

RachM84 · 12/08/2024 12:23

Well she’s left him for like a night or two but not a week.

OP posts:
EatCrow · 12/08/2024 12:24

Perhaps she intended you to feel that way OP? Sounds like it to me, in which case, although I’d also be hurt, I would definitely not let her know I was. Then I’d keep my distance, polite but distant,

redskydarknight · 12/08/2024 12:25

A question to ask yourself is why your sister's opinion matters to you, (and why the opinion of a bunch of randoms on MN matters to you)?

People make different decisions about things. Your sister chooses not to leave her children. You've chosen differently. Neither is a bad or a dangerous choice.

It sounds like you lack the self confidence to believe in yourself and your own choice.

Pinknotpurple · 12/08/2024 12:25

Wow, how on earth does she think her 18 year old will become an independent, useful member of society?

This is her being strange. Have a lovely holiday.

JudgeJ · 12/08/2024 12:26

itsmylife7 · 12/08/2024 12:22

I'd say your sister has "anxiety " she's never left her 18 Yr old alone.

Your plan sounds brilliant don't let her spoil your cruise

I am constantly amazed on MN as how much people discuss with others! I double I've ever discussed anything with anyone not directly concerned and am probably the better for it.

Fernticket · 12/08/2024 12:27

You are leaving your DS, in his own home with 2 siblings who are adults and more than capable of looking after him. As you have stated, he needs his routine and also you might get fined if you took him out of school. Go and enjoy your cruise 🙂. Your DS will be fine, I think the arrangement you have put in place is really good.

JudgeJ · 12/08/2024 12:27

JudgeJ · 12/08/2024 12:26

I am constantly amazed on MN as how much people discuss with others! I double I've ever discussed anything with anyone not directly concerned and am probably the better for it.

'doubt' not 'double'

MoveOnTheCards · 12/08/2024 12:28

This sounds like the kind of bullshit my SIL pulls. It used to really get to me and make me feel like a shit parent until I realised I didn’t actually care what she thought as long as the decisions I made (with DH) made sense for us as a family.

Please don’t let her views and judgements cloud your own decisions. Your son will be with his siblings, who you say are perfectly capable of taking care of him.

Go and enjoy yourself! Congratulations on winning a fab prize!

MonsteraMama · 12/08/2024 12:29

Your sister is setting her 18yo up for a world of problems being so fecking clingy. It's not normal to be that attached to your adult child. I can already envision the posts on here from his future spouse complaining about the overbearing and clingy MIL...

If your 13yo is happy and his siblings are happy, go and enjoy your cruise. Have a wonderful time. You are doing nothing wrong and are not a shit parent at all.

Hecatoncheires · 12/08/2024 12:32

I'm not one to jump to the envy card, but I reckon your sister has a touch of the green-eyed monster about your fantastic cruise win. Your youngest son will have a great time with his siblings and it will be a bonding experience. Whilst you and your DH have fun on your cruise and come back re-energised for family life. Heck, OP, I'm envious!! 😆

Do not let your sister doubt your perfectly thoughtful and sensible choices. Hope you have the very best time on your holiday.

RachM84 · 12/08/2024 12:40

You’re right @redskydarknight i do lack self confidence and I question my choices all the time. This I think has stemmed from my childhood (don’t want to elaborate) and the fact I went undiagnosed autistic/adhd until I was in my late 30’s. I have been a parent all of my adult life and didn’t have any he opportunity to figure out who I am and have always let other people’s opinions to influence me. Since turning 40 last year I had a shift in my attitude and started to feel more confidence in my decisions without the need to explain them to people but occasionally (like today for example) I slip back into my old mindset and find myself worrying unnecessarily and start doubting myself.

OP posts:
Mobcap · 12/08/2024 12:47

Well, I’ve been leaving DS since he was a baby for periods of a week and more. It wouldn’t occur to me to take anyone else’s opinion into account.

alloalloallo · 12/08/2024 12:50

This sounds like the kind of bullshit my SIL pulls. It used to really get to me and make me feel like a shit parent until I realised I didn’t actually care what she thought as long as the decisions I made (with DH) made sense for us as a family.

I’ve got a SiL exactly the same. I stopped giving a shit about what she thought a long time ago.

I was never sure whether she wanted me to feel like shit, or to make herself feel better.

You’re happy with your decision so stick with it, don’t let her snidey comments put you off. Your son will be in his own home with his own siblings who are perfectly capable adults.

RachM84 · 12/08/2024 12:52

Thank you @Hecatoncheires If she is envious then she’s being silly as she could easily afford to go on a cruise herself if she wanted to where as it’ll take me and my dh a year just to save up the spends and extras in order to go.

OP posts:
Wouldhavebeenproficient · 12/08/2024 12:53

I feel sorry for her son if he's never been away to Scout camp or on a school trip or anything like that.

jannier · 12/08/2024 12:54

You know your kids.
Your sister is overprotective her son could be going abroad on his own or living in digs/uni

Enjoy your break

BobbyBiscuits · 12/08/2024 12:54

She's being really unhelpful. If she cares so much why doesn't she offer to stay at yours, or pop in at least a few times to make sure all is well?
You know your own adult kids, and that they are capable of minding the younger one.
It would be worse to force to poor lad on the cruise, and a waste of money. Plus he might spoil it for you if he was bored and moaning.
Just tell her you're very happy with the arrangement.
Her claiming she doesn't even leave her adult son alone ever makes her sound positively unhinged! Your poor nephew. Maybe you should ask him if he wants to stay at yours with your kids while youre away. Just to get away from her Draconian smothering!
I'm sure your sister would be delighted! Haha.

PotatoLeopard · 12/08/2024 13:00

itsmylife7 · 12/08/2024 12:22

I'd say your sister has "anxiety " she's never left her 18 Yr old alone.

Your plan sounds brilliant don't let her spoil your cruise

That’s a leap.
Up until this year I’ve never left my 18 year old either - because shock horror he has always wanted to come on holiday with us. Nothing to do with anxiety.
This year he’s gone with his girlfriend instead so he’ll stay here when we go away.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/08/2024 13:00

I would say its more of a shit parent whose 18 year old has never been away from them for more than a night

BBCLW · 12/08/2024 13:00

Maybe your sister was hoping you'd ask her to go with you instead, if your husband had to stay home with the kids.

HideousKinky · 12/08/2024 13:00

When my 3 DDs were 3, 6 & 9 I went on a 5-week trip to Australia - not work but something very important I felt I needed to do. DH was entirely supportive and looked after the DCs throughout - they were happy to be with Daddy, he was happy, all good.

But the comments I got! Most of them aimed at making me feel bad/guilty - my personal favourite was, "Oh I could never do that - I'd miss my kids too much" like I was some heartless bitch who clearly didn't give a shit about mine!

redalex261 · 12/08/2024 13:01

Who cares what she thinks? Who made her Queen Of All The Mummies? No-one? Good.

Your sister is a spiteful cow and is probably jealous you are getting a luxury free holiday while your teenage is well cared for in his own home. Go have fun.

PotatoLeopard · 12/08/2024 13:02

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/08/2024 13:00

I would say its more of a shit parent whose 18 year old has never been away from them for more than a night

Some kids like being with their families.
Personally I think it’s shitty parenting to spend nights away from your children before they have requested it.
OP your child has requested not to come and would rather be at home with adult siblings so that is fine.